Criminal Law Portugal
Criminal Law in Portugal
Portugal’s criminal law system is based on the Civil Law tradition, which is influenced by Roman law and the Code Napoleon. The primary source of criminal law in Portugal is the Portuguese Penal Code (Código Penal), which defines criminal offenses and sets out punishments for those offenses. The criminal justice system in Portugal emphasizes individual rights, due process, and proportionality in sentencing.
1. Sources of Criminal Law in Portugal
Portuguese Penal Code (Código Penal): The Penal Code is the primary source of criminal law in Portugal, establishing the types of crimes and corresponding punishments. It was last revised in 1982 and has been amended several times since then. The Penal Code is divided into two parts: General Part, which covers the definition of crimes, principles of liability, and punishment; and the Special Part, which specifies the individual crimes.
Criminal Procedure Code (Código de Processo Penal): This code governs the criminal justice process in Portugal, outlining how criminal cases are investigated, prosecuted, and adjudicated. It regulates police investigations, the role of the Public Prosecutor, trials, and appeals.
Constitution of Portugal: The Portuguese Constitution guarantees fundamental rights and freedoms, which include protections against arbitrary detention, the right to a fair trial, and the presumption of innocence. These rights are applicable in criminal law matters, and all criminal proceedings must comply with constitutional principles.
Special Laws: In addition to the Penal Code, there are several special laws in Portugal that deal with specific crimes, such as drug offenses, terrorism, cybercrime, and domestic violence. For example, Law No. 5/2008 addresses violence against women, and Law No. 30/2000 deals with terrorism-related offenses.
2. Types of Crimes Under Portuguese Criminal Law
a. Crimes Against Persons
Murder (Article 132 Código Penal): Murder is the unlawful killing of another person, with the intent to cause death or grievous bodily harm. The penalty for murder is typically imprisonment, with the possibility of life imprisonment in particularly serious cases.
Manslaughter (Article 135 Código Penal): Manslaughter involves the unlawful killing of another person without malice aforethought, often due to sudden quarrels, provocation, or emotional stress. The penalty is less severe than for murder but still includes prison sentences.
Assault and Battery (Articles 143-145 Código Penal): Assault is intentionally causing physical harm to another person. The severity of the penalty depends on the nature and extent of the injury caused, and whether aggravating factors, such as the use of a weapon, are involved.
Sexual Offenses (Articles 163-172 Código Penal): Portugal has strict laws regarding sexual offenses, including rape, sexual assault, and sexual harassment. Rape involves non-consensual sexual intercourse and is punishable by significant prison terms. Sexual harassment and abuse of minors also carry severe penalties.
Kidnapping (Article 160 Código Penal): Kidnapping involves the unlawful detention or abduction of another person, typically for ransom or other illegal purposes. Penalties for kidnapping can include long-term imprisonment, especially when the victim is harmed or held for a prolonged period.
b. Crimes Against Property
Theft (Article 203 Código Penal): Theft is the unlawful taking of property with the intent to permanently deprive the owner of it. The severity of the offense is determined by factors such as the value of the property and whether the theft involved any aggravating circumstances like breaking into a home (burglary).
Robbery (Article 210 Código Penal): Robbery involves taking property by force or threat of force. If weapons are used or violence is involved, the penalty is more severe. Armed robbery may result in a sentence of several years in prison.
Fraud (Article 217 Código Penal): Fraud includes crimes like embezzlement, money laundering, or misrepresentation for financial gain. The penalties for fraud vary based on the amount of money involved and the complexity of the crime.
Arson (Article 286 Código Penal): Arson is the intentional setting of a fire, which can result in damage to property or even cause injuries or death. Penalties for arson vary depending on the damage caused, and in serious cases, they can include long-term imprisonment.
c. Drug Offenses
Drug Trafficking and Possession (Law No. 30/2000): Portugal has a relatively progressive approach to drug use. Drug trafficking is a serious criminal offense, carrying long prison sentences. Possession of drugs for personal use was decriminalized in 2001, meaning it is no longer a criminal offense unless the quantity exceeds the amount for personal use or is part of trafficking activities. However, individuals caught with small amounts may face administrative sanctions, such as fines or treatment programs.
Drug Manufacturing and Distribution: Producing or distributing illegal substances remains a serious crime, punishable by imprisonment. Large-scale operations or the involvement of minors results in more severe sentences.
d. Crimes Against Public Order and National Security
Terrorism (Law No. 30/2000): Terrorism is a serious criminal offense in Portugal, with penalties of long-term imprisonment for individuals involved in acts that aim to cause widespread fear, destruction, or disruption of public order. The law also covers terrorist financing and the recruitment of individuals for terrorist activities.
Public Disorder (Article 325 Código Penal): Crimes such as riot, unlawful assembly, and violence against public authorities are punishable under the Penal Code. These offenses typically involve disruption of public order or law enforcement activities.
e. Environmental Crimes
- Environmental Protection Laws: Portugal has several laws addressing environmental offenses, including illegal activities like pollution, deforestation, and wildlife trafficking. Violations of these laws can result in significant fines or imprisonment, depending on the severity of the crime.
f. Economic Crimes
Money Laundering and Corruption (Law No. 83/2017): Money laundering and corruption are serious criminal offenses in Portugal. Laws target individuals who hide or disguise the origins of illicit gains, especially in the public sector. Penalties include heavy fines and long-term imprisonment.
Tax Evasion and Fraud (Article 105 Código Penal): Criminal activities related to tax evasion, such as underreporting income or falsely claiming deductions, are subject to criminal penalties, including imprisonment for more severe offenses.
3. Punishments and Sentencing under Portuguese Criminal Law
Imprisonment: Penalties for criminal offenses in Portugal range from short-term imprisonment (for minor offenses) to life imprisonment (for particularly serious crimes such as murder or terrorism). In general, the prison sentence should reflect the severity of the crime and any aggravating or mitigating factors.
Fines: Fines are imposed for less severe crimes or in addition to prison sentences. The amount of the fine depends on the offense and the defendant's financial situation.
Probation: For less severe crimes or first-time offenders, a court may impose probation or community service. Probation is often used as an alternative to prison for non-violent offenses.
Suspended Sentences: In some cases, a judge may impose a suspended sentence, meaning the defendant does not have to serve prison time unless they commit another offense during the suspension period.
Restitution: Courts may order the offender to compensate the victim for losses, such as in cases of fraud, theft, or property damage.
4. Criminal Procedure in Portugal
a. Investigation and Arrest
Police Investigation: The Public Security Police (PSP) and Judicial Police (PJ) are responsible for investigating criminal offenses. The Public Prosecutor’s Office plays a key role in initiating and directing criminal investigations.
Arrest: Arrests in Portugal must be based on probable cause or a court warrant, except in cases of flagrante delicto (when a crime is being committed at the time of the arrest). Pretrial detention may be ordered for serious crimes or where there is a risk of flight or obstruction of justice.
b. Trial Process
Adversarial System: Portugal follows an adversarial system in criminal trials, where the prosecution and defense present their arguments before a judge. The accused has the right to a defense attorney and is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Court of First Instance: Most criminal cases are tried in the district courts, with a judge hearing the evidence and making a determination. For more serious offenses, cases may be heard by criminal courts or in a panel with more than one judge.
Appeals: Defendants and the prosecution have the right to appeal decisions to higher courts. Appeals can challenge the facts, the application of the law, or the sentence imposed.
5. Recent Legal Reforms and Issues
Decriminalization of Drug Use: In 2001, Portugal decriminalized the possession of small amounts of drugs for personal use. This was part of a broader strategy to address drug addiction as a public health issue rather than a criminal justice issue. While drug trafficking remains a criminal offense, the decriminalization has been considered a success in reducing drug-related harm.
Cybercrime: With the rise of digital technology, the Cybercrime Law has been updated to address crimes such as online fraud, identity theft, and cyberbullying. Portugal is part of international conventions like the Budapest Convention to combat cybercrime globally.
Domestic Violence: Portugal has strengthened its laws surrounding domestic violence. The Law on Domestic Violence includes strict penalties for offenses and provides measures of protection for victims, including restraining orders and support services.
Conclusion
Portugal’s criminal law system is grounded in the Revised Penal Code, with specific laws targeting a wide range of offenses, from traditional crimes like theft and murder to modern challenges such as cybercrime and drug-related offenses. The legal system emphasizes individual rights, due process, and proportionality in punishment, ensuring that those accused of crimes have access to a fair trial and appropriate legal representation.
RELATED Blog
0 comments