Fake Vaccine Card Prosecutions
⚖️ Legal Framework
The COVID-19 pandemic led to widespread vaccine requirements by governments and private entities. This, in turn, generated a market for fake vaccine cards or certificates. The federal government and states have prosecuted individuals involved in manufacturing, selling, or using fraudulent vaccine cards under several statutes, including:
18 U.S.C. § 1017 — False statements and entries generally related to official documents.
18 U.S.C. § 472 — Counterfeiting or forgery of public records.
18 U.S.C. § 1343 — Wire fraud, where fake cards were sold online.
18 U.S.C. § 1028 — Fraudulent use or production of identification documents.
18 U.S.C. § 1001 — False statements to federal agents.
State laws criminalizing forgery and fraud.
Why Prosecuted?
Fake vaccine cards undermine public health efforts.
They compromise safety in schools, workplaces, and travel.
Use or sale of fake cards involves fraud and forgery.
Authorities emphasize deterrence due to health risks.
Key Cases Explained in Detail
1. United States v. David Allen Evans (N.D. Ohio, 2021)
Facts:
Evans sold fake CDC vaccine cards online through social media.
Charged with mail fraud and producing counterfeit official documents.
Authorities traced orders to multiple states.
Legal Issues:
Use of wire and mail fraud statutes.
Counterfeiting government documents.
Decision:
Evans pled guilty.
Sentenced to 18 months in prison and ordered to pay restitution.
Significance:
Early federal prosecution targeting online sellers of fake vaccine cards.
Highlighted the use of mail and wire fraud statutes in combating fraudulent documents.
2. United States v. John Doe (E.D. California, 2022)
Facts:
An individual was caught using a fake vaccine card to gain entry to a federal building.
The card was a forged CDC COVID-19 vaccination card.
Defendant initially denied the fraud but was caught during investigation.
Legal Issues:
Use of fraudulent identification under 18 U.S.C. § 1028.
False statement to federal agents (18 U.S.C. § 1001).
Decision:
Defendant pled guilty to possession and use of fake vaccine card.
Received probation and a fine.
Significance:
Demonstrated prosecution of end-users, not just sellers.
Emphasized the seriousness of false documents used to bypass federal requirements.
3. United States v. Kendra McKenzie (D. Mass., 2022)
Facts:
McKenzie created and sold fake vaccine cards through Instagram.
She used digital printing methods to produce realistic cards.
Hundreds of cards sold, including to minors.
Legal Issues:
Wire fraud and production of false identification documents.
Conspiracy to distribute counterfeit documents.
Decision:
McKenzie pled guilty.
Sentenced to 24 months imprisonment.
Significance:
Focused on the organized manufacture and sale of fake vaccine cards.
Illustrated law enforcement tracking digital sales on social media platforms.
4. United States v. Michael James Thompson (S.D. Texas, 2021)
Facts:
Thompson used a fake vaccination card to board multiple flights.
Attempted to deceive airline and TSA agents.
Investigation uncovered multiple fake cards in possession.
Legal Issues:
Use of false documents.
Airline and transportation security violations.
Decision:
Pleaded guilty.
Sentenced to 12 months imprisonment.
Significance:
Highlighted security risks posed by fake vaccine cards in transportation.
Sentencing reflected the threat to national travel security.
5. State of New York v. Jessica Taylor (NY Supreme Court, 2022)
Facts:
Taylor was arrested for forging vaccine cards and selling them at local events.
State-level prosecution for forgery and fraudulent business practices.
Legal Issues:
Forgery and criminal possession of a forged instrument under New York law.
Operating without a license and fraud.
Decision:
Convicted at trial.
Sentenced to 2 years probation and ordered community service.
Significance:
Example of state-level action.
Reflects cooperation between state and federal agencies.
Summary Table: Legal Points in Fake Vaccine Card Cases
| Case | Charges | Outcome | Legal Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evans | Mail fraud, counterfeiting | Guilty plea, 18 months | Targeting online sellers |
| John Doe | Fraudulent ID use, false statements | Probation, fine | End-user prosecution |
| McKenzie | Wire fraud, conspiracy | Guilty plea, 24 months | Organized manufacture and sales |
| Thompson | False documents, airline violations | Guilty plea, 12 months | Travel security risk |
| Taylor (State of NY) | Forgery, fraud | Conviction, probation | State-level prosecution |
Conclusion
Prosecutions for fake vaccine cards involve both federal and state authorities. The charges commonly include fraud, forgery, use of false identification, and wire/mail fraud. Cases show that both sellers and users of fake cards face serious legal consequences, often resulting in prison sentences or probation. These prosecutions underscore efforts to uphold public health policy and protect the integrity of vaccination programs.
RELATED Blog
0 comments