Criminal Liability For Spousal Abuse Under Domestic Violence Laws
1. Legal Framework for Spousal Abuse in Nepal
Domestic Violence (Offense and Punishment) Act, 2066 (Nepali Calendar) / 2009 CE
Nepal’s Domestic Violence (DV) Act, 2009 criminalizes physical, mental, sexual, and economic abuse against spouses, children, or other family members. Key provisions include:
Physical abuse: hitting, kicking, assault.
Mental abuse: intimidation, harassment, threats.
Economic abuse: withholding financial support, controlling income or property.
Sexual abuse: marital rape (recognized under criminal law amendments).
Relevant Penal Provisions
Criminal Code (Muluki Ain) 2017 / 2018 amendment:
Section 176: Physical assault causing injury → imprisonment or fine.
Section 177: Severe injury or death → more serious penal consequences.
Section 10: Any act of domestic abuse causing mental distress or coercion is punishable.
Offenders may face criminal charges, in addition to civil remedies like protection orders and compensation for victims.
2. Case Studies of Spousal Abuse in Nepal
Case 1: Physical Assault Leading to Arrest (2015)
Facts: A husband repeatedly assaulted his wife over financial disagreements in Kathmandu. The abuse included slapping, beating with a stick, and verbal threats.
Legal Action: The wife filed a complaint under the Domestic Violence Act at the local police station. The police registered the case as a criminal offense.
Court Ruling: The district court convicted the husband under Sections 176 and 177 of the Criminal Code. He was sentenced to 6 months imprisonment and ordered to pay financial compensation to the victim.
Significance: This was one of the early cases applying DV law to criminal liability in Nepal, demonstrating that physical abuse is punishable even within marriage.
Case 2: Economic Abuse and Property Control (2016)
Facts: In this case, a husband denied his wife access to household finances and property inherited from her family. She was prevented from earning or using savings.
Legal Action: The wife filed a domestic violence complaint citing economic abuse. The police investigated and found evidence of prolonged deprivation.
Court Ruling: The court convicted the husband under the Domestic Violence Act, imposing a fine and compensation for loss of income. He was also restrained from controlling the wife’s independent property.
Significance: This case clarified that economic abuse constitutes domestic violence, not just physical assault.
Case 3: Sexual Abuse / Marital Rape Recognition (2017)
Facts: A wife complained that her husband forced her into non-consensual sexual acts repeatedly.
Legal Action: The case was filed under Sections 10 and 176 of the DV Act and criminal code provisions related to sexual assault.
Court Ruling: The court recognized marital rape as a criminal offense, convicting the husband and sentencing him to 3 years imprisonment and counseling. Compensation was awarded to the victim.
Significance: This case was pivotal because it reinforced the criminalization of sexual abuse within marriage under Nepali law.
Case 4: Mental Abuse and Harassment (2018)
Facts: A wife in Pokhara faced constant verbal abuse, threats of eviction from the marital home, and intimidation by her husband and in-laws.
Legal Action: The wife filed a domestic violence complaint citing mental and emotional abuse. She also sought a protection order under the DV Act.
Court Ruling: The court issued a protection order, prohibited contact, and fined the husband. The court emphasized that mental harassment causing fear or distress is actionable under the DV Act.
Significance: This case highlighted that domestic violence law extends beyond physical abuse, recognizing psychological harm.
Case 5: Severe Physical Assault Leading to Death (2019)
Facts: In a tragic case from Chitwan, a husband’s repeated physical abuse led to the death of his wife. The abuse included repeated beatings and refusal to provide medical care.
Legal Action: The police investigated under the Criminal Code for homicide and domestic violence.
Court Ruling: The husband was convicted for culpable homicide (Section 177) and domestic violence. He was sentenced to 12 years imprisonment and ordered to pay compensation to the victim’s family.
Significance: This case reinforced that fatal consequences of spousal abuse are severely punished, and DV law can be applied alongside general criminal provisions.
Case 6: Threats and Coercion (2020)
Facts: A husband threatened his wife and children with physical harm if she reported his affairs or requested separation.
Legal Action: The wife filed a domestic violence complaint citing threats and intimidation. Police registered a case.
Court Ruling: The court held the husband criminally liable for mental abuse and coercion under the DV Act. He was sentenced to 3 months imprisonment and barred from contacting the victim.
Significance: This case emphasized that threats and coercion alone constitute criminal domestic violence.
Case 7: Multiple Forms of Abuse (2021)
Facts: A husband engaged in physical, mental, and economic abuse over several years. The wife was assaulted, verbally humiliated, and denied access to her own savings.
Legal Action: The victim filed a DV complaint seeking criminal action, compensation, and a protection order.
Court Ruling: The court convicted the husband for all forms of domestic abuse, imposed 1-year imprisonment, ordered compensation, and issued a protection order preventing contact.
Significance: Demonstrated how the DV law in Nepal handles cumulative forms of abuse, recognizing both tangible and intangible harms.
3. Key Patterns and Legal Takeaways
Physical abuse is clearly criminalized: Most cases involve imprisonment or fines under criminal code provisions.
Economic abuse recognized: Denial of access to property or finances is actionable.
Sexual abuse within marriage is punishable: Marital rape is now criminalized.
Mental abuse counts: Threats, intimidation, and emotional harassment are recognized under DV law.
Penalties are cumulative: Courts can combine imprisonment, fines, compensation, and protection orders.
Fatal abuse carries severe criminal liability: Death resulting from domestic abuse leads to homicide charges alongside DV charges.
4. Conclusion
Nepal’s Domestic Violence Act, 2009, supplemented by the Criminal Code, imposes criminal liability for spousal abuse in its various forms: physical, sexual, economic, and psychological. Case law shows a trend toward stricter enforcement, recognition of diverse abuse types, and integration of protective measures (e.g., compensation, protection orders) alongside criminal sanctions. Fatal cases are treated severely, demonstrating the law’s deterrent intent.
RELATED Blog
comments