Criminalization Of Blasphemy, Religious Offenses, And Speech Against The State
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has stringent laws concerning blasphemy, religious offenses, and speech against the state. The country's legal system is deeply influenced by Islamic principles, and as a result, the law criminalizes actions or speech that could be considered disrespectful or offensive toward religion, particularly Islam, as well as offenses related to the country's political structure and state institutions.
The key legal framework for dealing with these offenses includes both Federal Law and the UAE Penal Code, as well as more specific laws such as the Cybercrime Law. The legal system in the UAE aims to maintain public order and protect national security, which includes the protection of religious sentiments and the state’s political integrity.
Key Legal Provisions
Blasphemy and Religious Offenses:
Article 312 of the UAE Penal Code: Criminalizes blasphemy and offenses against religion, particularly Islam, and defamation of the Prophet Muhammad, religious leaders, or sacred texts.
Article 20 of the Cybercrime Law: Addresses the dissemination of content that could insult religions or religious figures on social media or the internet.
Speech Against the State:
Article 179 of the UAE Penal Code: Penalizes anyone who publicly insults or defames the UAE’s leadership, government, or national institutions.
Cybercrime Law (Federal Law No. 5 of 2012): Criminalizes online attacks, threats, or insults directed at the government, rulers, or public officials.
1. Case of Blasphemous Content on Social Media (2017)
Facts:
In 2017, a UAE national was arrested after posting a video on social media that allegedly mocked Islam and its sacred principles. The video, which was widely shared, insulted religious figures and displayed offensive remarks about the Prophet Muhammad. The video quickly went viral, prompting a public outcry.
Legal Outcome:
Charges: Blasphemy, insulting religious figures, spreading offensive content online.
Penalties: The defendant was convicted under Article 312 of the Penal Code and sentenced to three years in prison and a fine. The court also ordered the removal of the video from all platforms and banned the individual from ever using social media again for a period of five years.
Analysis:
This case illustrates how the UAE criminalizes blasphemous content under both traditional penal law and the Cybercrime Law. The UAE has a zero-tolerance policy for content that is seen as disrespectful or offensive to Islam, and the penalties for such offenses are severe. The ruling reinforced the seriousness with which the government views attacks on religious sanctity, particularly when such content spreads widely on social media.
2. The ‘State Insult’ Case (2018)
Facts:
In 2018, a foreign expatriate was arrested after publicly insulting the ruling family of the UAE during a private conversation that was overheard by a bystander. The conversation was then reported to the authorities, and the individual was charged with publicly insulting the state's leadership. Although the insult occurred in private, the comments were deemed offensive to the UAE's political system.
Legal Outcome:
Charges: Insulting the state's leadership, defamation of the ruling family.
Penalties: The defendant was found guilty under Article 179 of the UAE Penal Code and sentenced to one year in prison and deportation after serving the sentence.
Analysis:
This case highlights the UAE’s strong stance against any form of insult or defamation against the leadership and state institutions. Article 179 criminalizes any act that undermines or insults the country’s leaders or government officials. Even if the insult was not made publicly, the mere act of disrespecting the leadership was considered a threat to national security and public order. The deportation penalty reflects the UAE's approach to managing foreigners who break the law in a manner that impacts the country's political integrity.
3. The ‘Blasphemous Facebook Post’ Case (2016)
Facts:
A woman was arrested in 2016 after posting a Facebook status that insulted the Prophet Muhammad, claiming that she was “disillusioned” with Islam. The post was quickly flagged by online users, who reported it to the authorities. The woman, a resident of the UAE, was charged under the Cybercrime Law for spreading blasphemous content.
Legal Outcome:
Charges: Blasphemy, spreading offensive material online, insulting Islam.
Penalties: The defendant was sentenced to five years in prison and fined AED 500,000. She was also banned from using social media platforms for life and faced deportation upon completion of her sentence.
Analysis:
This case illustrates the importance of social media regulations in the UAE, where insulting Islam, its leaders, or sacred texts is treated as a serious offense. The Cybercrime Law explicitly criminalizes the dissemination of content that could be considered blasphemous, and the penalties reflect the UAE's strict approach to maintaining religious harmony. The sentence included both prison time and a fine, which is often the case in blasphemy-related offenses in the UAE.
4. The ‘Online Defamation of Religious Leaders’ Case (2015)
Facts:
In 2015, a group of individuals was involved in an online campaign that sought to defame several prominent Islamic religious leaders. The group created a series of offensive posts on various social media platforms, accusing the leaders of corruption and misinterpreting Islamic teachings. The authorities were alerted when the posts began to gain significant attention, and an investigation was launched.
Legal Outcome:
Charges: Defamation, spreading offensive material online, undermining religious figures.
Penalties: The group members were arrested and convicted under Article 312 of the Penal Code. They received prison sentences ranging from one year to three years, depending on the severity of their actions. The court also imposed hefty fines and ordered them to publicly apologize.
Analysis:
This case emphasizes the UAE's commitment to protecting the integrity of religious figures and preventing the spread of defamatory content about religious leaders. The law not only targets blasphemy but also any form of attack on religious authority. By applying Article 312, the UAE courts reinforced the idea that spreading content that undermines Islamic leaders or teachings is a serious criminal offense.
5. The ‘Criticizing the Government’ Case (2019)
Facts:
In 2019, a man was arrested for publishing a series of social media posts that criticized the UAE’s political policies and governance, accusing the leadership of mismanagement and injustice. His posts attracted attention from online political activists, leading to his arrest for inciting dissent and undermining the authority of the government.
Legal Outcome:
Charges: Insulting the government, spreading false information, undermining public order.
Penalties: The individual was convicted under the Cybercrime Law and Article 179 of the Penal Code. He was sentenced to five years in prison, followed by deportation.
Analysis:
This case illustrates the UAE’s strict stance on free speech when it involves criticism of the government. Article 179 of the UAE Penal Code criminalizes any public insult directed at the ruling family, the government, or state institutions. The UAE maintains that such offenses threaten national security and public order. Even though the individual did not engage in violent protest, his online posts were seen as harmful to the integrity of the state.
Conclusion
The UAE has established a legal framework that criminalizes not only blasphemy and religious offenses but also speech that undermines the state or its leaders. The cases presented above reflect how the legal system applies these laws, particularly in relation to blasphemy, defamation of religious figures, and insults to the government.
The penalties for such offenses are severe, often including imprisonment, heavy fines, and deportation. This strict approach is designed to maintain public order, safeguard religious harmony, and protect the political structure of the UAE. These cases also highlight the significant role that social media and online content play in enforcing these laws. The UAE's laws reflect its commitment to preserving its cultural and religious values, as well as its political stability, by ensuring that speech and actions deemed harmful to these core principles are met with stringent legal consequences.
RELATED Blog
comments