Section 25 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, (BSA), 2023
Section 25: Admissions are not conclusive proof, but can be used as estoppel
What does it say?
This section states that admissions made by a person do not amount to conclusive proof of the facts admitted. However, such admissions can operate as estoppel against the person who made them.
Breaking it down:
Admission:
An admission is a statement made by a party in a case acknowledging the existence of certain facts relevant to the dispute. For example, if a defendant admits in court that they signed a contract, that is an admission.
Not Conclusive Proof:
Even if a party admits something, that admission alone is not treated as definitive or conclusive proof of the fact. It means that the court may still examine other evidence and decide independently whether the fact is true.
But it can be estoppel:
Although an admission is not conclusive proof, it prevents the party from denying or contradicting the admitted fact later on. This principle is known as estoppel — you cannot "go back" and deny something you have already admitted, except under exceptional circumstances.
Why this provision is important:
It maintains fairness in legal proceedings by preventing parties from taking contradictory positions at different times.
It ensures judicial economy by discouraging unnecessary disputes over facts already acknowledged by a party.
At the same time, it protects the interests of justice by not forcing the court to rely solely on admissions without looking at the entire evidence.
Example to illustrate:
Imagine a case where Party A sues Party B for breach of contract. Party B admits in court that they signed the contract (an admission).
According to Section 25, this admission does not automatically prove the breach occurred — the court will still look at other evidence (like the terms of the contract, actions of the parties, etc.).
However, Party B cannot later deny that they signed the contract because of this admission. It acts as estoppel.
Summary:
Admissions = statements acknowledging facts.
Not conclusive proof = court can still examine all evidence.
Admissions act as estoppel = party cannot deny facts once admitted.
Balances fairness and truth-finding in trials.
RELATED Blog
0 comments