South Dakota Administrative Rules Title 5 - Secretary of State
Overview: South Dakota Administrative Rules Title 5 – Secretary of State
Title 5 of the South Dakota Administrative Rules governs the functions, responsibilities, and procedures of the South Dakota Secretary of State’s Office. This office is a key state administrative body responsible for a broad range of duties, including:
Administration of business filings and registrations
Oversight of elections and campaign finance disclosures
Regulation of notaries public
Administration of trademark registrations within the state
Recordkeeping and publication of official documents
The rules codify the internal procedures of the Secretary of State’s Office, specifying how statutory duties are implemented and how public interactions occur.
Key Areas Covered in Title 5
1. Business Services
Rules regulate business entity filings such as incorporation, limited liability companies (LLCs), partnerships, and assumed business names.
They define the requirements for submission, format, fees, and timelines.
Procedures for annual reports and reinstatements are included.
2. Elections
The Secretary of State administers statewide elections.
Title 5 sets forth rules regarding voter registration, candidate filings, and campaign finance reporting.
It outlines the format, deadlines, and penalties for late or incomplete filings.
Procedures for petition circulators and signature verification are included.
3. Notaries Public
Title 5 governs the appointment, renewal, and regulation of notaries.
The rules specify training requirements, application procedures, bond amounts, and grounds for suspension or revocation.
4. Trademark Registration
The Secretary of State registers state trademarks.
Rules detail the application process, renewal, and cancellation procedures.
5. Public Records and Publications
Rules require the Secretary of State to maintain official records and publish certain documents, ensuring transparency and accessibility.
Legal Authority and Framework
The Secretary of State’s Office operates under statutory authority granted by the South Dakota Codified Laws (SDCL), especially Titles related to business organizations, elections, and public records.
The administrative rules are promulgated pursuant to the South Dakota Administrative Procedures Act (APA), which provides a framework for rulemaking, public notice, and appeals.
Case Law and Legal Principles Related to Title 5
While specific cases addressing South Dakota Administrative Rules Title 5 are not abundant, several important legal principles and related case law regarding Secretary of State duties are instructive:
1. Election Law and Candidate Eligibility
Courts have consistently held that Secretaries of State have broad discretion in enforcing election laws but must act in accordance with statutes and constitutional protections.
Equal Protection: Decisions by the Secretary of State regarding ballot access or candidate disqualification must comply with equal protection guarantees.
Due Process: Candidates and voters are entitled to due process in disputes involving eligibility, ballot access, or voter registration.
Example Principle:
A Secretary of State’s refusal to certify a candidate must be supported by clear statutory grounds; arbitrary or discriminatory denials are subject to judicial review.
2. Business Filings and Corporate Authority
Courts recognize that the Secretary of State's role in business filings is primarily ministerial, meaning the office processes documents that comply with statutory requirements.
However, the office may refuse filings that do not meet legal standards.
Courts have ruled that the Secretary of State cannot interfere with the internal affairs of corporations beyond the scope of filings.
Example Principle:
If a business entity’s filing is rejected improperly, courts may compel acceptance unless the documents fail to comply with statute.
3. Notary Public Regulation
The Secretary of State’s authority to appoint and discipline notaries is well-established.
Courts have upheld suspensions or revocations based on misconduct, provided procedural safeguards are followed.
4. Administrative Procedure and Judicial Review
Actions taken by the Secretary of State under Title 5 rules are subject to review under the South Dakota Administrative Procedures Act.
Parties aggrieved by decisions (e.g., denied filings or election-related rulings) can seek administrative hearings and, subsequently, judicial review.
Courts apply a standard of review assessing whether the Secretary acted within statutory authority, followed due process, and based decisions on substantial evidence.
Illustrative Hypothetical Case Examples
Case 1: Candidate Ballot Access Challenge
A candidate is denied certification by the Secretary of State for failing to meet a filing deadline.
The candidate challenges the denial, arguing extraordinary circumstances.
The court upholds the Secretary of State’s decision, emphasizing strict adherence to statutory deadlines to maintain election integrity.
Case 2: Business Filing Rejection
An LLC filing is rejected due to an alleged defective formation document.
The business owner sues, claiming the rejection was arbitrary.
The court finds that the Secretary of State acted properly based on statutory requirements and denies relief.
Summary Table
| Area | Key Functions/Rules | Legal Principles |
|---|---|---|
| Business Filings | Formation, annual reports, reinstatements | Ministerial duties, statutory compliance |
| Elections | Candidate filings, voter registration, campaign finance | Due process, equal protection, judicial review |
| Notaries Public | Appointment, training, discipline | Discretion with procedural safeguards |
| Trademarks | Registration and renewal | Compliance with state trademark law |
| Public Records | Maintenance and publication | Transparency, public access rights |
Conclusion
The South Dakota Administrative Rules Title 5 – Secretary of State provide the regulatory framework that guides the Secretary of State in executing its wide-ranging duties, from business registrations to election oversight. While the Secretary exercises significant administrative authority, courts maintain oversight to ensure adherence to statutory mandates, due process, and constitutional protections.
RELATED Blog
0 comments