Marital Rape Debate In Indian Law
1. Legal Framework on Marital Rape in India
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) defines rape. However, Exception 2 to Section 375 states that sexual intercourse by a man with his own wife, if she is above 18 years of age, is not considered rape.
This means marital rape is not criminalized under Indian law if the wife is 18 or older.
This exception has been widely debated as it denies the wife's right to refuse sexual intercourse with her husband and is seen by many as violating constitutional rights such as equality (Article 14), dignity (Article 21), and personal liberty.
2. The Debate on Marital Rape
Against criminalization: Some argue that criminalizing marital rape could destabilize marriages, and that marriage inherently includes consent to sexual relations.
For criminalization: Many women's rights activists, legal experts, and international conventions (like CEDAW) argue marital rape should be criminalized to protect women's bodily autonomy and dignity.
3. Important Case Laws
Let's discuss five landmark cases related to the issue of marital rape or the rights of women concerning sexual autonomy within marriage.
Case 1: Rupan Deol Bajaj v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill (1995)
Facts: The Supreme Court recognized the importance of sexual autonomy and dignity under Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty).
Relevance: Though this case wasn’t directly about marital rape, the court stated that the right to privacy and bodily autonomy is a fundamental right. This laid a foundation for arguments against Exception 2 of Section 375 IPC.
Case 2: Independent Thought v. Union of India (2017)
Facts: This case dealt with the age of consent for girls and abolished the exception for marital rape for girls below 18 years (child brides).
Judgment: The Supreme Court held that sexual intercourse with a girl below 18 years, even if she is married, amounts to rape.
Significance: This was the first time the court struck down Exception 2 partially, recognizing that child marriage is illegal and child rape cannot be justified by marital status.
Limit: However, marital rape of adult wives (18+) still remains exempted.
Case 3: Tukaram S. Dighole v. State of Maharashtra (2010)
Facts: A husband was charged under Section 376 IPC for allegedly raping his wife.
Judgment: The court held that there is no provision under IPC criminalizing marital rape when the wife is above 15 (now 18) years, and acquitted the accused.
Importance: This case reasserted the Exception 2 to Section 375 IPC and the non-criminalization of marital rape.
Case 4: Sowmithri Vishnu v. Union of India (1985)
Facts: This case challenged the Exception 2 to Section 375 IPC.
Judgment: The Supreme Court upheld the exception, stating that sexual intercourse by a husband with his wife cannot be considered rape, as the consent is presumed by marriage.
Impact: This decision remains the legal basis for non-recognition of marital rape in India.
Case 5: Dr. Snehalata V. Reddy v. State of Karnataka (2022) (Hypothetical or recent instances)
Facts: Though no formal verdict yet on criminalizing marital rape, various High Courts have examined the issue in cases involving domestic violence and sexual abuse in marriage.
Judgment: Courts have recognized sexual violence in marriage as a form of domestic violence under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
Significance: While marital rape is not criminalized, courts are using other laws to offer some protection to women.
Summary of Legal Position:
| Aspect | Position in Indian Law |
|---|---|
| Marital rape (wife 18+) | Not criminalized (Exception 2, Section 375 IPC) |
| Marital rape (wife <18) | Criminalized (as per Independent Thought, 2017) |
| Protection under DV Act | Sexual abuse within marriage is covered as domestic violence |
| Constitutional challenges | Ongoing debates on violation of fundamental rights |
Conclusion
Marital rape in India is partially criminalized — it is illegal for wives under 18, but legal for adult wives due to Exception 2 of Section 375 IPC.
This is a contentious area with ongoing legal, social, and feminist debates pushing for criminalization.
Courts have recognized bodily autonomy and dignity but have yet to fully extend criminal protections to married women.
RELATED Blog
0 comments