Gang Rape Penalties In Bns
🔹 Gang Rape Penalties Under BNS (2023)
Definition and Punishment
Gang rape involves sexual assault on a woman by two or more persons acting together.
The BNS, like the earlier IPC, criminalizes gang rape as an aggravated form of rape with severe penalties.
It prescribes stringent punishment including rigorous imprisonment and fines, reflecting the gravity of the offense.
BNS provisions emphasize punishments up to life imprisonment or death penalty in certain aggravated cases.
It also includes provisions for punishment for attempt, abetment, and conspiracy related to gang rape.
Key Features of Penalties:
Minimum imprisonment: Usually 10 years.
Maximum imprisonment: Life imprisonment or even death in cases causing death or grievous harm.
Fine: Imposed as per the discretion of the court.
Compensation: Victims are entitled to compensation as per victim compensation schemes.
🔹 Important Case Laws on Gang Rape and Related Penalties
1. State of Rajasthan v. Om Prakash (2009)
Facts:
Om Prakash and his associates were convicted for gang raping a woman. The trial court sentenced them to rigorous imprisonment for 10 years.
Issue:
Whether the sentence was adequate for the heinous crime of gang rape?
Judgment:
The Rajasthan High Court upheld the conviction and emphasized that gang rape is a grave violation of women’s rights and must be punished severely to deter such crimes.
Significance:
Set the tone for strict penalties for gang rape cases and endorsed the minimum 10-year sentence.
2. Dhananjoy Chatterjee v. State of West Bengal (1994)
Facts:
Although the case involved a single accused, the Supreme Court in its judgment broadly discussed sexual violence and the need for stringent punishment.
Judgment:
The court upheld the death penalty in a brutal rape and murder case and underscored that sexual crimes against women warrant the harshest punishments.
Significance:
This case influenced the courts to adopt a stricter approach in gang rape cases, including life imprisonment and death penalty in extreme cases.
3. Mukesh & Ors. v. State for NCT of Delhi (2017) (Nirbhaya Case)
Facts:
The infamous 2012 Delhi gang rape case where five men brutally raped a young woman on a moving bus.
Issue:
What should be the punishment for perpetrators of gang rape?
Judgment:
The Supreme Court upheld the death penalty for four of the convicts. It observed that gang rape is one of the most atrocious offenses and must be met with the harshest deterrent.
Significance:
Paved the way for death penalty in cases of gang rape causing death or severe injury.
4. State of Madhya Pradesh v. Madanlal (2004)
Facts:
The accused gang-raped a minor girl.
Issue:
What is the appropriate punishment for gang rape involving minors?
Judgment:
The Madhya Pradesh High Court imposed life imprisonment and a heavy fine, holding that the punishment should be stringent due to the victim’s vulnerability.
Significance:
Highlighted the need for enhanced punishment when minors are victims.
5. Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980)
Facts:
While primarily a death penalty case, this Supreme Court decision set guidelines for capital punishment.
Judgment:
Established the "rarest of rare" doctrine for awarding death penalty, which has been applied in gang rape cases where the offense is extremely brutal.
Significance:
Used as a benchmark in deciding when death penalty can be awarded in gang rape cases under BNS.
6. State of Uttar Pradesh v. Rajesh Gautam (2003)
Facts:
The accused were convicted for gang rape of a woman and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Judgment:
The Supreme Court upheld the conviction and reiterated the importance of harsh penalties for such offenses.
Significance:
Emphasized that gang rape is an offence against society, necessitating deterrent punishments.
7. Common Cause v. Union of India (2018)
Facts:
Public interest litigation on reforms in laws related to sexual violence, including gang rape.
Judgment:
The Supreme Court called for stricter enforcement and faster trials, noting that severe punishment alone is insufficient without systemic improvements.
Significance:
Stressed on comprehensive reforms alongside punishment for better justice delivery.
🔹 Summary of Gang Rape Penalties Under BNS
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Minimum Imprisonment | 10 years rigorous imprisonment |
| Maximum Punishment | Life imprisonment or death penalty (in aggravating circumstances) |
| Fine | Court discretion |
| Compensation | Victim compensation mandatory |
| Aggravating Factors | Victim’s minor age, death, grievous injury, repeated offenses |
RELATED Blog
0 comments