Constitutional Law at American Samoa (US)
Constitutional Law in American Samoa (U.S.) operates under a unique framework that blends both U.S. federal constitutional law and local laws established by the territorial government. American Samoa is an unincorporated territory of the United States, which means that it is under U.S. sovereignty but not fully integrated into the union as a state. The constitutional framework in American Samoa is shaped by U.S. law, the Covenant to Establish a Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, and local governance structures.
Here’s a closer look at constitutional law in American Samoa:
1. Relationship with the U.S. Constitution
American Samoa is an unincorporated U.S. territory, meaning it is part of the United States but does not have the full rights or privileges of a U.S. state. As an unincorporated territory, American Samoa is governed by a combination of federal law and local law, with some aspects of the U.S. Constitution applicable but others not directly applicable.
Federal Law: American Samoa is subject to U.S. federal law, but only to the extent that Congress determines it should apply. The U.S. Constitution generally applies to American Samoa, but the Bill of Rights (the first ten amendments to the Constitution) does not automatically apply to all U.S. territories, including American Samoa. However, many constitutional protections have been extended through federal case law.
Application of Constitutional Rights: Over the years, American Samoa has had cases where courts have considered the applicability of certain provisions of the U.S. Bill of Rights, especially in areas related to due process, free speech, and voting rights. However, the Supreme Court of the United States has ruled that certain constitutional rights, including some aspects of the Bill of Rights, do not fully apply in American Samoa due to its status as an unincorporated territory.
Samoa's Distinct Legal System: American Samoa retains a unique legal system that incorporates customary Samoan law, or fa'a Samoa, which refers to traditional cultural practices and customs that have legal significance in the territory. Fa'a Samoa influences many aspects of daily life and governance, including family law, land use, and even certain local governance practices. The incorporation of both federal law and Samoan customary law gives American Samoa a distinct constitutional and legal framework.
2. The Organic Act of American Samoa
The Organic Act of American Samoa (originally passed in 1929) serves as the primary local governing document for the territory. It outlines the structure of the territorial government and provides a framework for the relationship between the U.S. federal government and American Samoa. Key features of the Organic Act include:
Legislative Branch: The legislative body is known as the American Samoa Fono (legislature), consisting of a House of Representatives and a Senate. The Fono enacts laws for the territory, subject to approval by the U.S. Secretary of the Interior.
Executive Branch: The executive branch is headed by an elected Governor, who has significant powers, including the authority to veto legislation passed by the Fono and to issue executive orders.
Judicial Branch: The judiciary in American Samoa is headed by the High Court of American Samoa, which includes trial courts and an appellate court. The High Court has jurisdiction over local matters, including cases involving Samoan customary law.
Delegate to Congress: American Samoa elects a non-voting delegate to the U.S. House of Representatives. This delegate can participate in debates and committee work but does not have the right to vote on legislation on the House floor.
3. Customary Samoan Law (Fa'a Samoa)
A central element of American Samoa’s legal system is fa'a Samoa, the traditional Samoan way of life, which includes cultural, social, and legal norms that govern behavior and community relationships. Fa'a Samoa has a profound influence on legal matters in American Samoa, particularly in the areas of:
Land Ownership: Land in American Samoa is largely held in communal or customary titles rather than private ownership. Land cannot be sold to non-Samoans, which is a unique feature of American Samoa’s legal framework. The concept of land use and ownership is rooted in fa'a Samoa, and customary practices often determine land disputes.
Family and Social Law: Customary Samoan law also governs many aspects of family law, including marriage, inheritance, and dispute resolution. Elders, known as matai, play an important role in these matters, as they are responsible for maintaining the cultural and legal traditions of the community.
4. Samoan Customary Land and Property Law
The law surrounding land ownership in American Samoa is based heavily on Samoan customary law. While some lands are privately owned, a large portion of land is held in communal ownership under the control of local villages, chiefs, and families. Key aspects of land law include:
Alienability: Unlike most U.S. states, land in American Samoa cannot be sold to non-Samoans. This is a significant feature of American Samoa’s legal framework and reflects the desire to preserve traditional Samoan culture and way of life. The U.S. government cannot seize land in American Samoa without the express permission of the local community.
Matai System: Land disputes and other legal matters often involve the matai, or chiefs, who serve as the heads of families and communities. The matai system is essential for resolving disputes and upholding Samoan traditions and customs. This system is recognized within the legal structure of American Samoa and has the force of law in many contexts.
5. Judicial System and Courts in American Samoa
The judicial system in American Samoa operates under the High Court of American Samoa, which has jurisdiction over both local matters and certain cases involving U.S. federal law. The court system includes:
High Court of American Samoa: This court is the highest judicial authority in the territory, with the ability to hear civil and criminal cases, including those related to customary law (fa'a Samoa). The High Court is composed of a Chief Justice and Associate Justices.
Trial and Appellate Courts: The High Court includes both trial and appellate divisions. Cases that cannot be resolved at the trial level can be appealed to the appellate division of the High Court.
Customary Law Integration: The High Court incorporates Samoan customary law (fa'a Samoa) in its rulings, particularly in cases involving family law, land disputes, and community matters. The Court takes into account both federal law and traditional Samoan customs when issuing judgments.
6. Federal and Territorial Governance
As an unincorporated U.S. territory, American Samoa is subject to U.S. federal law, but with limitations. Several important points to note are:
Congressional Power: Congress has the authority to legislate for American Samoa. However, because American Samoa is an unincorporated territory, the full scope of U.S. constitutional provisions does not automatically apply, particularly those related to civil rights.
Federal Courts: While the High Court of American Samoa handles most legal matters, cases involving U.S. federal law or constitutional rights are heard in federal courts, such as the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii, which has jurisdiction over the territory.
Voting Rights: American Samoans are U.S. nationals, but not U.S. citizens by birth (unless they move to the mainland U.S.). Consequently, they do not have the right to vote in U.S. presidential elections. However, they can vote in local elections and elect a delegate to the U.S. House of Representatives.
7. Recent Developments and Legal Challenges
American Samoa has faced legal challenges related to its political and legal status, especially concerning civil rights and the full applicability of the U.S. Constitution. For instance:
Citizenship: In recent years, there have been debates and legal challenges regarding whether American Samoans should automatically be granted U.S. citizenship. The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to rule on whether American Samoans are entitled to automatic citizenship, leaving the issue unresolved.
Same-Sex Marriage: In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage nationwide, but American Samoa has maintained its traditional stance against same-sex marriage, which is in line with Samoan cultural values.
Conclusion
Constitutional law in American Samoa is shaped by the complex interaction between U.S. federal law, the Organic Act, and Samoan customary law (fa'a Samoa). As an unincorporated U.S. territory, American Samoa has its own unique legal framework that integrates federal, local, and cultural legal principles. While American Samoa is subject to U.S. sovereignty, it retains a distinct legal and cultural identity that influences many aspects of governance, law, and daily life in the territory.
RELATED Blog
0 comments