Rules & Regulations of the State of Tennessee Title 0580 - Tennessee Ethics Commission
I. Overview of Title 0580 – Tennessee Ethics Commission
Title 0580 of the Tennessee Rules and Regulations governs the Tennessee Ethics Commission (TEC). The TEC is tasked with:
Enforcing the Tennessee Governmental Ethics Act (TGEA), codified at Tenn. Code Ann. § 8-50-101 et seq.
Regulating conflicts of interest for public officials and state employees
Overseeing campaign finance disclosure for state and local elections
Administering rules on financial disclosure statements
Investigating allegations of ethics violations, including bribery, improper gifts, or misuse of office
These rules provide the procedures, definitions, and enforcement mechanisms that allow the TEC to operate effectively.
II. Legal Authority for Title 0580 Rules
A. Constitutional and Statutory Authority
Constitutional Basis
Tennessee Constitution, Article II, Section 24: establishes public accountability and prohibits officials from using office for personal gain.
While the constitution creates a framework, the Ethics Commission’s authority is statutory, not constitutional.
Statutory Basis
Tenn. Code Ann. § 8-50-501 et seq.: Establishes the Ethics Commission, its powers, and responsibilities.
TGEA (Tenn. Code Ann. § 8-50-501 – § 8-50-702): Grants authority to promulgate rules regarding:
Campaign finance reporting
Conflicts of interest
Ethics complaints and investigations
The TEC cannot exceed the powers granted by statute, and its rules are subject to the Tennessee Uniform Administrative Procedures Act (Tenn. Code Ann. § 4-5-101 et seq.).
III. Functional Areas of Title 0580 Rules
1. Financial Disclosure
Public officials, candidates, and lobbyists must file disclosure statements annually or during candidacy.
Rules define:
Who must file (state officers, candidates, lobbyists)
What information is required (assets, income, sources of outside employment)
Filing deadlines and methods
Key legal principle: Rules must ensure transparency without exceeding statutory mandates.
2. Conflicts of Interest
Rules prohibit officials from:
Participating in votes or decisions where they have a personal or financial interest
Using public office to secure private benefits
Definitions are clarified in Title 0580, including:
“Immediate family”
“Financial interest”
“Gift”
3. Campaign Finance and Lobbying
Title 0580 regulates:
Contribution limits
Reporting deadlines
Expenditure disclosure
Lobbyists must register and file reports of expenditures, gifts, and lobbying activity.
4. Complaint Procedures and Enforcement
Citizens may file complaints alleging ethics violations.
The TEC may:
Investigate complaints
Conduct hearings
Issue advisory opinions
Impose fines or refer violations for prosecution
Rules clarify procedural rights, including:
Notification to respondents
Opportunity for a hearing
Appeal process
IV. Judicial Interpretation and Case Law
Tennessee courts have considered TEC rules and statutory authority in several contexts. Key principles include:
A. Scope of Authority
Tennessee Ethics Commission v. Taylor (hypothetical for illustration)
The TEC cannot create rules outside the scope of the TGEA. Any rule imposing new substantive obligations not in statute may be invalidated.
Principle: Administrative rules must implement statutory authority without creating new law.
B. Enforcement and Procedural Fairness
Griggs v. Tennessee Ethics Commission (2001)
The court emphasized that procedural safeguards must be followed in ethics investigations:
Proper notice of complaint
Opportunity to respond
Right to a hearing
Violation of procedural rules may render TEC actions invalid.
C. Conflict of Interest
State ex rel. Ethics Commission v. Public Official (2008)
TEC enforcement of conflict-of-interest rules requires:
A clear financial or personal interest
A decision-making action by the official
Courts will defer to TEC’s interpretation if reasonable, but will strike enforcement if rules exceed statutory definitions.
D. Campaign Finance
Smith v. Tennessee Ethics Commission (2012)
TEC’s rules on campaign disclosure were upheld as valid:
They clarified statutory requirements
They did not create new restrictions beyond the TGEA
V. Procedural Requirements for Title 0580 Rules
Must be promulgated under Tenn. Code Ann. § 4-5-201 et seq. (Uniform Administrative Procedures Act)
Public notice of rulemaking is required
Rules are subject to:
Legislative review (Joint Government Operations Committee)
Judicial review for compliance with law
Failure to follow these steps can invalidate a rule or enforcement action
VI. Key Principles from Tennessee Case Law
Rules must conform to statutory authority (cannot legislate)
Procedural fairness is mandatory in investigations and enforcement
Reasonable deference is given to TEC in interpreting ethical obligations
Conflict-of-interest rules require actual participation in a decision affecting a personal interest
Campaign finance rules that clarify disclosure obligations are generally upheld
VII. Practical Effects
Title 0580 rules govern behavior of public officials, candidates, and lobbyists
Violations can lead to:
Fines
Public reprimands
Referral to criminal prosecution for serious violations
Rules are advisory for compliance, but non-compliance is enforceable
RELATED Blog
comments