Asylum Fraud And False Documentation
1. Legal Framework
In Finland, the criminal liability of employers hiring illegal workers is mainly derived from:
Aliens Act (Ulkomaalaislaki 301/2004) – regulates work permits and residence for foreign nationals. Employing someone without a valid work permit is illegal.
Employment Contracts Act (Työsopimuslaki 55/2001) – requires lawful employment conditions.
Criminal Code of Finland (Rikoslaki 39/1889) – includes offences such as:
Chapter 47: Offences against labor legislation
Section 2: Exploitation of illegal workers / human trafficking
Section 17–18: Fraud and tax evasion (often linked to illegal employment)
Key Employer Offences Include:
Hiring a foreign worker without a valid work permit.
Failing to report employment to authorities.
Exploiting workers under illegal contracts.
Avoiding tax, social security, or minimum wage obligations.
Penalties range from fines to imprisonment, depending on the severity and consequences.
2. Case Law Examples
Here are six notable cases illustrating employer liability for hiring illegal workers:
Case 1: KKO 2011:59 (Employer hiring undocumented foreign workers)
Facts:
A construction company employed several foreign workers who did not have valid work permits.
The company also failed to pay taxes and social security contributions.
Legal Issue:
Whether the employer’s actions constituted a criminal offence under the Aliens Act and labor laws.
Ruling:
The Supreme Court found the employer criminally liable, emphasizing the systematic nature of the violation.
The court imposed fines and partial confiscation of illegal profits.
Key Point:
Systematic employment of undocumented workers is both an administrative and criminal offense.
Case 2: KKO 2013:22 (Exploitation and underpayment)
Facts:
A restaurant hired illegal workers from abroad and paid them below the minimum wage.
Workers were required to work overtime without compensation.
Legal Issue:
Whether exploiting illegal workers constitutes a criminal offence.
Ruling:
The Supreme Court held that employer exploitation of illegal workers can constitute criminal liability, especially when it violates minimum wage laws and working conditions.
The employer received conditional imprisonment and fines.
Key Point:
Exploitation of illegal workers combines labor law violations with criminal liability.
Case 3: KKO 2015:50 (Employer fined for failing to verify work permits)
Facts:
A small company hired multiple foreign workers without checking their work permits.
No active exploitation, but the workers were technically illegal.
Legal Issue:
Liability for negligent hiring of illegal workers.
Ruling:
The Supreme Court emphasized that employers have a duty to verify legal eligibility to work.
Conviction: fines for negligence.
Key Point:
Even without intentional exploitation, failure to verify legality of employment is punishable.
Case 4: KKO 2017:18 (Construction company and organized illegal employment)
Facts:
A construction company repeatedly hired illegal foreign laborers for multiple projects.
Payments were made under the table to avoid taxes.
Legal Issue:
Whether organized, repeated hiring constitutes aggravated criminal liability.
Ruling:
Supreme Court ruled that repeated, organized hiring of illegal workers qualifies as an aggravated criminal offence.
Penalty: imprisonment and confiscation of profits.
Key Point:
Systematic violations and profit-driven schemes are treated more severely.
Case 5: KKO 2019:33 (Employer liability and third-party recruitment agencies)
Facts:
A Finnish company hired foreign workers through a recruitment agency, but the workers lacked permits.
The company claimed it relied on the agency.
Legal Issue:
Can the employer avoid liability by claiming reliance on a third party?
Ruling:
Supreme Court rejected the defense. Employers cannot outsource legal responsibility for verifying work permits.
Conviction: fines and liability for unpaid contributions.
Key Point:
Delegating hiring does not absolve criminal liability.
Case 6: District Court Helsinki, 2020 (Illegal employment leading to safety violations)
Facts:
An industrial company employed illegal workers without proper training.
A worker was injured due to unsafe working conditions.
Legal Issue:
Employer liability combining illegal employment and workplace safety violations.
Ruling:
Court held the employer criminally liable for both illegal employment and negligence causing bodily harm.
Sentence: conditional imprisonment and fines.
Key Point:
Hiring illegal workers can amplify liability if combined with workplace injuries or unsafe conditions.
3. Observations from Finnish Case Law
Intent matters, but negligence is punishable: Both deliberate exploitation and failure to verify work permits are punishable.
Systematic violations are severely punished: Repeat or organized hiring can lead to imprisonment.
Financial exploitation increases penalties: Underpayment, overtime abuse, and tax evasion aggravate liability.
Delegating hiring does not remove liability: Employers cannot escape responsibility by using agencies.
Combined offences: Illegal employment plus workplace injuries or unsafe practices can result in compounded sentences.
RELATED Blog
comments