Role Of Dna Evidence In Solving Cold Cases
DNA evidence has revolutionized criminal investigations, especially in cold cases—unsolved crimes that linger for years or even decades. DNA allows law enforcement to:
Identify perpetrators long after the crime occurred
Exonerate the innocent
Link multiple crimes to a single offender
Overcome limitations of witness testimony or circumstantial evidence
1. People v. Richard Buckner (1983 / 1990s)
Background
Richard Buckner was accused of murder in California in the early 1980s.
At the time, DNA testing was not available.
Investigation
The case went cold for over 10 years.
Blood samples preserved at the crime lab were re-tested in the 1990s using PCR-based DNA testing.
Role of DNA Evidence
DNA from the crime scene was matched to Buckner.
Exonerated a previously convicted suspect who had been jailed based on eyewitness testimony.
Outcome
Buckner was convicted of murder.
Established the principle that cold cases could be reopened and solved decades later using DNA.
Legal Significance
Courts recognized that DNA evidence is reliable even years after collection, provided proper chain-of-custody is maintained.
2. The Green River Killer – Gary Ridgway (Washington, 2001)
Background
The Green River Killer committed multiple murders of women in the 1980s.
Investigation stalled for nearly 20 years.
DNA Breakthrough
Preserved biological samples from victims were re-analyzed using modern DNA profiling.
DNA matched Gary Ridgway’s saliva from prior convictions.
Outcome
Ridgway confessed to 49 murders, later admitted to 71.
Sentenced to life imprisonment without parole.
Significance
First major example in the U.S. of decades-old cold cases solved primarily through DNA.
Demonstrated how DNA evidence could link multiple crimes to one serial offender.
3. The Night Stalker – Richard Ramirez (California, 1985 / 1989)
Background
Ramirez was suspected of multiple homicides and sexual assaults.
Some evidence was preserved, including biological traces from victims.
DNA Role
During trial and appeals, DNA testing confirmed his presence at several crime scenes.
Allowed prosecutors to corroborate eyewitness accounts.
Outcome
Convicted of 13 counts of murder and 30+ counts of other crimes.
Sentenced to death (later died in prison).
Legal Significance
Highlighted that DNA evidence can bolster circumstantial and eyewitness evidence, reducing the chance of wrongful conviction in complex serial crimes.
4. People v. Wayne Williams – Atlanta Child Murders (1979–1981)
Background
Multiple child murders in Atlanta went unsolved for years.
Wayne Williams was suspected but initially could not be conclusively linked to all murders.
DNA Breakthrough
Years later, preserved fibers and hair samples were analyzed using mitochondrial DNA testing.
DNA matched Williams’ biological samples, confirming links to at least some victims.
Outcome
Williams was convicted of two adult murders, suspected in at least 20 child murders.
DNA strengthened the historical case against him.
Significance
Early example of using DNA to retrospectively strengthen cold case evidence.
Demonstrated the utility of mitochondrial DNA when nuclear DNA is degraded.
5. The Grim Sleeper – Lonnie Franklin Jr. (Los Angeles, 2007 / DNA breakthrough 2010s)
Background
Franklin murdered women in Los Angeles over 25+ years.
Case went cold due to lack of evidence.
DNA Evidence
Investigators used familial DNA searching: partial DNA match led to Franklin’s son.
Confirmatory testing connected Franklin to multiple decades-old murders.
Outcome
Franklin convicted of 10 murders in 2016.
Sentenced to death.
Significance
Landmark case for familial DNA searching in cold cases.
Demonstrated that DNA databases can extend investigative reach to relatives of suspects.
6. The Golden State Killer – Joseph James DeAngelo (California, 1974–1986 / Arrest 2018)
Background
DeAngelo committed 13 murders, 50+ rapes, and burglaries.
Case remained unsolved for decades.
DNA Breakthrough
Investigators used genetic genealogy: DNA uploaded to public genealogy databases identified distant relatives.
Narrowed down suspects to DeAngelo, confirmed by direct DNA match.
Outcome
DeAngelo pled guilty in 2020 to avoid death penalty.
Sentenced to life without parole.
Significance
Revolutionized cold case investigations using DNA combined with genealogy.
Expanded the legal and ethical debate on public DNA databases in law enforcement.
7. Ted Bundy Cold Case Reinvestigations
Background
Bundy was executed in 1989, but many cases remained unresolved.
Preserved biological samples were later re-examined.
Role of DNA Evidence
Cold cases were definitively linked to Bundy via DNA from semen stains.
Helped close unsolved sexual assault and murder cases from the 1970s.
Significance
Showed that even posthumous DNA testing can bring closure to victims’ families.
DNA evidence can correct or confirm historical convictions.
Key Roles of DNA Evidence in Cold Cases
Identification of Unknown Suspects
Even when suspects were never previously in the system.
Linking Multiple Crimes to a Single Perpetrator
Serial cases like Green River Killer and Grim Sleeper.
Exoneration of Wrongfully Convicted Individuals
Buckner case demonstrates the power to correct miscarriages of justice.
Familial and Genetic Genealogy
Helps identify suspects indirectly through relatives (Golden State Killer).
Posthumous Identification and Closure
Bundy cases show families can get answers decades later.
Admissibility in Court
DNA evidence is highly persuasive when chain-of-custody and testing protocols are followed.
Conclusion
DNA evidence has fundamentally transformed cold case investigations. Its applications include:
Solving decades-old crimes
Strengthening circumstantial evidence
Exonerating the innocent
Innovative techniques like familial searching and genealogy
Case law has repeatedly confirmed: DNA evidence is reliable, admissible, and capable of achieving justice, even decades after the crime occurred.
RELATED Blog
0 comments