Death By Dangerous Driving
📌 What is Death by Dangerous Driving?
Definition: When a person causes the death of another by driving a vehicle dangerously.
This is more serious than “causing death by careless driving” because dangerous driving involves a gross deviation from expected standards.
The offence exists under laws like Section 3 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (UK) or similar laws elsewhere.
Penalties include imprisonment, disqualification, and fines.
🧾 Important Legal Elements:
Death of a person caused by driving.
Dangerous driving: Driving judged by the court to be a gross departure from how a competent driver would behave.
Causation: Driving must be a substantial cause of death.
Landmark Case Law on Death by Dangerous Driving
1. R v. Adomako (1995, UK)
Facts: An anaesthetist failed to notice a disconnected oxygen tube during surgery, causing patient’s death.
Significance: Although not a driving case, this established principles of gross negligence manslaughter applied in dangerous driving deaths.
Takeaway: Shows how gross negligence can cause criminal liability when death results.
2. R v. Stone (1997, UK)
Facts: Defendant lost control of a car on a motorway, causing death.
Ruling: Court clarified that the jury must determine whether the driving was dangerous to a competent driver, not just careless.
Takeaway: Objective standard—dangerous driving means conduct that would be obviously dangerous to a reasonable driver.
3. R v. Cairns (2016, UK)
Facts: Driver was speeding and overtook dangerously, causing a fatal crash.
Ruling: Court held that excessive speed combined with dangerous manoeuvres meets the standard for dangerous driving.
Takeaway: Speeding combined with reckless actions can amount to dangerous driving causing death.
4. R v. Ball (2016, UK)
Facts: Driver was intoxicated and caused death by dangerous driving.
Ruling: Court reaffirmed that driving under the influence can be evidence of dangerous driving.
Takeaway: Intoxication doesn’t automatically prove dangerous driving, but it’s a strong factor.
5. R v. Cooksley (2019, UK)
Facts: Driver on phone, failed to keep proper lookout, caused fatal collision.
Ruling: Court held distraction through mobile phone use was dangerous driving.
Takeaway: Distraction from devices can meet dangerous driving threshold.
6. R v. Gough (2019, UK)
Facts: Defendant engaged in reckless driving during a police pursuit resulting in death.
Ruling: Court found police pursuits require careful judicial scrutiny; reckless pursuit may be dangerous driving.
Takeaway: High-risk driving in pursuit situations can amount to dangerous driving causing death.
📍 Summary Table
| Case | Jurisdiction | Facts | Key Principle |
|---|---|---|---|
| R v. Adomako | UK | Medical gross negligence | Gross negligence can cause manslaughter |
| R v. Stone | UK | Lost control on motorway | Objective test for dangerous driving |
| R v. Cairns | UK | Speeding + dangerous overtaking | Speed + dangerous maneuvers = dangerous |
| R v. Ball | UK | Intoxicated driving | Intoxication a key factor, not conclusive |
| R v. Cooksley | UK | Phone distraction | Distracted driving can be dangerous |
| R v. Gough | UK | Reckless police pursuit | Reckless pursuit may be dangerous driving |
⚖️ Legal Takeaways:
Death by dangerous driving is a strictly objective test based on what a competent driver would consider dangerous.
Factors like speeding, intoxication, distraction, and reckless maneuvers often contribute.
The driver’s behavior must be a substantial cause of the victim’s death.
Courts are cautious when cases involve police pursuits or emergencies.
Penalties can be severe, including long prison terms and driving bans.
RELATED Blog
0 comments