Section 189 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023
Section 189 — Obstruction of Lawful Orders by Public Servants
1. Purpose of Section 189
Section 189 of the BNS, 2023 is intended to punish individuals who obstruct, hinder, or prevent public servants from carrying out lawful duties.
The main goal is to ensure the effective enforcement of laws and lawful orders.
It protects public servants performing duties related to public safety, health, administration, or law enforcement.
It is a complement to Section 188, which deals with general disobedience of lawful orders, whereas Section 189 specifically targets active obstruction.
2. Legal Meaning
Under Section 189:
A person is liable if they knowingly obstruct or prevent a public servant from executing a lawful order or duty, in a way that:
Hinders the performance of their work, or
Creates danger to life, property, health, or public order.
Key points:
The obstruction can be physical, verbal, or procedural.
The public servant must be acting within the scope of their lawful authority.
Even indirect interference, such as inciting others to obstruct, falls under this section.
3. Elements of the Offence
To prove a violation of Section 189, the following elements must exist:
Lawful Order or Duty
The public servant must be executing a lawful act authorized by law.
Knowledge and Intent
The person obstructing must know the order is lawful and intentionally act to hinder it.
Obstruction or Hindrance
This can include:
Blocking access physically
Threatening or intimidating the public servant
Refusing to allow lawful action to proceed
Encouraging others to obstruct
Result (Optional for Liability)
Even if no harm occurs, obstruction is punishable.
If the obstruction endangers life, health, or property, penalties are increased.
4. Punishment Under Section 189
Imprisonment: Up to 1 year for general obstruction
Fine: Monetary penalty may also be imposed
Enhanced Penalty: If obstruction causes danger to life, property, or health, imprisonment can increase up to 2 years and fine.
This is a cognizable offence, so law enforcement can take immediate action.
5. Practical Examples
Example 1: Firefighter Obstruction
Firefighters arrive to extinguish a fire.
Residents block their vehicles and refuse access.
Section 189 applies because the obstruction prevents lawful emergency duties.
Example 2: Municipal Officers
Municipal officers attempt to seal an illegal construction.
Builder physically blocks access and intimidates officials.
Section 189 is invoked.
Example 3: Health Emergency
Health authorities attempt to enforce quarantine during a contagious outbreak.
Individuals prevent officials from entering homes.
Section 189 applies, as the obstruction endangers public health.
Example 4: Traffic or Public Safety Orders
Police issue a lawful order to clear a blocked road.
Drivers refuse to comply and actively block enforcement.
Liability arises under Section 189.
6. Important Points
Active Obstruction Required: Mere disobedience without hindering the official act may fall under Section 188, not 189.
Lawful Duty: Only acts interfering with lawful duties of public servants are covered.
Forms of Obstruction: Can be physical, verbal, procedural, or indirect.
Cognizable Offence: Police may take immediate action without prior court approval.
7. Summary Table
| Aspect | Section 189 BNS, 2023 |
|---|---|
| Purpose | Protect public servants performing lawful duties from obstruction |
| Who is liable | Anyone who intentionally obstructs or hinders a public servant |
| Core Elements | Lawful order, knowledge, intentional obstruction |
| Punishment | Up to 1 year imprisonment (up to 2 years if danger results) and/or fine |
| Practical Significance | Ensures enforcement of public safety, law, and administrative orders |
RELATED Blog
comments