Penology in Eritrea
Penology in Eritrea is characterized by a highly authoritarian system, with limited regard for human rights and a penal system that has been widely criticized by international organizations. The country is known for its harsh treatment of political dissidents, arbitrary detentions, and widespread use of forced labor in prisons. Here’s an overview:
1. Legal Framework
Penal Code: Eritrea's Penal Code is based on Italian colonial law, with some modifications. However, it is not consistently applied, and the judicial system is highly influenced by the authoritarian government.
Judiciary: The Eritrean judiciary is not independent; judges and legal decisions are often subject to the control of the ruling party, the People's Front for Democracy and Justice (PFDJ). The legal process is opaque, and defendants have little access to a fair trial.
Lack of due process: There is little legal protection for citizens, and laws are often used to silence political opposition.
2. Prison System
Harsh Conditions: Eritrean prisons are infamous for their inhumane conditions. They are known for:
Overcrowding: Prisons often hold far more detainees than they are designed for.
Poor sanitation: Facilities suffer from unsanitary conditions, with inadequate food, water, and medical care.
Use of forced labor: Many prisoners, including political prisoners, are subjected to forced labor as part of their sentence, often in harsh conditions.
Torture and abuse: Prisoners, especially political prisoners, are often subjected to physical abuse, including beatings, lack of food, and denial of access to healthcare.
Notorious Prisons:
Asmara Central Prison, Keren Prison, and Adi Abeto are among the most well-known for their brutal treatment of prisoners.
"Shipping containers" are frequently used as makeshift cells for detainees, where prisoners are confined in overcrowded, degrading conditions.
3. Penal Philosophy
Political repression: The primary function of Eritrean prisons is to suppress political opposition and dissent. Many prisoners are detained without trial for political reasons, including journalists, human rights activists, and former government officials.
Lack of rehabilitation: There is no established system for prisoner rehabilitation or reintegration into society. Instead, prisons are seen as tools for punishment and control.
Indefinite detention: Many individuals, particularly political prisoners, are held without charge or trial, sometimes for years.
4. Human Rights Concerns
Arbitrary detentions: The government routinely detains individuals without charge, trial, or access to legal representation. Detainees often spend years in prison without facing formal legal proceedings.
Political prisoners: Thousands of political prisoners are held in Eritrean prisons. These individuals are often arrested for their beliefs, participation in opposition movements, or attempting to flee the country.
International scrutiny: Eritrea is frequently condemned by organizations like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the UN Human Rights Council for its human rights abuses in prisons.
5. Alternatives to Incarceration
Eritrea has no functional system of probation, parole, or community-based alternatives to incarceration. The penal system remains largely focused on punishment, particularly in politically motivated cases.
Forced military service and national service (which can be indefinite) often function as alternative forms of detention for many Eritreans, particularly young people. These systems are seen as a means of maintaining strict control over the population.
6. Challenges and Reforms
Reform resistance: The Eritrean government shows little interest in penal reform. It views prisons largely as a tool for maintaining political control.
International pressure: Although there is significant international pressure on Eritrea to improve its human rights record, particularly regarding political prisoners, there has been little meaningful change.
Lack of transparency: The government’s secrecy about the conditions of its prison system and the number of political prisoners exacerbates international criticism.
Summary
Penology in Eritrea is primarily focused on political repression rather than rehabilitation or reform. The penal system is characterized by severe human rights violations, arbitrary detention, forced labor, and widespread torture. There are no effective mechanisms for rehabilitation or alternatives to imprisonment, and political prisoners are a significant concern.
RELATED Blog
0 comments