Healthcare Fraud Prosecutions
What Is Healthcare Fraud?
Healthcare fraud refers to deliberate deception or misrepresentation that results in unauthorized benefits or payments from healthcare programs. Common examples include:
Billing for services not rendered
Upcoding (billing for more expensive services)
Kickbacks for patient referrals
Falsifying patient records
Important Healthcare Fraud Cases Explained
1. United States v. Steven J. Hatfill (2007)
Facts:
Hatfill, a former government scientist, was accused of healthcare fraud related to overbilling in a medical laboratory.
Issue:
Did Hatfill knowingly submit false claims for reimbursement?
Outcome:
The charges were dropped due to insufficient evidence.
Significance:
Shows the high burden of proof in healthcare fraud prosecutions and importance of solid evidence.
2. United States v. Kenneth M. Johnson (2011)
Facts:
Johnson, a physician, was convicted for billing Medicare for unnecessary and unperformed procedures.
Issue:
Did Johnson submit fraudulent claims to Medicare?
Outcome:
Convicted and sentenced to prison; ordered to pay restitution.
Significance:
Example of prosecuting fraud involving unnecessary medical services.
3. United States v. DaVita Inc. (2018)
Facts:
DaVita, a large dialysis provider, was investigated for kickbacks to physicians for patient referrals.
Issue:
Did DaVita violate the Anti-Kickback Statute?
Outcome:
DaVita paid hundreds of millions in fines and settlements but did not admit wrongdoing.
Significance:
Shows the scale of corporate healthcare fraud enforcement.
4. United States v. Michael L. Davis (2014)
Facts:
Davis was charged for running a scheme submitting false claims for durable medical equipment.
Issue:
Was there intentional fraud in billing for equipment that was never provided?
Outcome:
Convicted and sentenced to prison.
Significance:
Demonstrates prosecution of fraud in medical device billing.
5. United States v. Jay Kim (2019)
Facts:
Kim, a chiropractor, was convicted for billing Medicare for services that were either unnecessary or never performed.
Issue:
Did Kim knowingly defraud Medicare?
Outcome:
Sentenced to prison and ordered to pay restitution.
Significance:
Highlights scrutiny on individual practitioners in Medicare fraud.
6. United States v. Global Medical Staffing Inc. (2020)
Facts:
The company was accused of submitting inflated invoices and false billing for temporary healthcare staffing.
Issue:
Was there a pattern of false claims submitted to government healthcare programs?
Outcome:
Settlement agreement included hefty fines.
Significance:
Example of fraud involving healthcare staffing agencies.
Summary Table
| Case | Fraud Type | Outcome | Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hatfill (2007) | Overbilling lab services | Charges dropped | Importance of strong evidence |
| Johnson (2011) | Unnecessary medical procedures | Conviction, prison, restitution | Prosecuting unnecessary services |
| DaVita Inc. (2018) | Physician kickbacks | Multi-million dollar settlement | Corporate fraud enforcement |
| Davis (2014) | False durable medical equipment | Conviction, prison | Device billing fraud |
| Kim (2019) | Billing for unnecessary services | Conviction, prison | Individual practitioner fraud |
| Global Medical Staffing (2020) | Inflated staffing invoices | Settlement with fines | Fraud in staffing industry |
RELATED Blog
0 comments