Criminal Procedure Code at Hungary
The Criminal Procedure Code of Hungary (Hungarian: Magyar Büntetőeljárási Törvénykönyv) regulates the process of criminal investigations, trials, and appeals within the Hungarian legal system. It defines the rights of the accused, the duties of the prosecution, and the role of the judiciary in criminal proceedings. Hungary’s legal system follows an inquisitorial model, meaning the judge plays a more active role in investigating the case, compared to the adversarial system used in countries like the United States.
The most recent version of the Hungarian Criminal Procedure Code came into effect in 2018 (Act No. XC of 2017), although it has been amended multiple times since its introduction.
Key Aspects of the Hungarian Criminal Procedure Code:
1. Investigation and Arrest:
Police Investigation: The police are responsible for conducting criminal investigations in Hungary. However, investigations can also be led by the prosecutor’s office, depending on the type of crime.
Arrest: The police may arrest a suspect if there is sufficient evidence of a crime. For certain serious crimes, an arrest warrant may be issued by a judge. If the arrest is made without a warrant, the suspect must be presented to a judge within 72 hours.
Pre-trial Detention: If the accused is detained, they may be held in custody for a period of time before trial, but this is subject to legal limits. The judge must review the necessity of pre-trial detention periodically.
2. Rights of the Accused:
Presumption of Innocence: The accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty. The burden of proof is on the prosecution, and the accused has the right to remain silent.
Right to Legal Counsel: The accused has the right to an attorney at all stages of the criminal process. If the defendant cannot afford one, legal aid may be provided.
Right to Information: The accused must be informed of the charges against them and the evidence being used.
Right to Challenge Evidence: The accused can challenge evidence, witness statements, and expert testimony presented by the prosecution.
3. Role of the Prosecutor:
The prosecutor has a central role in the criminal procedure, as they are responsible for initiating investigations and bringing charges. They are also responsible for overseeing the legality of the investigation and ensuring the proper administration of justice.
In Hungary, the prosecutor can request measures like arrest warrants, search orders, or the freezing of assets, and also has the authority to appeal decisions.
4. Pre-Trial Procedures:
Investigation: Before a trial, the investigating judge (or prosecutor, depending on the case) will oversee the collection of evidence and the interrogation of witnesses and suspects. A preliminary hearing may be held to assess the progress of the investigation.
Decision to Charge: If the investigation concludes that there is sufficient evidence, the prosecutor will file formal charges, and the case will move to trial. If there is not enough evidence, the case may be dropped.
Alternative Solutions: The Criminal Procedure Code allows for alternatives to formal prosecution in some cases, such as diversion or a plea bargain. These can lead to a resolution without a full trial, often involving lighter sanctions for the accused.
5. Trial Process:
Court Composition: Criminal cases are generally tried in a single-judge court for less serious offenses. However, for more serious crimes (like murder or organized crime), a panel of judges (usually with a professional judge and two lay judges) will hear the case.
Public and Oral Trials: Trials are typically public and conducted orally, where both the prosecution and defense can present evidence, question witnesses, and make arguments. In some cases, the trial may be closed to the public for reasons such as the protection of victims or state secrets.
Role of the Judge: In Hungary's inquisitorial system, the judge plays an active role in investigating the case. The judge may ask questions of witnesses, request additional evidence, and direct the investigation to ensure fairness and clarity.
6. Sentencing:
If the defendant is found guilty, the judge will impose a sentence. Sentences may include imprisonment, fines, community service, or probation.
The Hungarian Penal Code allows for both fixed-term sentences (for specific crimes) and indeterminate sentences (especially in cases involving long-term imprisonment).
Judges have some discretion in sentencing, but they are guided by the severity of the crime, mitigating circumstances, and the defendant’s criminal history.
7. Appeals:
Right to Appeal: Both the prosecution and the defense have the right to appeal a verdict, either on the grounds of legal errors or the severity of the sentence.
Appeals can be made to higher courts, and in some cases, the case can be reviewed by the Supreme Court of Hungary.
Appeals on Sentence: The defendant may appeal the sentence if it seems disproportionate or unlawful. However, an appeal can only challenge legal aspects or the application of law, not factual determinations made by the trial court.
8. Post-Trial:
Rehabilitation and Pardons: In certain circumstances, after serving part of a sentence, prisoners may apply for early release, or the president may grant pardon based on good behavior or exceptional circumstances.
Execution of Sentences: The Code provides detailed rules for the enforcement of sentences, such as the conditions under which an individual will serve their sentence and the rehabilitation measures available.
9. Victims’ Rights:
The victim of a crime also has certain rights during the criminal procedure, including the right to be informed of the progress of the case, the right to compensation, and the right to testify or give a statement during the trial.
Hungary has provisions for victim protection, particularly in cases of domestic violence, human trafficking, and organized crime.
Recent Reforms and Modernization:
The 2018 amendments to Hungary’s Criminal Procedure Code were part of an effort to modernize the legal process, reduce delays, and enhance the rights of victims. These changes also sought to ensure that Hungary’s legal system complies with European Union standards and promotes fair trial guarantees.
Challenges:
Despite these reforms, challenges remain in the system, such as concerns about overcrowded prisons, delays in trials, and corruption in the justice system.
Hungary has faced criticism from international bodies about issues with judicial independence and fair trial rights, particularly in politically sensitive cases.
RELATED Blog
0 comments