Criminal Procedure Code at United Arab Emirates
In the United Arab Emirates (UAE), the criminal justice system is governed by a combination of Civil Law and Sharia Law, with a strong influence from the legal traditions of the French and Islamic legal systems. The Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) in the UAE is a key piece of legislation that governs the process of criminal investigations, trials, and sentencing.
Key Legal Frameworks for Criminal Procedure in the UAE:
Federal Law No. 35 of 1992 (The Criminal Procedure Code):
The Criminal Procedure Code is the primary legal framework regulating the process of criminal investigation, prosecution, and trial in the UAE.
The Code lays down the steps involved in the criminal justice process, from the investigation phase to the final judgment, and addresses the rights of the accused, the role of law enforcement, and procedures for appeals.
It applies to both federal and emirate-level criminal cases in the UAE.
The UAE Penal Code (Federal Law No. 3 of 1987):
The Penal Code defines criminal offenses and prescribes penalties for those offenses.
It includes provisions related to crimes like theft, assault, bribery, fraud, and more serious crimes like murder, terrorism, and organized crime.
Sharia Law:
Sharia law plays a significant role in the legal system of the UAE, especially in personal matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, and some criminal cases, particularly those involving moral offenses (e.g., adultery, apostasy, theft).
Certain crimes, particularly those relating to morality (e.g., alcohol consumption, adultery, and public indecency), can be prosecuted under Sharia principles.
The UAE Constitution:
The Constitution of the UAE guarantees certain fundamental rights for citizens, including the right to a fair trial, the presumption of innocence, and protection against unlawful detention.
Key Aspects of Criminal Procedure in the UAE:
Investigation and Arrest:
The public prosecution or police have the authority to initiate criminal investigations based on complaints or reports of crimes.
The Criminal Procedure Code provides detailed procedures for the arrest and detention of suspects, ensuring that arrests are made based on reasonable evidence or suspicion.
Arrests must be conducted by law enforcement, and suspects are typically brought before a judge or public prosecutor shortly after their arrest.
The police are required to inform the arrested individual of their rights, including the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel.
Pre-trial detention is allowed, but it is limited to certain periods, after which the suspect must either be charged or released. In cases of serious crimes, detention can be extended.
Rights of the Accused:
The UAE's Criminal Procedure Code provides rights to individuals under investigation, such as the right to legal representation, the right to be informed of charges, and the right to challenge evidence.
In some cases, particularly under Sharia law, the rights of the accused can be somewhat restricted depending on the nature of the offense.
Prosecution:
Criminal cases are prosecuted by the public prosecutor or the Attorney General's Office. The public prosecutor is responsible for leading investigations, deciding whether there is sufficient evidence to file charges, and representing the state in court.
In the case of serious crimes, a judge will review the evidence presented by the prosecution before proceeding to trial.
Court System:
The UAE has a dual court system: Federal Courts and Emirate-level courts. Criminal cases are heard by criminal courts in both systems, with more serious offenses being tried in the Federal Supreme Court or high-level emirate courts.
The court procedure involves the presentation of evidence, the examination of witnesses, and arguments by the prosecution and defense.
In some cases, a judge may issue a judgment based on the evidence, but in others, the court may consult a jury, particularly in cases involving matters of public order or national security.
Trial and Sentencing:
Criminal trials in the UAE are typically heard by a panel of judges, especially for more serious offenses. In the case of lesser offenses, a single judge may preside over the trial.
After hearing the case, the court will issue a verdict. The judge can impose a range of penalties, from fines and community service to imprisonment or, in rare cases, the death penalty.
The death penalty can be applied for the most serious crimes, such as terrorism, premeditated murder, and certain acts of espionage. However, it is important to note that executions are rare in the UAE.
Appeals:
Defendants have the right to appeal criminal convictions to a higher court. The appellate courts review the legal correctness of the judgment and sentencing.
In some cases, a defendant may appeal directly to the Federal Supreme Court, especially if constitutional issues are involved.
Punishments:
Penalties vary depending on the crime and may include imprisonment, fines, deportation (for foreign nationals), and the death penalty.
For some offenses, such as theft or adultery, Sharia-based punishments like flogging or amputation may be considered, but these punishments are rarely implemented in practice. Instead, the court tends to apply alternative sentences such as imprisonment or fines.
Certain crimes, particularly those of a moral or religious nature, may be punished under Sharia law in addition to civil law penalties.
Protection of Rights:
The UAE's legal system has protections in place to prevent unlawful detention, and the accused is entitled to a defense in court.
However, critics have raised concerns about the transparency and fairness of trials, particularly for non-citizens or cases involving national security or political offenses.
Challenges and Criticisms:
The criminal justice system in the UAE has faced some criticism for its lack of transparency, particularly in politically sensitive cases.
Rights of detainees and fair trial guarantees have been questioned, with reports of limited access to legal counsel during investigations and trials.
There are concerns about the application of Sharia law in some criminal cases, especially where the penalties might conflict with international human rights standards.
RELATED Blog
0 comments