Domestic Violence Criminal Law Provisions
⚖️ Legal Framework for Domestic Violence in Afghanistan
1. Afghan Penal Code (2017)
Recognizes crimes such as assault, battery, threats, rape, and coercion — applicable in domestic settings.
No standalone law criminalizing “domestic violence,” but general provisions apply to abuse within the family.
2. Law on Elimination of Violence Against Women (EVAW, 2009)
Presidential decree (not ratified by Parliament) criminalizing 22 forms of violence against women, including:
Forced marriage
Child marriage
Physical violence
Verbal and psychological abuse
Deprivation of inheritance
Not consistently enforced across all provinces.
3. Sharia (Islamic Law)
Recognizes protection of life, dignity, and family rights, but interpretations vary.
Domestic violence may be treated as a private family matter unless it involves severe harm.
🧾 Detailed Case Explanations (6+ Cases)
1. Case: Physical Abuse by Husband
Facts: A woman suffered repeated beatings by her husband, resulting in hospitalization.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (Article 22 – beating), Penal Code provisions on intentional harm.
Court Ruling: The husband was sentenced to imprisonment and fined.
Significance: A rare example where the court applied EVAW effectively in protecting the wife.
2. Case: Verbal and Psychological Abuse
Facts: A wife accused her husband of constant threats, humiliation, and verbal abuse.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (psychological violence), no exact Penal Code article but linked to coercion laws.
Court Ruling: Case dismissed due to lack of physical evidence and cultural norms prioritizing family unity.
Significance: Shows limitations in handling non-physical forms of domestic abuse in Afghan courts.
3. Case: Forced Marriage of Minor
Facts: A 15-year-old girl was forced into marriage by her father.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (Article 26 – forced marriage, and child marriage provisions).
Court Ruling: The father was convicted, marriage annulled, and the cleric who officiated was fined.
Significance: Rare enforcement of child marriage laws; often ignored in rural areas due to custom.
4. Case: Murder in Domestic Context
Facts: A woman killed her abusive husband in self-defense after years of violence.
Law Applied: Penal Code (murder), defense claim under self-defense.
Court Ruling: Sentence reduced based on history of abuse; five years' imprisonment instead of life.
Significance: Shows court’s recognition of mitigating factors in domestic violence cases.
5. Case: Denial of Inheritance to Female Heirs
Facts: A widow and daughters were denied inheritance after husband’s death by male relatives.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (Article 36 – deprivation of inheritance), Sharia-based inheritance laws.
Court Ruling: Property divided according to Islamic inheritance rules; men forced to comply.
Significance: Illustrates use of both Sharia and EVAW for women's economic rights in family disputes.
6. Case: Domestic Violence Leading to Suicide
Facts: A teenage girl committed suicide after severe abuse by husband and in-laws.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (physical and mental abuse); Penal Code on causing suicide.
Court Ruling: Husband and mother-in-law charged with abuse; husband sentenced to 7 years.
Significance: Highlights the legal potential to treat psychological abuse as a serious criminal matter, but such rulings are rare.
7. Case: Dowry-Related Abuse
Facts: A wife was beaten and thrown out of her home for not bringing additional dowry.
Law Applied: EVAW Law (Article 27 – dowry abuse), Penal Code on threats and assault.
Court Ruling: Husband was fined and ordered to return the wife’s dowry.
Significance: Demonstrates how economic violence is being treated within Afghan criminal law.
📌 Summary Table
| Case Type | Law Applied | Outcome | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical Abuse | EVAW + Penal Code | Conviction | Enforcement of violence laws |
| Verbal Abuse | EVAW (psychological violence) | Dismissed | Weak evidence standards |
| Forced Marriage | EVAW (Articles 26–28) | Conviction + annulment | Rare success in child marriage cases |
| Murder in Abuse Context | Penal Code + self-defense | Reduced sentence | Abuse history considered legally |
| Inheritance Denial | EVAW + Sharia inheritance rules | Inheritance enforced | Legal blend of Sharia and EVAW |
| Suicide from Abuse | EVAW + Penal Code | Conviction of husband | Psychological abuse considered |
| Dowry Abuse | EVAW + Penal Code | Fines, return of dowry | Financial abuse recognized |
🧠 Key Takeaways
Afghan law provides some tools for criminal accountability in domestic violence cases, especially through the EVAW Law.
Enforcement is uneven, often depending on:
Region
Gender of the judge
Influence of local customs
Availability of legal aid
Physical violence is more likely to result in prosecution than emotional, psychological, or economic abuse.
Cultural resistance, fear of retaliation, and pressure to keep matters “within the family” still discourage many women from reporting abuse.
RELATED Blog
0 comments