Life Imprisonment And Its Meaning
Life imprisonment is a legal punishment where a person is sentenced to spend the remainder of their natural life in prison. Unlike the death penalty, it does not involve taking the life of the convict but entails incarceration for life.
Key Features:
It means imprisonment for the entire natural life of the convict.
The convict may or may not be eligible for parole, depending on the jurisdiction and case specifics.
It is considered the rarest and harshest punishment after the death penalty.
It is imposed in serious offenses like murder, terrorism, rape, or repeat offenders.
In some jurisdictions, life imprisonment may mean imprisonment for a fixed term (e.g., 14, 20, or 25 years), but traditionally, it means imprisonment for the entire life unless pardoned or released on parole.
Case Law on Life Imprisonment
1. M. Habeeb v. State of Kerala (1999)
Court: Supreme Court of India
Facts: Habeeb was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder.
Holding: The Supreme Court ruled that life imprisonment means imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life and cannot be reduced to a fixed term of years. The court emphasized that premature release can be granted only under exceptional circumstances and by competent authority.
Importance: This case clarified that life imprisonment is not equivalent to a 14 or 20-year sentence unless explicitly stated and that remission is a matter of executive discretion.
2. Sher Singh & Ors v. State of Punjab (1983)
Court: Supreme Court of India
Facts: Sher Singh was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment for murder.
Holding: The court stated that life imprisonment means imprisonment for the whole of the convict’s natural life, except if the sentence is commuted by the government or the convict is released on parole.
The court also held that the power to remit or commute life imprisonment rests with the government and not with the courts.
Importance: Reinforced the idea that life imprisonment is lifelong and that only executive authorities can grant remission or parole.
3. Karnail Singh v. State of Punjab (2009)
Court: Supreme Court of India
Facts: Karnail Singh was sentenced to life imprisonment and sought premature release after serving 14 years.
Holding: The Supreme Court ruled that life imprisonment means the convict must be kept in prison for life, but parole or remission can be granted on grounds of good behavior, health, or other exceptional reasons.
The court advised that the government should review each case individually and not grant blanket remissions.
Importance: This case emphasized balancing punishment with rehabilitation and humane treatment of prisoners.
4. Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980)
Court: Supreme Court of India
Facts: The case dealt with the constitutional validity of the death penalty and its alternatives, including life imprisonment.
Holding: The court held that the death penalty should be imposed only in the “rarest of rare” cases, and life imprisonment is a valid alternative punishment.
The court described life imprisonment as a serious punishment, meant for the rest of the convict’s natural life.
Importance: Set a landmark precedent on when to impose the death penalty versus life imprisonment and reinforced the seriousness of life imprisonment.
5. Swamy Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka (2008)
Court: Supreme Court of India
Facts: Swamy Shraddananda was convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Holding: The court reiterated that life imprisonment is a sentence for the whole life of the convict, subject to remission or pardon.
The judgment also highlighted that life imprisonment entails complete deprivation of liberty and is a severe punishment.
Importance: Affirmed that life imprisonment is not a fixed term sentence and reinforced executive power over remission.
Summary of Life Imprisonment Principles Based on Case Laws:
| Principle | Explanation | Case Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Life imprisonment means imprisonment for life | Convict must serve imprisonment for the rest of natural life. | Habeeb v. Kerala, Sher Singh |
| Remission and parole are executive powers | Only government can grant remission/parole, not courts. | Sher Singh, Karnail Singh |
| Life imprisonment is a severe punishment | It involves complete deprivation of liberty and is harsh. | Swamy Shraddananda, Bachan Singh |
| Death penalty imposed only in "rarest of rare" cases | Life imprisonment is an alternative to death penalty. | Bachan Singh |
| No fixed term unless specified | Life imprisonment is not equivalent to 14/20/25 years unless explicitly stated. | Habeeb v. Kerala |
RELATED Blog
0 comments