Penology in Artsakh
Penology in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) has undergone significant transformations, especially following the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war and the subsequent events leading up to 2023. The region's penal system, once centralized around the Shushi penitentiary, faced numerous challenges due to geopolitical shifts, humanitarian crises, and institutional changes. (What Happened to Artsakh's Prisoners After Azerbaijan’s Occupation? Insights from Human Rights Defender Gegham Stepanyan)
🏛️ Pre-2020 Penitentiary System
Prior to the 2020 conflict, Artsakh's sole penitentiary institution was the Shushi prison, located near the town of Shushi. Established in 1869, it housed individuals convicted under Artsakh's legal framework. The prison had a capacity of 350 inmates but typically held fewer, ensuring relatively manageable conditions. Inmates were provided with basic amenities, including iron-frame bunks, whitewashed walls, and concrete floors. The facility also allowed for family visits and food packages, fostering a semblance of normalcy within the constraints of the region's resources. (What Happened to Artsakh's Prisoners After Azerbaijan’s Occupation? Insights from Human Rights Defender Gegham Stepanyan, Karabakh Prisons: A Rare Glimpse Inside | Institute for War and Peace Reporting)
⚖️ Impact of the 2020 War and Subsequent Developments
The 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war marked a turning point for Artsakh's penal system. During the conflict, some inmates were transferred to Armenia, while others were released under amnesty, depending on the severity of their offenses. However, the fall of Shushi to Azerbaijani forces in 2020 led to the cessation of Artsakh's judicial and penal institutions. Most prisoners convicted by Artsakh courts were subsequently housed in Armenian penitentiaries, such as the Goris prison. This transition posed challenges in safeguarding their rights, as logistical issues and the blockade of the Lachin corridor hindered communication and prisoner transfers . (What Happened to Artsakh's Prisoners After Azerbaijan’s Occupation? Insights from Human Rights Defender Gegham Stepanyan)
🏚️ Post-2023: Collapse of Penal Institutions
Following the ethnic cleansing of Artsakh in 2023, the region's legal and penal systems effectively ceased to exist. Most individuals convicted by Artsakh's judicial system were released during this period. The Human Rights Defender of Artsakh, Gegham Stepanyan, highlighted the challenges in ensuring fair treatment for prisoners, noting that many were transferred to Armenian facilities, complicating oversight and advocacy efforts . (What Happened to Artsakh's Prisoners After Azerbaijan’s Occupation? Insights from Human Rights Defender Gegham Stepanyan)
⚖️ Current Status and Human Rights Concerns
In the aftermath of the conflict, the legal status and treatment of former Artsakh officials have been subjects of international scrutiny. For instance, Ruben Vardanyan, a former top official in Nagorno-Karabakh, has been accused of financing terrorism and illegal border crossing by Azerbaijani authorities. His legal team alleges that he was subjected to torture during custody, including sleep deprivation and forced standing. These allegations have raised concerns about the adherence to international human rights standards in the region . (Ex-Karabakh official held by Azerbaijan was tortured in custody, lawyers say)
🧭 Outlook
The future of penology in Artsakh remains uncertain. With the dissolution of its judicial and penal systems, the region faces significant challenges in establishing a fair and humane penal framework. The international community's role in monitoring and advocating for the rights of individuals affected by these changes will be crucial in ensuring justice and accountability.
RELATED Blog
0 comments