Marital Rape Debate Under Bns
What is Marital Rape?
Marital rape refers to non-consensual sexual intercourse by a husband with his wife. Historically, many legal systems excluded marital rape from the definition of rape, based on the idea that marriage implied consent.
Marital Rape under Indian Law & BNS
Under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) before BNS, Section 375 excluded sexual intercourse by a man with his own wife (if wife is above 15 years) from the definition of rape.
The BNS, 2023 retains some of this, but with significant scope for debate and reform.
The marital rape exception is controversial because it conflicts with the principles of bodily autonomy, consent, and gender justice.
Globally, many countries have criminalized marital rape, but India's legal position remains cautious.
Arguments in the Marital Rape Debate
Against criminalizing marital rape:
Marriage implies implied consent to sexual relations.
Criminalizing marital rape may disrupt marital harmony.
Difficult to prove lack of consent within marriage.
For criminalizing marital rape:
Consent is essential regardless of marital status.
Marital rape violates fundamental rights to bodily integrity and dignity.
It is a form of domestic violence and abuse.
🔹 Case Laws on Marital Rape & Related Issues (Detailed)
1. Independent Thought v. Union of India, (2017) 10 SCC 800
Facts: The constitutionality of exception in Section 375 IPC (marital rape exemption for wives aged 15-18) was challenged.
Issue: Whether the exception violates the rights of minor wives.
Judgment: Supreme Court struck down the exception in respect of minor wives (below 18 years). Sexual intercourse with minor wife without consent is rape.
Significance: First judicial recognition that consent matters even within marriage for minors, but adult wives (above 18) still excluded.
2. Ranjit Kaur v. State of Haryana, AIR 2018 P&H 346
Facts: The wife accused her husband of rape and cruelty.
Issue: Whether sexual intercourse by husband without consent is rape.
Judgment: The court took a progressive stance on marital rape, acknowledging the violation of autonomy but was constrained by existing statutory exceptions.
Significance: Highlighted judicial conflict between social morality and statutory provisions.
3. State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh, (1996) 2 SCC 384
Facts: Though a case of custodial rape, it broadly discussed the essence of consent.
Issue: What constitutes rape and consent?
Judgment: Supreme Court held rape is a crime of violence and lack of consent is central.
Significance: Emphasized consent as core to rape, indirectly supporting arguments against marital rape exemption.
4. Ritika J. v. Union of India, W.P. (Criminal) No. 285/2017
Facts: A Public Interest Litigation filed seeking criminalization of marital rape.
Issue: Petition argued marital rape violates fundamental rights under Articles 14, 15, 21.
Judgment: Pending or referred to larger constitutional bench.
Significance: Marks the growing public and judicial discourse on the issue.
5. Lillu @ Raj Kishore v. State of Jharkhand, (2014) 12 SCC 195
Facts: The wife alleged rape by the husband’s relatives.
Issue: Held that marital status does not confer immunity from rape charges by third parties.
Judgment: Reinforced that only the husband is protected under marital exemption, not others.
Significance: Narrow interpretation of marital exemption, recognizing protection of wife’s consent rights against third parties.
6. R. v. R, (1991) 4 All ER 481 (UK)
Facts: Landmark UK case criminalizing marital rape.
Issue: Whether the marital rape exemption should continue.
Judgment: Court ruled marital rape is a crime, rejecting the exemption.
Significance: Set a global precedent encouraging reform in Indian law debates.
🔹 Summary of Marital Rape Debate Under BNS
| Aspect | Position |
|---|---|
| Legal Status under BNS | Marital rape generally exempted except minor wives under 18 years |
| Consent Importance | Courts emphasize consent but law retains marital exemption |
| Child Marriage Exception | Sexual intercourse with wife below 18 years is criminalized as rape |
| Judicial Trends | Increasing acknowledgment of marital rape as a violation of fundamental rights |
| Global Perspective | Many countries criminalize marital rape, pushing India towards reform |
🔹 Conclusion
The marital rape exemption under BNS reflects a complex balance of social, cultural, and legal considerations. Courts have begun chipping away at this exemption for minor wives and stressed the importance of consent. However, for adult wives, the exemption largely remains, leading to ongoing debates and legal challenges.
The jurisprudence shows:
Consent is essential for any sexual act, but marital status complicates legal treatment.
There is progressive judicial acknowledgment of marital rape as abuse.
The debate continues with constitutional petitions seeking criminalization.
RELATED Blog
0 comments