Fake Degree Prosecutions
✅ Overview: Fake Degree Prosecutions in the U.S.
⚖️ What is a Fake Degree?
A fake degree refers to a diploma or academic credential that is either:
Completely fabricated (not issued by any school),
Issued by a "diploma mill"—a fraudulent entity posing as a school, or
Forged or altered from a real institution.
These degrees are often used to fraudulently secure jobs, promotions, visas, or professional licenses.
📜 Legal Framework
Prosecutions may be brought under various federal and state laws, depending on the context:
Wire fraud / mail fraud (18 U.S.C. §§ 1341, 1343)
Forgery / uttering false documents
False statements on government applications or forms
Impersonation of licensed professionals
Fraudulent academic credentials laws (in some states like Texas and Oregon)
📚 Notable Fake Degree Prosecutions with Case Law
1. United States v. Axact (Diploma Mill Case, 2015–2018)
Facts: Axact, a Pakistan-based company, was accused of running a global fake diploma scheme, selling counterfeit degrees from fictitious universities (e.g., “Barkley University”) to thousands of U.S. residents.
Charges: Wire fraud, conspiracy, and misrepresentation.
Outcome: Multiple U.S.-based “agents” were prosecuted. Purchasers were also investigated, especially those who used degrees to obtain jobs.
Significance: One of the largest international diploma mill operations; exposed use of fake degrees in U.S. education and healthcare sectors.
2. State v. Claude E. Allen (Texas, 2010)
Facts: Allen used a fake degree from a non-accredited university to secure a high-paying job with the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.
Charges: Tampering with government records and securing execution of a document by deception.
Outcome: Convicted; received probation, restitution, and was fired from state employment.
Significance: Texas has specific statutes criminalizing the use of fake degrees in public employment, making it easier to prosecute.
3. People v. Patel (California, 2013)
Facts: Patel submitted a forged medical degree and fake transcripts to apply for a medical license in California.
Charges: Forgery, grand theft by false pretenses, and practicing medicine without a license.
Outcome: Convicted and sentenced to prison. California Medical Board revoked the license.
Significance: Shows how fake degrees are used in high-stakes fields like medicine, triggering multiple criminal charges.
4. United States v. Snyder (Illinois, 2016)
Facts: Snyder submitted a fake degree in an application for a Department of Homeland Security job, claiming to have a master’s from a real university.
Charges: Making false statements to a federal agency (18 U.S.C. § 1001).
Outcome: Convicted; sentenced to 18 months in federal prison.
Significance: Shows how fake degrees can lead to federal criminal liability, especially in government employment.
5. Commonwealth v. Hall (Massachusetts, 2018)
Facts: Hall, a school administrator, submitted a fake doctorate from a non-accredited online university to receive a salary raise.
Charges: Larceny over $250 (fraudulently obtained salary), forgery.
Outcome: Convicted of larceny and ordered to repay over $60,000 in excess salary.
Significance: Highlights how fake degrees are used for financial gain and how salary fraud is prosecuted as theft.
6. State v. Chen (New York, 2020)
Facts: Chen used a fake nursing degree from a now-shuttered school to sit for the NCLEX exam and obtained licensure as an RN.
Charges: Offering a false instrument for filing and practicing without valid educational credentials.
Outcome: Nursing license revoked; Chen was criminally prosecuted and sentenced to 1 year in jail.
Significance: Nursing boards and prosecutors are increasingly aggressive in verifying credentials after similar national scandals.
⚖️ Legal Themes in Fake Degree Cases
| Theme | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Intent to Defraud | Central to proving criminal liability — especially in fraud or theft charges. |
| Use of Degree | Mere possession is usually not criminal — use to gain employment or benefit is key. |
| Forgery vs. Diploma Mill | Forging real school documents is a crime; using diploma mill degrees can also be illegal in certain states. |
| Government Applications | False credentials submitted to federal/state entities often trigger false statements charges. |
| Professional Licensing Impact | Fake degrees used to obtain professional licenses can lead to license revocation and criminal charges. |
🧾 Penalties in Fake Degree Prosecutions
Penalties vary widely based on the context:
Misdemeanor charges (simple fraud or misrepresentation): fines, probation
Felony charges (forgery, grand theft, federal fraud): 1–10 years prison
Professional consequences: Loss of license, job termination, ineligibility for public service
Restitution: Repayment of salaries or benefits obtained through deception
✅ Conclusion
Fake degree prosecutions are serious matters with wide-reaching consequences, especially in public service, education, and healthcare. Courts have consistently ruled that intentional use of fraudulent academic credentials for financial gain, employment, or licensing constitutes a criminal offense. Whether through forged documents or diploma mills, using fake degrees invites significant legal exposure.
RELATED Blog
0 comments