Environmental Crime Prosecutions In Usa
What Are Environmental Crimes?
Environmental crimes involve violations of laws designed to protect air, water, land, and wildlife. They include illegal dumping, pollution, wildlife trafficking, illegal logging, and violations of environmental permits.
1. United States v. Exxon Mobil Corporation (2001)
Background: Exxon Mobil was prosecuted for illegal dumping of hazardous waste at its refinery in Baytown, Texas.
Charges:
Clean Water Act violations
Illegal hazardous waste disposal
Legal Issues:
Discharge of pollutants without permits.
Corporate responsibility for environmental harm.
Outcome: Exxon paid millions in fines and undertook cleanup efforts; case reinforced corporate accountability.
2. United States v. Volkswagen AG (2017)
Background: Volkswagen was charged with intentionally cheating emissions tests by installing “defeat devices” on diesel vehicles.
Charges:
Clean Air Act violations
Fraud
Conspiracy
Legal Issues:
Corporate deception harming public health and environment.
Criminal liability for environmental fraud.
Outcome: Company pleaded guilty, paid over $2.8 billion in fines, and faced ongoing litigation.
3. United States v. Massey Energy Company (2011)
Background: Massey Energy was charged after the Upper Big Branch mine explosion killed 29 miners; investigations revealed safety violations and illegal dumping.
Charges:
Clean Water Act violations
Mine Safety and Health Act violations
Negligent homicide
Legal Issues:
Reckless disregard for worker safety and environment.
Corporate and individual criminal responsibility.
Outcome: Company fined $10 million; executives prosecuted and convicted.
4. United States v. BP Exploration & Production Inc. (2012)
Background: Following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, BP faced criminal charges for environmental damage and false reporting.
Charges:
Clean Water Act violations
Obstruction of justice
Negligence
Legal Issues:
Accountability for massive environmental disaster.
False information to federal authorities.
Outcome: BP pled guilty to manslaughter and environmental crimes; paid over $4 billion in fines and compensation.
5. United States v. United States Steel Corporation (2016)
Background: Steel Corp was prosecuted for illegal air pollution and falsifying emissions reports at several plants.
Charges:
Clean Air Act violations
Fraud
Legal Issues:
Manipulation of pollution control data.
Ongoing monitoring and compliance.
Outcome: Company paid fines, implemented corrective measures, and faced close regulatory scrutiny.
6. United States v. Wildlife Traffickers (Operation Crash, 2014)
Background: A multi-agency operation targeted individuals trafficking endangered species and illegal wildlife parts.
Charges:
Violations of the Endangered Species Act
Smuggling and trafficking
Legal Issues:
Criminal enforcement of wildlife protection laws.
International and interstate trafficking.
Outcome: Several convictions with prison sentences; helped curb illegal wildlife trade.
7. United States v. Dow Chemical Company (1995)
Background: Dow Chemical was prosecuted for improper disposal of chemical wastes leading to contamination.
Charges:
Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) violations
Environmental contamination
Legal Issues:
Handling and disposal of hazardous waste.
Corporate liability for contamination.
Outcome: Paid millions in penalties and cleanup; became a benchmark case for hazardous waste enforcement.
Key Legal Frameworks in Environmental Crime
| Statute | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Clean Water Act (CWA) | Controls water pollution from point sources |
| Clean Air Act (CAA) | Regulates air emissions from industrial sources |
| Endangered Species Act (ESA) | Protects endangered wildlife and plants |
| Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) | Governs hazardous waste management |
| Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) | Handles hazardous waste site cleanup |
Summary
Environmental crime prosecutions in the USA show a strong federal commitment to enforcing laws protecting natural resources and public health. Cases involve major corporations and individuals, with serious penalties including fines, imprisonment, and mandated remediation.
RELATED Blog
0 comments