Criminal Procedure Code at Egypt
Egypt's legal framework governing criminal procedures is primarily based on Law No. 150 of 1950, known as the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC). This code outlines the processes for criminal investigations, trials, and appeals, and has undergone various amendments over the years. (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Recent Developments and Proposed Amendments
In 2024, the Egyptian parliament considered a draft amendment to the CPC, aiming to address certain legal provisions. Key aspects of the proposed changes include: (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Pretrial Detention Limits: The draft proposes reducing the maximum duration of pretrial detention: 4 months for misdemeanors (down from 6), 12 months for felonies (down from 18), and 18 months for crimes punishable by death or life imprisonment (down from 24) . (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Use of Technology: The amendment suggests incorporating modern communication methods in investigations, allowing for remote trials and witness testimonies, and presenting digital evidence . (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Rights of the Accused: It emphasizes the right to legal representation and the concealment of witnesses' identities for their safety. (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Judicial Oversight: The draft mandates that investigative judges provide written justifications for pretrial detention decisions . (Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Criticisms and Concerns
Despite these proposed reforms, the draft has faced significant criticism from various organizations: (Egypt’s proposed new criminal procedures code consolidates individual rights and freedoms - Politics - Egypt - Ahram Online)
Human Rights Watch argues that the draft fails to address systemic issues like arbitrary detention and the lack of accountability for security forces. (Calls for Rejection of Egypt’s Proposed Criminal Procedure Code – nationalcourrier)
Amnesty International highlights concerns over the prolonged pretrial detention periods and the expansion of prosecutorial powers, which could undermine fair trial rights . (Egypt: Reject Draft Criminal Procedure Code | Human Rights Watch)
Egyptian Lawyers' Syndicate and the Journalists' Syndicate express apprehensions about provisions that may restrict the role of defense attorneys and the press. (Egypt: Reject draft Criminal Procedure Code - IFEX, Egypt: Draft Law to Amend Code of Criminal Procedure Under Consideration | Library of Congress)
Conclusion
While the proposed amendments to Egypt's Criminal Procedure Code aim to modernize certain aspects of the legal system, they have raised concerns regarding the protection of individual rights and the balance of power within the judicial process. Ongoing debates and reviews are expected to continue shaping the future of criminal procedure law in Egypt.
RELATED Blog
0 comments