Public Health And Safety Offences
1. United States v. DuPont (C-8 Contamination Case, 2017)
Facts:
DuPont was prosecuted for contaminating water supplies near its chemical plant with perfluorooctanoic acid (C-8), linked to health problems.
Legal Issues:
Violation of the Clean Water Act.
Failure to disclose risks and environmental contamination.
Endangerment of public health through toxic waste discharge.
Outcome:
DuPont settled for over $670 million to affected residents and paid penalties to the government.
Significance:
Highlighted corporate responsibility for environmental pollution.
Established precedent for large-scale environmental health prosecutions.
2. OSHA v. BP (Texas City Refinery Explosion, 2005)
Facts:
A massive explosion at BP’s Texas City refinery killed 15 workers and injured many more. OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) charged BP with safety violations.
Legal Issues:
Willful violations of workplace safety regulations under OSHA laws.
Negligence in maintaining safe working conditions.
Outcome:
BP pleaded guilty to safety violations and paid $50 million in fines and restitution.
Significance:
Emphasized the importance of workplace safety.
Sent a strong message that companies can be criminally liable for safety failures causing deaths.
3. United States v. Volkswagen AG (2015 Diesel Emissions Scandal)
Facts:
Volkswagen was prosecuted for installing “defeat devices” in diesel cars to cheat emissions tests, exposing the public to illegal levels of pollutants.
Legal Issues:
Violations of the Clean Air Act.
Fraud and conspiracy to deceive regulators.
Outcome:
Volkswagen agreed to pay over $2.8 billion in criminal and civil penalties, including consumer compensation.
Significance:
Landmark case in environmental public health enforcement.
Showed consequences of corporate deception harming air quality and public health.
4. United States v. Johnson & Johnson (Talcum Powder Lawsuits, ongoing)
Facts:
Johnson & Johnson faced lawsuits alleging their talcum powder contained asbestos, causing cancer and endangering public health.
Legal Issues:
Failure to warn consumers about health risks.
Negligence and product liability under consumer safety laws.
Outcome:
Several large verdicts against J&J, with billions in damages awarded to plaintiffs (some ongoing appeals).
Significance:
Raised awareness of corporate accountability for product safety.
Highlighted public health concerns linked to consumer goods.
5. State of California v. Pacific Gas & Electric (Camp Fire, 2018)
Facts:
PG&E was found responsible for sparking the deadly Camp Fire due to failure to maintain power lines, causing widespread destruction and deaths.
Legal Issues:
Negligence in equipment maintenance.
Violations of public safety laws.
Outcome:
PG&E pleaded guilty to 84 counts of involuntary manslaughter and paid billions in settlements and fines.
Significance:
Demonstrated criminal liability for companies in public safety disasters.
Stressed importance of infrastructure safety and preventative measures.
Summary Table
| Case | Issue | Charges/Violations | Outcome | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US v. DuPont (C-8 Contamination) | Environmental pollution | Clean Water Act violations | $670M settlement | Corporate environmental liability |
| OSHA v. BP (Texas City Explosion) | Workplace safety failure | OSHA safety violations | $50M fines | Workplace safety enforcement |
| US v. Volkswagen (Diesel Scandal) | Emissions cheating | Clean Air Act, fraud | $2.8B+ penalties | Environmental fraud & public health |
| US v. Johnson & Johnson (Talcum) | Product safety & cancer risk | Consumer safety negligence | Billions in damages (ongoing) | Product liability & public health |
| CA v. PG&E (Camp Fire) | Negligent infrastructure maintenance | Manslaughter, safety violations | Guilty plea, billions in fines | Corporate criminal liability in disasters |
Key Takeaways:
Public health and safety offenses can arise from environmental pollution, workplace accidents, product safety failures, or infrastructure neglect.
Prosecutors rely on statutes like the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, OSHA laws, and product liability laws.
Cases often involve criminal negligence, fraud, or willful violations.
Outcomes typically include criminal fines, civil settlements, and sometimes criminal convictions.
These cases emphasize the corporate duty to protect public health and safety.
RELATED Blog
0 comments