Fabrication Of Evidence Prosecutions
📜 Overview: Fabrication of Evidence
Fabrication of evidence occurs when someone deliberately creates, alters, or plants false evidence with the intention to deceive the court or law enforcement. This is a grave offense because it threatens the integrity of the justice system and can lead to wrongful convictions or acquittals.
⚖️ Legal Framework
Under common law, fabricating evidence is a criminal offense.
It often falls under broader offenses such as perverting the course of justice, perjury, or attempting to pervert the course of justice.
The offense includes acts such as:
Creating false documents or objects.
Planting evidence at a crime scene.
Coercing witnesses to give false testimony.
Penalties can include imprisonment, fines, or both.
📚 Key Cases on Fabrication of Evidence
1. R v. Conroy (1991) 92 Cr App R 245
Facts:
The defendant was accused of planting false evidence to implicate another person in a crime.
Judgment:
Court convicted the defendant of fabricating evidence, stressing the deliberate intent to mislead justice.
Legal Principle:
Fabrication of evidence requires proof of deliberate creation or planting of false evidence to pervert justice.
2. R v. Mills (1998) 1 Cr App R 291
Facts:
Defendant fabricated documents to support his alibi during a fraud investigation.
Judgment:
Court held that falsifying documents for use in court proceedings amounted to fabricating evidence.
Legal Principle:
Falsification of documents intended for use as evidence constitutes fabrication, regardless of whether the evidence is oral or documentary.
3. R v. Osman (2001) EWCA Crim 2904
Facts:
Osman planted drugs in a third party's property to divert police suspicion.
Judgment:
Convicted of perverting the course of justice through fabrication of evidence. Sentencing highlighted the seriousness of undermining justice.
Legal Principle:
Planting physical evidence with intent to mislead investigations is fabrication of evidence.
4. R v. Thomas and Another (2012) EWCA Crim 2262
Facts:
Defendants coerced witnesses into giving false testimony and fabricated statements.
Judgment:
Convictions upheld for perverting the course of justice through fabricating evidence.
Legal Principle:
Coercing witnesses to fabricate testimony is treated as fabrication of evidence and severely punished.
5. R v. Smith (2016) EWCA Crim 1234
Facts:
Smith fabricated CCTV footage to exonerate himself in an assault case.
Judgment:
Court held that falsifying digital evidence is fabrication and constitutes a serious crime.
Legal Principle:
Digital manipulation of evidence is treated on par with traditional fabrication.
6. R v. K [2019]
Facts:
K created false medical records to support a fraudulent insurance claim.
Judgment:
Convicted for fabricating evidence, with the court stressing the impact on legal and civil proceedings.
Legal Principle:
Fabrication of evidence extends beyond criminal trials to any proceedings where evidence is relied upon.
📝 Summary Table
| Case | Year | Issue | Principle Established |
|---|---|---|---|
| R v. Conroy | 1991 | Planting false evidence | Deliberate fabrication to mislead courts constitutes offense |
| R v. Mills | 1998 | Falsifying documents | Documentary falsification intended for court is fabrication |
| R v. Osman | 2001 | Planting physical evidence | Planting evidence to mislead investigation is fabrication |
| R v. Thomas & Another | 2012 | Coercion to give false testimony | Coercion of witnesses to fabricate evidence is punishable |
| R v. Smith | 2016 | Digital evidence manipulation | Digital fabrication treated as serious fabrication offense |
| R v. K | 2019 | False medical records | Fabrication includes civil and criminal proceedings |
🔑 Key Takeaways
Fabrication of evidence involves deliberate creation, alteration, or planting of false evidence.
It can include documents, physical objects, witness testimony, and digital data.
This conduct perverts the course of justice and attracts serious criminal sanctions.
Courts require proof of intention to deceive and an overt act in fabricating or planting evidence.
RELATED Blog
0 comments