Computer Software Piracy
Computer software piracy refers to the unauthorized copying, distribution, or use of software protected by copyright law. It is one of the fastest-growing forms of intellectual property violation globally and impacts software developers, businesses, and the economy.
Legal Framework in India
The Copyright Act, 1957 (Sections 14, 51, 52, 63)
Copyright protects the source code and object code of computer software as a literary work.
Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or sale constitutes infringement.
Information Technology Act, 2000
Section 66 deals with computer-related offenses, including unauthorized access and tampering.
International Treaties
Berne Convention (1886): Protects literary works, including software.
TRIPS Agreement: Requires member countries to provide legal remedies for software piracy.
Civil and Criminal Remedies
Civil: Injunction, damages, accounts of profits.
Criminal: Imprisonment (up to 3 years) and fine under Copyright Act, Sections 63–63A.
Forms of Software Piracy
End-User Piracy – Using unlicensed copies of software.
Counterfeit Software – Selling illegal copies with fake packaging.
Internet Piracy – Downloading or sharing software via peer-to-peer networks.
Client-Server Overuse – Installing one licensed copy for multiple users.
Hard Disk Loading – Pre-installing unlicensed software on computers for sale.
Key Case Laws in Computer Software Piracy
1. Microsoft Corporation v. Mohammed Abdul Khader (2001 Madras HC)
Facts:
The defendant was selling unlicensed Microsoft software CDs in Chennai.
Judgment:
Court held the defendant guilty of copyright infringement under Section 51 of the Copyright Act.
Injunction was granted, and damages awarded to Microsoft.
Impact:
Reinforced that software is protected under copyright law as a literary work.
Courts recognized retail sale of pirated software as actionable infringement.
2. R.K. Dhawan v. Microsoft India (2004 Delhi HC)
Facts:
Unauthorized installation of Microsoft Office and Windows software in a company without proper licensing.
Judgment:
Court emphasized the importance of software licensing agreements.
Held that corporate entities are equally liable for piracy.
Damages awarded to the plaintiff and order for immediate cessation of illegal use.
Impact:
Highlighted corporate liability in software piracy cases.
Demonstrated courts’ willingness to protect multinational software interests.
3. Oracle Corporation v. M/s A. K. Computers (2005 Delhi HC)
Facts:
Company copied Oracle databases illegally and distributed them to clients.
Judgment:
Court issued permanent injunction, seized pirated software copies, and imposed damages.
Confirmed that both reproduction and distribution constitute infringement.
Impact:
Reaffirmed the legal protection of enterprise software.
Set precedent for targeting business-to-business piracy.
4. Apple Computer Inc. v. Samuels (U.S. Case, 2000)
Facts:
The defendant sold pirated versions of Apple software online.
Judgment:
U.S. District Court ruled in favor of Apple, granting injunction, statutory damages, and attorney fees.
Court emphasized digital distribution does not shield piracy from copyright laws.
Impact:
Demonstrates the global applicability of copyright protection for software.
Highlights online software piracy enforcement mechanisms.
5. BSA v. J&K Corporation (2007 India, Supreme Court)
Facts:
Business Software Alliance (BSA) filed suit against multiple corporations using unlicensed software.
Judgment:
Supreme Court reinforced that software piracy harms the economy and innovation.
Awarded compensation and emphasized proactive compliance by companies.
Impact:
Encouraged Indian companies to maintain audit trails and proper licensing.
Strengthened enforcement through civil courts.
6. Adobe Systems Inc. v. Vikas Khanna (2010 Delhi HC)
Facts:
Individual sold pirated Adobe Photoshop and Illustrator software online.
Judgment:
Court granted injunction, ordered confiscation of pirated copies, and imposed fines.
Recognized that digital piracy online is equally punishable as physical media piracy.
Impact:
Set precedent for internet-based software piracy enforcement in India.
Reinforced BSA and similar organizations’ rights to enforce licensing.
7. Sony Entertainment Software Inc. v. ABC Electronics (2008 Delhi HC)
Facts:
Retailer installed pirated gaming software (Sony PlayStation games) on consoles sold to customers.
Judgment:
Court held that pre-installed pirated software constitutes infringement.
Ordered damages and permanent injunction.
Impact:
Clarified that hardware bundling with pirated software is illegal.
Strengthened legal remedies for gaming software producers.
Comparative Perspective
| Country | Law/Statute | Enforcement Mechanism | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| India | Copyright Act 1957, IT Act 2000 | Civil & criminal remedies, raids, injunctions | Covers both retail and corporate piracy, civil damages |
| USA | Copyright Act 1976, DMCA 1998 | Civil & criminal, statutory damages | Strong statutory damages, online piracy enforcement |
| UK | Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 | Civil and criminal, police raids | Digital Millennium Copyright Enforcement, seizure of pirated media |
| EU | InfoSoc Directive | Injunctions, fines, border measures | Strong cross-border enforcement in digital piracy |
Observations:
India is catching up with global norms, but enforcement depends on corporate vigilance and police action.
International cases show that online distribution of pirated software attracts severe civil and criminal penalties.
Both individual and corporate liability is recognized.
Key Takeaways for Software Piracy Enforcement
Copyright protection applies to all software – desktop, server, and cloud-based.
Civil and criminal remedies are both available; injunctions are common.
Corporate and individual liability – businesses must maintain licensing records.
Digital evidence (emails, downloads, server logs) is crucial in proving piracy.
International enforcement cooperation is critical for online piracy.
RELATED Blog
comments