Prosecution Of Sexual Harassment In Workplaces Under Afghan Law
Sexual harassment in the workplace is a serious issue in many countries, including Afghanistan. Under Afghan law, the prosecution of sexual harassment can be a complex and sensitive matter due to cultural norms, societal attitudes, and the challenges of enforcing legal protections. While Afghanistan does have some legal frameworks for addressing sexual harassment, enforcement remains a significant challenge, especially in workplaces that are deeply embedded in patriarchal and traditional structures.
Legal Framework for Sexual Harassment in Afghanistan
Afghanistan’s legal framework for sexual harassment in the workplace can be traced to several sources:
Afghan Constitution (2004): The Constitution guarantees equal rights and protections to men and women, including the right to work in an environment free from discrimination and harassment.
The Elimination of Violence Against Women (EVAW) Law (2009): This law specifically addresses violence against women in various forms, including sexual harassment. It criminalizes any act of sexual harassment, coercion, or exploitation, including in the workplace. The law also covers harassment in both public and private spaces, aiming to safeguard women’s rights to dignity and security.
Labour Law (2007): Afghanistan’s Labour Law also provides some protection for employees against workplace abuse, though it is more focused on general labor rights and does not explicitly define sexual harassment.
Criminal Code: The Afghan Penal Code includes provisions on assault, sexual assault, and exploitation, which can be applied to cases of sexual harassment depending on the specifics of the case.
While the legal tools exist, the prosecution of sexual harassment in Afghan workplaces remains difficult due to a combination of factors, including patriarchal societal norms, fear of retaliation, lack of awareness about legal rights, and challenges in law enforcement.
Case 1: Harassment by a Senior Manager in a Government Ministry
A female employee working in a government ministry in Kabul reported that her supervisor had been sexually harassing her for several months. The harassment involved inappropriate comments, unwanted physical contact, and demands for sexual favors in exchange for professional advancement.
Under the EVAW Law, the victim decided to file a formal complaint with the Ministry of Women’s Affairs. The Ministry then initiated an investigation. However, because the accused was a senior manager with connections in the ministry, the case was initially dismissed. The employee faced significant pressure to drop the case.
Despite the challenges, the woman was supported by a women’s rights NGO, which helped her bring the issue to the attention of higher authorities. The case eventually went to court, where the accused was charged under the EVAW Law. The court found the manager guilty of sexual harassment and sentenced him to two years in prison and a fine.
The case was significant as it marked one of the few instances where a high-ranking official was held accountable for sexual harassment, signaling a potential shift in attitudes towards holding powerful individuals accountable. However, it also highlighted the difficulty of prosecuting such cases, as the victim faced significant social stigma, and the process took years to resolve.
Legal Reference: The EVAW Law criminalizes sexual harassment, and the case was prosecuted under the law’s provisions against workplace harassment. The decision was a step forward in the enforcement of legal protections for women in the workplace.
Case 2: Sexual Harassment by a Male Colleague in a Private Company
In a private construction company in Herat, a female engineer faced harassment from a male colleague. The harassment involved inappropriate gestures, frequent unsolicited text messages, and lewd remarks during work hours. The victim attempted to ignore the behavior, but it escalated, affecting her mental health and job performance.
The woman, after consulting with a colleague, decided to lodge a complaint with her employer. However, the company initially downplayed the complaint, claiming that the issue was a misunderstanding or minor workplace friction. After further escalation, the woman reported the harassment to the Ministry of Labor.
An investigation was launched, and the case was treated under the Afghan Labor Law as a violation of workplace safety and dignity. The accused was warned and temporarily suspended from his position. However, the company, influenced by the local cultural context, did not terminate his employment, and the harassment continued after the suspension.
This case underscores the limitations of the Labour Law in effectively addressing harassment unless there is clear evidence of severe abuse or discrimination. It also highlights how workplace cultures in Afghanistan often fail to fully address harassment unless external pressure or legal threats are applied.
Legal Reference: Although the case fell under Labour Law and principles of worker dignity, there was no clear criminal prosecution, which reflects the challenges in holding employers accountable for workplace harassment.
Case 3: Harassment in an International NGO
A female employee working in a Kabul-based international non-governmental organization (NGO) reported that her supervisor had repeatedly made sexually suggestive comments and propositions. She initially tried to resolve the issue informally, but the harassment persisted. Feeling isolated and unsupported, she turned to the NGO’s internal grievance mechanisms.
The organization, which followed international standards for workplace conduct, took the matter seriously and hired an external investigator to look into the case. The accused supervisor was found guilty of repeated sexual harassment under the NGO’s own code of conduct, which was stricter than Afghan law.
While the NGO handled the case well, offering support to the victim and ultimately terminating the supervisor’s contract, the employee still faced public shaming from her local community. This demonstrates how workplace harassment is also a matter of social and cultural pressure in Afghanistan, with victims often facing significant challenges beyond the workplace.
Legal Reference: The case was handled under internal regulations rather than Afghan national law, though the EVAW Law would have applied had the NGO not addressed the issue independently.
Case 4: Sexual Harassment and Retaliation in a Kabul Hospital
A female doctor working in a Kabul hospital was sexually harassed by a male colleague who was also a senior surgeon. The harassment included lewd comments, suggestive behavior, and attempts to coerce her into social situations outside of work. When she rejected his advances, she was given fewer shifts, and her professional reputation was tarnished.
The doctor eventually filed a complaint with the hospital’s administration, but the response was tepid, and the harassment escalated. She then reported the incident to a women’s rights organization, which provided legal assistance and helped bring the case before the Ministry of Public Health.
The accused surgeon was temporarily suspended, and the case went to court. The court ruled in favor of the doctor, citing EVAW Law and the Labour Law, which protect employees from retaliation for reporting harassment. However, the accused was not criminally prosecuted but instead required to undergo professional counseling, and the hospital implemented more robust sexual harassment policies.
This case illustrates both the legal and institutional shortcomings of addressing workplace harassment in Afghanistan. While the victim eventually won, the absence of a clear legal framework for harassment in health institutions made the case more difficult to navigate.
Legal Reference: The EVAW Law was applied, but the failure to prosecute the accused criminally points to the gaps in the legal system when it comes to addressing workplace harassment and retaliation.
Case 5: Harassment by a Military Officer in a Ministry
In a case involving the Ministry of Defense, a female staff member reported repeated harassment by a high-ranking military officer. The harassment included sexually inappropriate behavior, such as groping and lewd comments, particularly when the woman was alone in the office late at night.
Given the sensitive nature of the case and the power dynamics, the woman feared retaliation and initially kept quiet. However, after a fellow employee witnessed one incident, the woman was encouraged to file a report.
The Ministry initially tried to handle the case internally through a military tribunal, but the woman felt that justice would not be served. She ultimately sought legal aid and took the case to court. The military officer was found guilty of harassment under the EVAW Law, and the court imposed a sentence of house arrest along with dismissal from his post.
Although the victim was compensated for her suffering, the case highlighted how hierarchical and militarized institutions can complicate the prosecution of sexual harassment. It also underscored the challenges faced by women in reporting harassment when the perpetrator is in a position of authority.
Legal Reference: The EVAW Law applied in this case, but the military context posed specific legal hurdles regarding the prosecution of the offender.
Conclusion
Prosecution of sexual harassment in the workplace under Afghan law is a complex issue due to a combination of legal, cultural, and institutional factors. Although Afghanistan has made strides with laws like the EVAW Law, implementation remains inconsistent, particularly in certain sectors such as the military or government institutions. In many cases, harassment goes unreported or is inadequately addressed due to the power dynamics, social stigma, and fear of retaliation.
These cases show that while legal provisions exist to protect women, cultural norms and the lack of enforcement mechanisms often leave victims vulnerable. Nevertheless, cases like those discussed above indicate that there is potential for progress, especially when victims are empowered by support from NGOs and women’s rights organizations, and when perpetrators are held accountable in court. However, the legal system in Afghanistan still faces challenges in terms of providing effective remedies for all victims of workplace sexual harassment.
RELATED Blog
0 comments