Forensic Science, Dna Analysis, And Crime Scene Investigation
⚖️ I. Understanding Forensic Science in Criminal Investigation
1. Definition
Forensic science applies scientific methods and techniques to investigate crimes.
Main areas include:
Crime scene investigation (CSI): Collection and preservation of evidence.
DNA analysis: Identification of individuals using genetic material.
Fingerprints, ballistics, toxicology: To link suspects with crime scenes.
2. Role in Criminal Justice
Provides objective evidence.
Reduces reliance on witness statements alone.
Helps solve cold cases, sexual assault, murder, and fraud cases.
3. Legal Framework in India
Indian Evidence Act, 1872:
Section 45: Expert opinion admissible in court.
Section 273 & 293: Evidence from forensic experts.
DNA Profiling Regulations, 2012:
Establishes use of DNA data banks and collection procedures.
Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
Section 53: Medical examination of accused or victim for evidence.
Section 164A: Medical examination of sexual assault victims.
⚖️ II. Landmark Cases
1. State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh (1996)
Facts:
One of the earliest cases in India to admit forensic evidence. Hair and fiber analysis linked accused to murder scene.
Held:
Punjab & Haryana High Court recognized forensic evidence as corroborative, not sole proof, but admissible under Section 45 of Indian Evidence Act.
Principle:
→ Scientific evidence supports but does not replace judicial evaluation.
2. State of Maharashtra v. Dr. Praful B. Desai (2003)
Facts:
Dr. Praful Desai was charged with sexual assault; DNA analysis of semen samples was crucial.
Held:
Supreme Court held that DNA profiling provides strong corroborative evidence but must be interpreted alongside medical and circumstantial evidence.
Principle:
→ DNA evidence is highly persuasive if collection and testing follow due procedure.
3. State v. K. Vijay Kumar (2008, Tamil Nadu)
Facts:
Murder investigation; crime scene analysis included fingerprints, blood spatter patterns, and fiber analysis.
Held:
High Court relied heavily on forensic reports to link the accused to the crime scene, confirming presence and actions of accused.
Principle:
→ Crime scene reconstruction using forensics can establish modus operandi and sequence of events.
4. DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Act, 2014 Cases
Cases under this act emphasize use of DNA databanks for sexual assault and murder cases.
Example: XYZ v. State of Karnataka (2015)
DNA from crime scene matched accused, leading to conviction.
Court emphasized chain of custody, laboratory accreditation, and consent procedures.
Principle:
→ Legal safeguards are essential to ensure DNA evidence is admissible.
5. Hemraj vs State of Delhi (2010)
Facts:
Sexual assault case; DNA from vaginal swabs linked accused to victim.
Held:
Delhi High Court upheld conviction based on DNA match and corroborative medical evidence, marking DNA as pivotal in sexual assault convictions.
Principle:
→ DNA evidence strengthens cases of sexual assault and homicide.
6. State of Gujarat v. Kishore Bhai (2016)
Facts:
Murder investigation; ballistic and DNA evidence used to link accused to weapon and crime scene.
Held:
Gujarat High Court highlighted importance of multi-disciplinary forensic investigation (ballistics + DNA + fingerprints).
Principle:
→ Combined forensic methods provide comprehensive evidence to the court.
7. Lyle & Scott v. UK (2001, European Court of Human Rights)
Facts:
International case on admissibility of DNA profiling in criminal trials.
Held:
DNA evidence admissible if procedures are transparent, accurate, and respect privacy rights.
Principle:
→ Scientific evidence must balance accuracy with legal safeguards.
⚖️ III. Key Aspects of Crime Scene Investigation (CSI)
Securing the Scene – Prevent contamination of physical or biological evidence.
Documentation – Photos, sketches, videos.
Evidence Collection – Blood, hair, fibers, bullets, electronic devices.
Chain of Custody – Proper labeling, storage, and transfer.
Analysis – DNA, ballistics, toxicology, fingerprints.
Reporting – Expert report admissible under Section 45 of Indian Evidence Act.
⚖️ IV. Key Legal Takeaways
| Area | Legal Provision | Case Example | Principle |
|---|---|---|---|
| DNA Profiling | DNA Technology Act, 2014 | XYZ v. State of Karnataka 2015 | Requires proper chain of custody |
| Sexual Assault | CrPC 164A, Section 53 | Hemraj v. State of Delhi 2010 | DNA corroborates medical evidence |
| Crime Scene | Section 45 Evidence Act | K. Vijay Kumar 2008 | Reconstruction establishes sequence of events |
| Forensic Corroboration | Indian Evidence Act 45 | Gurmit Singh 1996 | Scientific evidence is corroborative |
| Multi-disciplinary Forensics | DNA + Ballistics + Fingerprints | Gujarat v. Kishore Bhai 2016 | Strengthens conviction through multiple evidence types |
| International Safeguards | ECHR Lyle & Scott 2001 | International precedent | Accuracy + privacy compliance essential |
⚖️ V. Emerging Trends in Forensic Science
Next-Gen DNA Techniques – Familial DNA, touch DNA, phenotyping.
Digital Forensics – Cybercrime investigations, mobile and computer evidence.
Automated CSI Tools – 3D scanning of crime scenes.
Integration with AI – AI-assisted fingerprint matching, pattern recognition in ballistic and blood spatter analysis.
Key principle: Proper forensic methodology combined with legal safeguards ensures evidence admissibility and conviction reliability.
RELATED Blog
0 comments