Online Scam Prosecutions
I. What Is an Online Scam?
An online scam is a form of cybercrime that involves deceptive or fraudulent tactics used over the internet to gain money, data, or access to systems. These scams typically target individuals, businesses, or institutions and can include:
Phishing and identity theft
Investment and cryptocurrency scams
Online shopping fraud
Romance and dating scams
Business email compromise (BEC)
Social media impersonation or fake profiles
II. Legal Framework (UK Focus)
Online scams can be prosecuted under a range of criminal laws, including:
Fraud Act 2006
Section 2: Fraud by false representation
Section 3: Fraud by failing to disclose information
Section 4: Fraud by abuse of position
Computer Misuse Act 1990
Hacking, unauthorized access to data, DDoS attacks.
Serious Crime Act 2007
Conspiracy to commit fraud.
Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA)
Seizure and confiscation of illicit gains.
Money Laundering Regulations
III. Detailed Case Law – Online Scam Prosecutions
1. R v. Daniel Kay (2018)
Type: Business Email Compromise (BEC) Scam
Facts:
Daniel Kay was responsible for cyber attacks targeting internet service providers in Sierra Leone and Liberia. He also conducted BEC scams, sending fraudulent emails to company employees tricking them into transferring funds.
Legal Issues:
Unauthorized access to computer systems
Fraud by false representation
Conspiracy to defraud
Outcome:
Kay was sentenced to 32 months in prison.
Found guilty under the Computer Misuse Act 1990 and Fraud Act 2006.
Significance:
Set a precedent for UK nationals being prosecuted for international online scams, even when targeting foreign infrastructure.
2. R v. Grant West (2018)
Type: Phishing, Data Theft, and Online Fraud
Facts:
Grant West ran an online operation under the alias "Courvoisier" on the dark web. He phished login details from thousands of victims using fake emails posing as major retailers (e.g., Just Eat). He sold stolen data for cryptocurrency.
Legal Issues:
Fraud by false representation
Unauthorized access and selling of data
Money laundering
Outcome:
Sentenced to 10 years and 8 months in prison.
£1.6 million in cryptocurrency was seized.
Significance:
One of the largest personal data theft cases in the UK, showing law enforcement’s increasing capacity to tackle dark web crime.
3. R v. Mark Acklom (2019)
Type: Romance Scam
Facts:
Mark Acklom posed as an MI6 agent and wealthy banker to defraud a woman out of nearly £300,000 during a fake romantic relationship.
Legal Issues:
Fraud by false representation
Conspiracy to defraud
Outcome:
Acklom was sentenced to 5 years and 8 months in prison.
Found guilty under the Fraud Act 2006.
Significance:
A leading case of romance fraud, emphasizing that emotional deception used for financial gain is criminal.
4. R v. Ramani and Others (2021)
Type: Fake Investment and Crypto Scam
Facts:
The defendants created fake trading websites, claiming to invest in cryptocurrency and foreign exchange. Victims were encouraged to “invest” funds, which were then stolen.
Legal Issues:
Conspiracy to commit fraud
Fraud by abuse of position
Money laundering
Outcome:
Sentences ranged from 6 to 15 years, depending on the role.
Millions were defrauded from UK and EU citizens.
Significance:
One of the largest cryptocurrency fraud prosecutions in the UK. It confirmed that fake digital investment platforms are subject to strict criminal penalties.
5. R v. Jason Moore (2017)
Type: Online Shopping Scam
Facts:
Jason Moore ran multiple e-commerce websites advertising electronics at very low prices. Customers paid but never received the products.
Legal Issues:
Fraud by false representation
Deceptive trading practices
Outcome:
Convicted and sentenced to 6 years in prison.
Banned from running businesses for 10 years.
Significance:
Demonstrated that fraudulent online trading, even by an individual, can lead to significant jail time.
6. R v. Zain Qaiser (2019)
Type: Ransomware and Sextortion Scam
Facts:
Qaiser used pornographic websites to trap victims into downloading ransomware. He extorted money by threatening to expose their activities.
Legal Issues:
Multiple counts of blackmail, fraud, and money laundering
Computer misuse
Outcome:
Sentenced to over 6 years in prison.
Described by the NCA as a “prolific cyber criminal.”
Significance:
Landmark sextortion case showing how online scams can involve coercion and blackmail.
IV. Legal Principles Emerging from Case Law
| Principle | Application |
|---|---|
| False Representation (Fraud Act) | Covers misleading online ads, emails, or fake identities to obtain money. |
| Abuse of Position | Applies when scammers exploit trusted roles (e.g., partners, financial advisors). |
| Conspiracy to Defraud | Often used in cases involving organised scam operations. |
| Computer Misuse | Involves hacking or using malware to access systems fraudulently. |
| Money Laundering | Applies to concealment or transfer of scam proceeds through crypto or shell accounts. |
V. Common Types of Online Scams Prosecuted
Phishing: Fake emails/websites tricking victims to provide personal or financial data.
Advance Fee Fraud: Victims are promised large rewards after paying small “processing fees.”
Fake E-commerce Stores: Items listed online that are never delivered.
Tech Support Scams: Scammers pose as IT experts and charge fees for fake problems.
Crypto Scams: Fake trading or wallet apps promising high returns.
VI. Investigative and Enforcement Tools
National Crime Agency (NCA) and Action Fraud handle serious online fraud.
Cyber units in local police forces investigate smaller-scale scams.
Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA) used to recover stolen funds.
Digital forensics used to trace IP addresses, crypto transactions, and data breaches.
VII. Conclusion
Online scam prosecutions in the UK are increasing in scale and complexity. The courts treat these offences seriously due to the often devastating impact on victims—financially and emotionally. The legal system is evolving to tackle emerging threats such as cryptocurrency fraud and large-scale phishing campaigns.
The cases above illustrate that regardless of the scam type—romance, phishing, e-commerce, or ransomware—the law provides strong mechanisms for prosecution and punishment.
RELATED Blog
0 comments