Fraternity Misconduct Prosecutions
π What Is Fraternity Misconduct?
Fraternity misconduct refers to illegal or harmful acts committed by fraternity members or during fraternity events. These often include:
Hazing (physical abuse, forced drinking, humiliation)
Alcohol poisoning or overdose deaths
Sexual assault
Battery or physical abuse
Failure to report crimes
Negligent supervision of events
These acts can be prosecuted at both the state and federal levels, depending on severity and jurisdiction.
βοΈ Legal Framework
Anti-Hazing Laws (state-level statutes)
Criminal Negligence / Reckless Endangerment
Involuntary Manslaughter
Sexual Assault Statutes
Civil Lawsuits often follow criminal cases (wrongful death, negligence)
Schools may also apply Title IX for institutional liability
π Key Case Law Examples
1. People v. Chun Hsien Deng (2015) β New York
Facts:
Deng, a Baruch College student and pledge, died during a fraternity hazing ritual ("Glass Ceiling") after being forced to carry heavy backpacks and endure physical abuse in subfreezing temperatures.
Charges:
Fraternity members were charged with criminal hazing and manslaughter.
Outcome:
Several members pleaded guilty to lesser charges (hindering prosecution, hazing), with jail time and probation. No one was convicted of murder.
Significance:
One of the first cases to bring serious criminal charges after a hazing death. Raised awareness of the lethality of hazing traditions.
2. Commonwealth v. Piazza (2017) β Pennsylvania (Penn State)
Facts:
Timothy Piazza died after a hazing ritual at Beta Theta Pi involving heavy drinking and no medical help. He fell repeatedly and sustained massive internal injuries.
Charges:
Multiple fraternity members were charged with involuntary manslaughter, aggravated assault, hazardous drinking, and hazing.
Outcome:
Some members pled guilty to lesser charges (e.g., hazing, furnishing alcohol to minors); the chapter was banned; civil suits followed.
Significance:
This became one of the most publicized fraternity death cases, leading to tougher hazing laws in Pennsylvania.
3. State v. Max Gruver Defendants (2018) β Louisiana (LSU)
Facts:
Max Gruver died of alcohol poisoning during a Phi Delta Theta initiation event involving forced drinking.
Charges:
One member was convicted of negligent homicide; others faced hazing charges.
Outcome:
Main defendant was sentenced to 5 years (reduced to probation); civil suits led to multimillion-dollar settlements.
Significance:
Led to "Max Gruver Act" in Louisiana, strengthening anti-hazing laws and increasing penalties.
4. State v. Danny Santulli Defendants (2022) β Missouri (University of Missouri)
Facts:
Danny Santulli suffered permanent brain damage after being forced to drink excessive alcohol in a hazing event.
Charges:
Fraternity members faced felony hazing, negligent endangerment, and providing alcohol to minors.
Outcome:
Several pled guilty; ongoing civil litigation.
Significance:
Even without death, the catastrophic injury resulted in criminal and civil accountability. Expanded legal focus to non-fatal hazing outcomes.
5. United States v. Sigma Alpha Epsilon (2013β2016) β Multiple Jurisdictions
Facts:
Multiple SAE chapters across the U.S. faced legal action after reports of racist behavior, hazing, sexual assault, and alcohol violations.
Charges:
Chapters were investigated under civil rights, Title IX, and local criminal law.
Outcome:
Some chapters were permanently banned. Criminal charges were filed against individuals; schools faced lawsuits.
Significance:
Demonstrated systemic issues and how institutions (schools and fraternities) can be held accountable for repeated misconduct.
π Summary: Legal Lessons
| Legal Principle | Application in Cases |
|---|---|
| Hazing laws | Criminalizes forced initiation rituals (even if βvoluntaryβ) |
| Involuntary manslaughter | Applies when hazing leads to death via recklessness |
| Negligent homicide | For deaths caused by failure to act (e.g., not calling 911) |
| Civil liability | Families sue for wrongful death, negligence, emotional distress |
| University sanctions | Expulsion, chapter bans, and Title IX investigations |
RELATED Blog
0 comments