Section 331 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, (BSA), 2023
Section 331 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023 in English, along with its context and significance.
Overview of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023
The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 is the newly enacted Indian Evidence Act which replaced the older Evidence Act of 1872. It is designed to modernize and streamline the rules relating to the admissibility and evaluation of evidence in Indian courts. The Act lays down comprehensive provisions on what constitutes evidence, how evidence can be presented, and how courts should treat various types of evidence.
Understanding Section 331 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023
Section 331 of the BSA, 2023 primarily deals with affidavits and their admissibility as evidence in court proceedings.
What is an Affidavit?
An affidavit is a written statement confirmed by oath or affirmation, used as evidence in court. It is a way for a person to submit their statement or facts in writing without needing to appear and testify orally before the court.
Key Provisions of Section 331 (Summary)
Section 331 allows parties to present affidavits as evidence instead of oral testimony, but only when the court permits it.
The court must be satisfied that there are "sufficient reasons" to accept an affidavit in lieu of live testimony.
This section is designed to reduce the burden of oral testimony, save court time, and make proceedings more efficient while ensuring fairness.
Purpose of Section 331
Efficiency: Affidavits can streamline judicial processes by reducing the need for lengthy oral evidence.
Flexibility: Courts can allow affidavits in exceptional circumstances, such as when a witness is unavailable or it would be unjust to compel oral testimony.
Reliability and Fairness: The court’s discretion to admit affidavits ensures that evidence presented in this manner is reliable and the opposing party has an opportunity to challenge it.
Detailed Explanation and Implications
1. Affidavits as Evidence
Traditionally, evidence is given orally in court, allowing for cross-examination and real-time assessment of credibility. However, affidavits provide an alternative where the witness swears to the truth of the statement in writing. Under Section 331, the court can permit affidavits, but it is not mandatory; it depends on the circumstances.
2. Court’s Discretion and Criteria
The court evaluates if sufficient reasons exist to rely on affidavits. For example, reasons might include:
The witness is seriously ill or incapacitated.
The witness resides far away, making physical appearance burdensome.
The evidence is uncontroversial or straightforward.
The court may reject affidavits if it believes that oral testimony is essential for justice, such as cases involving serious credibility issues or where cross-examination is crucial.
3. Safeguards for Fair Trial
To balance efficiency and fairness, Section 331 incorporates safeguards:
Affidavits are admissible only when the court explicitly permits.
The opposing party has the right to request oral examination or challenge the affidavit.
The court may order cross-examination if needed to test the affidavit’s credibility.
4. Comparison with Previous Law
Section 331 is inspired by provisions in the older Evidence Act and procedural rules (such as Order XIX Rules 1-3 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908), which allowed affidavits under certain conditions but with caution. The 2023 Act codifies and updates these principles, providing a clearer legal framework.
Practical Example
Suppose in a civil lawsuit, a key witness is elderly and suffering from a serious illness. Traveling to court to testify would be difficult. Under Section 331, the court may allow the witness’s sworn written statement (affidavit) to be used as evidence. The opposing lawyer can still request to cross-examine the witness remotely or submit objections.
Significance of Section 331 in Modern Judicial Practice
Time-saving: Courts can dispose of cases faster by limiting oral evidence.
Access to justice: It accommodates witnesses who cannot physically attend court.
Technological adaptation: The provision complements electronic affidavits and remote testimony, which are increasingly important post-pandemic.
Conclusion
Section 331 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, marks a thoughtful balance between efficiency and fairness in Indian legal proceedings. It recognizes that while oral evidence remains the gold standard, written affidavits have an important role in modernizing the justice system. By granting courts discretion to admit affidavits under reasonable circumstances, this section helps reduce delays, minimize inconvenience, and ensure just outcomes.
RELATED Blog
comments