ndian Constitution is Both Rigid and Flexible Explain
The Indian Constitution is often described as both rigid and flexible, meaning it strikes a balance between adaptability and stability. Here's a clear and detailed explanation of why and how:
🧾 Why is the Indian Constitution Called Both Rigid and Flexible?
✅ Because it contains elements of both:
| Aspect | Description |
|---|---|
| Rigid | Some parts of the Constitution are difficult to amend, requiring special procedures. |
| Flexible | Other parts can be amended relatively easily, like ordinary laws. |
This dual nature was deliberately designed by the framers of the Constitution to ensure continuity and change, depending on the needs of the nation.
⚖️ Rigid Features of the Constitution
Special Procedure for Amendment (Article 368)
Certain provisions (like federal structure, judiciary, representation of states) require:
Absolute majority in both Houses of Parliament, and
Ratification by 50% of state legislatures
This ensures rigid protection to the basic structure and federal character.
Checks and Balances
Amendments must go through multiple stages, and there is no provision for referendum.
The Supreme Court can review constitutional amendments under the Basic Structure Doctrine.
Federal Features
Distribution of powers between the Centre and the States is protected and not easily alterable.
For example, changing entries in the Union, State, or Concurrent Lists requires special procedures.
🪶 Flexible Features of the Constitution
Simple Amendment Process (Under Article 368)
Many provisions (like salaries, powers of election commissions, or other non-federal matters) can be amended by a simple majority of the Parliament.
These amendments are treated like ordinary legislation.
Parliament’s Power to Alter State Boundaries (Article 3)
Unlike most federal systems, Parliament can create new states or change existing state boundaries by ordinary legislation, not constitutional amendment.
Adaptability
The Constitution is designed to be dynamic and respond to social, economic, and political changes.
The framers avoided excessive rigidity to prevent gridlock and stagnation.
📌 Examples
| Feature/Provision | Rigid or Flexible | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Amendment of Fundamental Rights | Rigid | Needs special majority + satisfies Basic Structure doctrine |
| Amendment of First Schedule (State names) | Flexible | Can be done through a simple law passed by Parliament |
| Addition of languages to 8th Schedule | Flexible | Simple majority amendment suffices |
| Change in election procedures | Rigid/Flexible | Depends on the part being changed; some need special majority |
🏁 Conclusion
The Indian Constitution is a unique blend of rigidity and flexibility. It protects the core principles and federal structure through rigid procedures, while allowing for evolution and reform through flexible methods.
⚖️ This balance helps preserve constitutional values while also adapting to changing needs, making it one of the most dynamic and enduring constitutions in the world.
Do write to us if you need any further assistance.
RELATED Blog
0 comments