Access To Justice For Female Victims Of Crime In Afghanistan
🔷 Access to Justice for Female Victims in Afghanistan
✅ Context and Challenges
Afghanistan’s patriarchal society and ongoing conflict severely limit women’s access to justice.
Cultural norms, insecurity, illiteracy, and weak law enforcement compound these challenges.
Female victims of crimes like domestic violence, honor killings, sexual assault, and forced marriage face stigma and threats.
The justice system is often inaccessible or hostile due to lack of female judges, lawyers, and fear of reprisals.
🔷 Legal Framework
Afghan Penal Code (2004) criminalizes acts like rape, violence, and forced marriage.
Law on Elimination of Violence Against Women (EVAW) 2009 provides specific protections.
Constitution guarantees equality and the right to a fair trial but enforcement is weak.
Sharia-based traditional justice (jirgas) often contradicts formal laws.
🔷 Case Law Examples
📍 Case 1: Rape Victim Denied Justice (2017, Kabul)
Facts: A woman reported rape by a powerful local official.
Barriers: Police initially refused to register the complaint due to social pressure.
Legal Process: Case taken up by EVAW courts after NGO intervention.
Outcome: Perpetrator sentenced, but victim faced community ostracism.
Significance: Shows formal legal pathways exist but social barriers remain high.
📍 Case 2: Forced Marriage Challenge (2018, Herat)
Scenario: Teenage girl forced into marriage by family against her will.
Legal Action: Girl petitioned EVAW unit; legal challenge filed citing Penal Code.
Court Decision: Marriage annulled; family warned.
Implication: Demonstrates legal recognition of consent and protection under Afghan law, but rare and reliant on external support.
📍 Case 3: Domestic Violence and Lack of Police Support (2019, Nangarhar)
Case: Woman repeatedly abused by husband; police refused shelter or arrest.
Judicial Role: EVAW courts intervened after media coverage.
Result: Temporary protection order issued; husband penalized.
Analysis: Reflects gap between law and enforcement; role of public pressure critical.
📍 Case 4: Honor Killing Investigation (2020, Kandahar)
Incident: Woman murdered by male relatives for alleged "family dishonor."
Legal Proceedings: Slow investigation; jirga pressure to avoid prosecution.
Court Action: Despite intimidation, judge sentenced perpetrators.
Importance: Rare example of judiciary upholding law against tribal customs.
📍 Case 5: Sexual Harassment in Workplace (2021, Kabul)
Facts: Female employee harassed by supervisor; fear of retaliation prevented reporting.
Legal Steps: NGO helped file complaint under Labor and Penal Code.
Outcome: Case ongoing; victim protected under EVAW.
Lesson: Highlights workplace harassment as emerging justice area for women.
🔷 Common Barriers Highlighted by Cases
| Barrier | Example | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Social stigma | Rape and honor killing cases | Victim isolation |
| Weak police response | Domestic violence cases | Lack of immediate protection |
| Tribal/jirga interference | Honor killing | Undermining formal justice |
| Fear of retaliation | Workplace harassment | Underreporting |
| Limited legal knowledge | Forced marriage | Reliance on NGOs |
🔷 Steps to Improve Access
Increase female judges, prosecutors, and police officers.
Train law enforcement on women’s rights and EVAW law.
Strengthen witness protection and victim support services.
Improve public awareness of women’s legal rights.
Enhance coordination with NGOs and international bodies.
🔷 Summary
Afghan law formally provides mechanisms to protect female victims, especially through the EVAW law and Penal Code. However, entrenched social norms, weak enforcement, and threats limit real access. Case law shows some judicial courage but also systemic challenges.
RELATED Blog
0 comments