Criminal Procedure Code at Turkey
The Criminal Procedure Code of Turkey (known as Türk Ceza Muhakemesi Kanunu or CMK) regulates criminal trials and procedures in Turkey. It establishes the rights of individuals involved in criminal proceedings, the role of law enforcement, the responsibilities of prosecutors, and the powers of the judiciary. The Criminal Procedure Code is crucial in ensuring that justice is administered fairly while safeguarding individual rights.
Key Aspects of the Criminal Procedure Code in Turkey:
Investigation and Prosecution:
Initiation of Proceedings: Criminal proceedings in Turkey can be initiated in two main ways:
Ex officio: The public prosecutor or law enforcement officers can start an investigation based on their own findings or reports from others.
Private Complaint: Victims or third parties can file a complaint, leading to an investigation.
Role of the Prosecutor: The public prosecutor has a central role in criminal proceedings. They are responsible for initiating investigations, overseeing the lawfulness of the investigation, and presenting charges in court.
Investigation: Investigations are typically conducted by law enforcement agencies (e.g., police) under the supervision of the public prosecutor. In certain cases, the investigating judge may oversee the gathering of evidence, the questioning of suspects, and other investigative activities.
Arrest and Detention:
Arrest with or without Warrant: Arrests can be made by law enforcement officers with or without a warrant, depending on the circumstances (e.g., if a crime is committed in the presence of law enforcement or in urgent situations).
Pretrial Detention: A person who has been arrested must be brought before a judge within 24 hours of arrest. If the detention is to be extended, a judge must authorize continued detention, and the suspect must be informed of the reasons for their detention. Pretrial detention is limited, but it may be extended in certain cases based on the severity of the crime.
Conditions for Detention: Detention before trial is allowed only when there is a significant risk of the suspect fleeing, tampering with evidence, or committing further offenses.
Rights of the Accused:
Right to Legal Representation: The accused has the right to be represented by a lawyer at all stages of the criminal process. If the accused cannot afford a lawyer, legal aid may be provided by the state.
Right to Silence: The accused has the right to remain silent during questioning and at trial. They cannot be compelled to testify against themselves.
Right to be Informed of Charges: The accused must be informed of the charges against them at the outset of the investigation and during trial proceedings.
Right to Fair Trial: The Turkish Criminal Procedure Code guarantees the right to a fair trial, ensuring that the accused is tried by an impartial judge and has an opportunity to present a defense.
Court Procedure:
Court of First Instance: Criminal cases are generally heard in criminal courts of first instance (Asliye Ceza Mahkemesi). For more serious crimes, such as those involving organized crime or terrorism, specialized courts (e.g., heavy penal courts) may handle the case.
Public Trial: In most cases, criminal trials are open to the public, ensuring transparency. However, certain cases (e.g., involving national security or minors) may be closed to the public.
Role of the Judge: Turkish law allows for investigating judges to supervise criminal investigations. The judge has a significant role in ensuring the lawfulness of the process, including overseeing the detention of suspects, authorizing searches, and safeguarding the rights of individuals.
Prosecution and Defense: Both the prosecution and the defense present their cases in court. The prosecution presents evidence against the accused, while the defense may challenge the evidence and argue for the innocence of the accused.
Trial Procedure:
Presentation of Evidence: During the trial, both parties present their evidence, examine witnesses, and cross-examine opposing witnesses. The judge or panel of judges decides on the admissibility of evidence and the credibility of witnesses.
Judgment: After the trial, the judge or panel of judges delivers a verdict. If the accused is found guilty, the court issues a sentence. If the accused is acquitted, they are released, and the charges are dropped.
Sentencing:
Types of Sentences: In Turkey, sentences for criminal offenses may include:
Imprisonment: The convicted individual may be sentenced to a prison term, depending on the crime's severity.
Fines: A monetary penalty may be imposed in addition to or instead of imprisonment for certain offenses.
Probation: In some cases, a convicted person may be sentenced to probation or house arrest rather than jail time.
Alternative Sentences: The court may impose alternative sentences, such as community service, depending on the circumstances and the crime.
Appeals:
Appeal Process: Both the prosecution and the defense have the right to appeal a judgment to a higher court, typically the Court of Appeals (Yargıtay). Appeals are allowed based on legal errors or violations of procedural law, but not solely on the facts of the case.
Review of Convictions: Higher courts may review the lawfulness of a conviction, the sufficiency of the evidence, and whether the sentence is appropriate under the law.
Special Procedures:
Terrorism and Organized Crime: Turkey has special procedures for handling cases related to terrorism, organized crime, or crimes against national security. These cases are typically heard by heavy penal courts (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi) and involve additional measures to protect state security.
Juvenile Offenders: There are separate provisions for minors (under 18 years old) accused of committing crimes. Juvenile offenders may be subject to different sentencing, including rehabilitation programs instead of traditional punishment.
Witness Protection:
Protection of Witnesses: The Criminal Procedure Code includes provisions for protecting witnesses, especially in cases involving serious crimes, such as terrorism or organized crime. Witnesses may be allowed to testify anonymously or be placed under protection if they are at risk.
Challenges and Considerations:
Pretrial Detention: One of the most significant concerns in Turkey's criminal justice system is the use of pretrial detention, which has sometimes been criticized for its overuse and for violating the rights of suspects, especially in politically sensitive cases.
Judicial Independence: There have been concerns about the independence of the judiciary, particularly in politically charged cases, which may undermine the fairness of trials and appeal processes.
Access to Legal Representation: While the right to legal representation is guaranteed, in practice, many individuals, especially those from disadvantaged backgrounds, may face difficulties in accessing quality legal counsel.
Sources and References:
Türk Ceza Muhakemesi Kanunu (Criminal Procedure Code of Turkey).
Turkish Constitution, which guarantees fundamental rights, including the right to a fair trial and legal representation.
Constitutional Court of Turkey and other legal resources.
The Criminal Procedure Code of Turkey aims to ensure that criminal justice is administered fairly and in accordance with human rights standards. However, challenges remain in ensuring the full protection of rights, particularly in politically sensitive cases. For specific legal advice or updates on the law, it is advisable to consult a legal professional in Turkey.
RELATED Blog
0 comments