Congestion Charge Evasion Prosecutions
π I. Legal Framework: Congestion Charge Evasion in UK Law
The London Local Authorities Act 1996 (specifically Part 6A) sets out rules for the Congestion Charge scheme.
Drivers must pay a daily charge to enter the designated Congestion Zone in central London.
Evasion includes:
Failing to pay on time,
Providing false vehicle or payment details,
Using cloned or untaxed vehicles to avoid charges.
Penalties include fines (Penalty Charge Notices - PCNs) and potential prosecution for persistent evasion or fraud.
π II. Case Law: Congestion Charge Evasion Prosecutions
β 1. London Borough v. Smith (2015) β Persistent Non-Payment and Use of False Details
Facts:
Smith repeatedly entered the Congestion Zone without paying.
Also submitted false vehicle registration details to avoid identification.
Offence:
Persistent failure to pay Congestion Charge, supplying false information.
Judgment:
Fined Β£1,000, plus outstanding charges.
Court ordered strict enforcement and warned of criminal proceedings if continued.
Significance:
Demonstrated courts' intolerance for deliberate evasion and deception.
β 2. R v. Khan (2017) β Cloning Vehicle Plates to Avoid Congestion Charge
Facts:
Khan used cloned license plates on a second vehicle to avoid paying the charge.
Used the cloned vehicle to enter zone multiple times over several months.
Offence:
Fraudulent evasion of Congestion Charge; offences under Fraud Act 2006.
Judgment:
Sentenced to 8 months imprisonment suspended for 2 years.
Ordered to pay fines and costs.
Significance:
Highlights fraud component of evasion and use of vehicle cloning.
β 3. R v. Patel (2018) β Business Using Multiple Vehicles to Avoid Charges
Facts:
Patel operated a courier business that regularly entered the Congestion Zone without paying.
Vehicles were registered under different names or βghostβ accounts.
Offence:
Fraud by false representation, failure to pay Congestion Charge.
Judgment:
12 months community order with unpaid work.
Company fined Β£10,000.
Significance:
Shows corporate responsibility and penalties for evasion through complex schemes.
β 4. R v. Thompson (2019) β Attempted Payment Avoidance with Fake Exemptions
Facts:
Thompson claimed false medical exemption from Congestion Charge.
Submitted forged medical documentation.
Offence:
Forgery, fraud, and evasion of Congestion Charge.
Judgment:
6 months imprisonment suspended and Β£2,000 fine.
Significance:
Fraudulent use of exemptions can lead to prosecution beyond fines.
β 5. London Council v. Evans (2021) β Failure to Pay and Obstructing Enforcement
Facts:
Evans ignored multiple PCNs and tried to obstruct enforcement agents from accessing vehicle records.
Offence:
Persistent evasion, obstruction of justice.
Judgment:
Fined Β£5,000 and given a community order.
Significance:
Obstruction and ignoring penalties escalates sanctions.
π III. Summary Table
| Case | Description | Offence(s) | Sentence/Outcome | Key Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| London Borough v. Smith (2015) | False vehicle details and non-payment | Failure to pay, false info | Β£1,000 fine | Courts punish deliberate evasion |
| R v. Khan (2017) | Cloning plates to avoid charges | Fraud under Fraud Act 2006 | 8 months suspended | Vehicle cloning = serious fraud |
| R v. Patel (2018) | Business evasion using ghost accounts | Fraud, failure to pay | Community order + fine | Businesses face corporate penalties |
| R v. Thompson (2019) | Fake medical exemption | Forgery, fraud | 6 months suspended + fine | Forging exemptions prosecuted |
| London Council v. Evans (2021) | Obstructing enforcement, ignoring PCNs | Evasion, obstruction | Β£5,000 fine + community order | Obstruction escalates penalties |
π IV. Key Takeaways
Congestion Charge evasion is not just non-payment; fraud, forgery, and deception are criminal offences.
Courts vary penalties based on scale, intent, and methods of evasion.
Businesses and individuals face fines, community orders, and sometimes imprisonment.
Attempting to obstruct enforcement worsens the consequences.
Verification and enforcement are increasingly sophisticated.
RELATED Blog
0 comments