What are Ex Post Facto Laws?
Definition of Ex Post Facto Law:
An Ex Post Facto law is a law that retroactively changes the legal consequences of actions that were committed before the enactment of the law.
In simpler terms, it makes an act illegal or increases punishment after it was already committed, which was not illegal or less punishable at the time of commission.
Constitutional Provision:
Article 20(1) of the Indian Constitution:
“No person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act.”
This prohibits ex post facto criminal laws, ensuring that no one is punished for an act that was not a crime when committed.
Types of Ex Post Facto Laws:
Criminal Ex Post Facto Laws (Prohibited by Constitution)
Law that punishes an act retroactively.
Example: If a person committed theft in 2020, and in 2022 a law is passed increasing the penalty for 2020 theft, this is prohibited.
Civil Ex Post Facto Laws (Allowed in India)
Retroactive effect is allowed in civil or tax laws.
Example: Retroactive increase in tax liability is valid.
Key Features:
Retroactive Operation:
Applies to acts committed before the law was enacted.
Criminal vs Civil:
Criminal ex post facto laws are prohibited.
Civil ex post facto laws may be valid, subject to procedural safeguards.
Protection of Citizens:
Ensures certainty in law; citizens cannot be punished for acts that were legal at the time.
Important Case Law:
Kedar Nath v. State of Bihar (1962)
The Supreme Court held that retrospective penal laws violate Article 20(1).
A law increasing punishment after the commission of the offence was held unconstitutional.
Rustom Cavasjee Cooper v. Union of India (1970)
Expropriation of property through retrospective legislation was challenged.
Court emphasized protection against arbitrary retrospective laws, though in civil matters, some retroactivity is allowed.
State of Bombay v. R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla (1957)
Retroactive imposition of licensing regulations was valid because it was civil in nature, not criminal.
Significance:
Protects individual liberty: Citizens are safeguarded from arbitrary punishment.
Ensures fairness in criminal law: Acts are judged according to law in force at the time.
Guides legislative drafting: Legislators are cautious in enacting retrospective laws, especially in criminal matters.
Conclusion:
Ex Post Facto laws are laws that apply retroactively to past actions. Under Article 20(1), India strictly prohibits criminal ex post facto laws, while civil or fiscal ex post facto laws may be valid. Landmark judgments like Kedar Nath v. State of Bihar reinforce that no person can be punished for an act that was legal at the time of commission, ensuring justice, fairness, and legal certainty
RELATED Blog
0 comments