Sexual Offences In Afghanistan
๐น Legal Framework: Sexual Offences in Afghanistan
Afghan Penal Code (2017 update) includes laws against rape, sexual assault, child abuse, and forced prostitution.
Sharia principles also influence how acts like zina (unlawful sexual intercourse) are prosecuted.
Proof requirements can be strict โ in zina cases, for example, four adult male witnesses are needed unless the suspect confesses.
Gender-based violence laws (e.g., the Elimination of Violence Against Women [EVAW] Law, 2009) were created to improve victim protection, but enforcement has been inconsistent.
๐น Case 1: Rape Case โ M.T. v. State (2015, Kabul)
Facts: A young woman was gang-raped while returning from school. Her attackers were later arrested.
Legal Issues: Whether rape could be proven without four male witnesses.
Evidence: Medical exam, witness testimony from one woman and forensic traces.
Outcome: All suspects convicted under rape provisions in the Penal Code, not zina.
Significance: Showed courts using forensic and circumstantial evidence, not Sharia-only standards.
๐น Case 2: Zina Allegation Against Rape Victim (2011)
Facts: A teenage girl reported being raped by a relative. Without four witnesses, she was charged with zina.
Outcome: Sentenced to prison and later gave birth in custody. Eventually released after presidential pardon.
Significance: This case sparked public outrage and reform discussion. Highlighted how rape victims were re-criminalized under zina laws.
๐น Case 3: Child Sexual Abuse in Religious School (2018)
Facts: A mullah was accused of molesting multiple boys in a madrasa.
Evidence: Victim testimonies and medical reports.
Outcome: Mullah convicted and sentenced under child abuse laws, though only after media pressure.
Significance: Marked rare enforcement of child protection laws, reflecting increasing attention to institutional abuse.
๐น Case 4: Honor-Based Accusation of Adultery (Herat, 2013)
Facts: A woman accused by her husbandโs family of adultery after fleeing domestic abuse.
Legal Path: Charged with zina; no witnesses or confession.
Outcome: Acquitted after appeal, aided by EVAW law advocates.
Significance: Demonstrated misuse of sexual offence charges as a tool of control and retaliation.
๐น Case 5: Prosecution of Sexual Harassment (2020)
Facts: A university professor accused of coercing female students for grades.
Evidence: Audio recordings and testimonies.
Outcome: Professor dismissed and sentenced under anti-harassment provisions in Kabul.
Significance: Example of non-violent sexual misconduct being prosecuted under modernized legal frameworks.
๐น Case 6: Sexual Assault in Refugee Camp (2021)
Facts: A female IDP (internally displaced person) was assaulted by a camp official.
Legal Challenge: Victim feared retaliation and did not report until NGOs intervened.
Outcome: Case brought under Penal Code; perpetrator received reduced sentence after "forgiveness" by victimโs family.
Significance: Showed how informal reconciliation can undermine justice in sexual violence cases.
๐ Summary Table
| Case No. | Type of Offence | Legal Issue | Outcome | Legal Insight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rape (forcible) | Evidence without 4 witnesses | Conviction under Penal Code | Forensics over Sharia witness rule |
| 2 | Rape mistaken as zina | Victim punished as offender | Pardon after outcry | Victim criminalized due to evidentiary gap |
| 3 | Child molestation | Institutional abuse | Conviction | Child protection law applied |
| 4 | Zina (honor accusation) | No confession/witness | Acquittal after appeal | EVAW law intervened |
| 5 | Sexual harassment | Abuse of power | Conviction | Modern laws used |
| 6 | Sexual assault in camp | Power dynamics + fear of reporting | Reduced sentence | Justice undermined by compromise |
โ Key Legal Takeaways
Rape and sexual violence can be prosecuted under secular penal codes with medical and testimonial evidence.
However, zina laws still result in wrongful convictions when rape victims can't meet traditional proof standards.
Social stigma and tribal justice systems often silence victims or pressure reconciliation.
Progress has been made using EVAW law and Penal Code 2017, but enforcement remains uneven.
RELATED Blog
0 comments