Domestic Violence Cases And Legal Remedies
1. Overview of Domestic Violence
Domestic violence (DV) refers to physical, emotional, sexual, or economic abuse within a domestic or family relationship. It can include:
Physical assault (hitting, slapping, choking)
Psychological abuse (threats, harassment, intimidation)
Sexual abuse or marital rape
Economic control (withholding money or resources)
Social isolation
Legal framework in India (for reference):
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) – Provides civil remedies such as protection orders, residence orders, and maintenance.
Indian Penal Code (IPC) Provisions:
Section 498A – Cruelty by husband or relatives
Section 304B – Dowry death
Section 375/376 – Sexual assault / marital rape (with exceptions in India)
Legal Remedies under PWDVA:
Protection orders – Prevent the abuser from contacting the victim.
Residence orders – Allow the victim to stay in shared household.
Monetary relief – Maintenance for herself and children.
Custody orders – Safeguarding children’s custody.
Counseling/mediation – For rehabilitation and reconciliation if safe.
2. Detailed Case Law Examples
Case 1: Indra Sarma v. V.K.V. Sarma (2013, Supreme Court of India)
Background: Indra Sarma approached the court alleging harassment and threat of domestic violence from her husband and in-laws.
Legal Issues: Enforcement of PWDVA for protection orders and right to reside in marital home.
Court Findings:
Upheld that PWDVA is a civil remedy; it can be invoked even if there is no ongoing physical abuse but a threat to safety.
Directed the husband to provide alternate accommodation if necessary.
Significance: Clarified the scope of “shared household” and the broad reach of civil remedies under PWDVA.
Case 2: Rajesh Sharma & Ors. v. State of UP (2017, Supreme Court of India)
Background: Wife sought protection from domestic violence and cruel behavior by husband.
Legal Issues: Whether PWDVA can protect married women even without divorce.
Court Findings:
PWDVA is independent of criminal remedies under IPC.
Courts can grant protection orders without the need for separation.
Significance: Strengthened civil remedies for immediate protection, even when criminal prosecution is pending.
Case 3: State of Rajasthan v. Veer Singh (Dowry Death, 1991)
Background: Bride died under suspicious circumstances shortly after marriage; alleged harassment for dowry.
Legal Provisions: Section 304B (Dowry Death) & Section 498A (Cruelty).
Court Findings:
Husband and in-laws convicted for dowry-related cruelty.
Highlighted burden of proof shifts in dowry deaths: presumption against accused if death occurs within 7 years of marriage.
Significance: Established stringent legal consequences for dowry harassment and death.
Case 4: Poonam v. State of Delhi (2001, Delhi High Court)
Background: Woman faced repeated physical assault and threats by husband.
Legal Issues: Seeking interim protection and residence order.
Court Findings:
Court granted immediate protection order and directed police to ensure safety.
Emphasized PWDVA’s protective and preventive intent.
Significance: Highlighted the importance of swift judicial intervention to prevent ongoing abuse.
Case 5: Reshma v. State of Maharashtra (Marital Rape/IPC 375 Exception)
Background: Wife alleged sexual abuse by husband.
Legal Issues: Marital rape is not fully criminalized in India, but coercion and threat could amount to cruelty under Section 498A.
Court Findings:
Courts recognized sexual abuse within marriage as part of domestic violence under PWDVA.
Directed protection and counseling orders, even if criminal law could not be applied.
Significance: Shows civil remedies under PWDVA can cover marital sexual abuse, filling a gap in criminal law.
Case 6: Sarita v. State of Haryana (Economic Abuse Case)
Background: Woman claimed husband withheld maintenance and controlled finances to coerce her.
Legal Issues: Economic abuse recognized as domestic violence.
Court Findings:
Granted monetary relief and maintenance under Section 20 of PWDVA.
Reinforced that economic control is a form of abuse, not just physical violence.
Significance: Expanded understanding of domestic abuse beyond physical violence.
Case 7: Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa (1993, Supreme Court of India)
Background: While primarily a custodial death case, it also addressed state responsibility to protect women.
Significance: Established that state negligence in protecting women from violence violates constitutional rights, reinforcing proactive state intervention in DV cases.
3. Key Takeaways / Legal Principles
PWDVA Provides Civil Remedies: Protection, residence, maintenance, and counseling orders.
IPC Provides Criminal Remedies: Section 498A, 304B, 375–376 (marital rape exceptions).
Burden of Proof: Shifts in dowry death cases; mere threat can trigger protection orders.
Broad Definition of Domestic Violence: Physical, sexual, psychological, and economic abuse.
RELATED Blog
0 comments