Supreme Court Revisits Laws on Surrogacy for NRIs and Foreign Nationals
- ByAdmin --
- 31 May 2025 --
- 0 Comments
The Supreme Court of India has recently taken a critical stance on the laws governing surrogacy for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) and foreign nationals, sparking renewed debate on the legal framework that regulates this sensitive and complex subject. This article delves into the legal provisions involved, the recent developments by the Supreme Court, and the implications for NRIs and foreign nationals seeking surrogacy in India.
Background: Surrogacy Laws in India
India has long been a preferred destination for surrogacy due to advanced medical infrastructure and cost-effectiveness. However, ethical and legal challenges led to the enactment of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, which aims to regulate surrogacy practices, prohibit commercial surrogacy, and protect the rights of surrogate mothers and children born through surrogacy.
- The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 prohibits commercial surrogacy and allows only altruistic surrogacy.
- The Act mandates that surrogacy is permissible only for Indian couples married for at least five years and unable to conceive naturally.
- It explicitly excludes NRIs, foreign nationals, and same-sex couples from eligibility to avail of surrogacy services in India.
The Supreme Court’s Intervention
Recently, the Supreme Court has revisited the restrictions placed on NRIs and foreign nationals under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act. The Court is examining whether these restrictions are constitutionally valid and in conformity with the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Indian Constitution.
Key Issues Under Consideration:
- Right to Equality (Article 14): Whether denying surrogacy services to NRIs and foreign nationals violates the principle of equality before the law.
- Right to Privacy and Family Life: Whether the restriction interferes with the right to make reproductive choices, which is increasingly recognized as part of the right to privacy under Article 21.
- Citizenship and Parentage Rights: The legal status of children born to foreign nationals or NRIs through surrogacy and their citizenship rights under the Citizenship Act, 1955.
Legal Challenges to the Current Restrictions
Many NRIs and foreign nationals have challenged the provisions of the Surrogacy Act on grounds that the restrictions are arbitrary and discriminatory. The principal arguments presented include:
- Violation of Article 14 (Equality Before Law): The law distinguishes between Indian citizens and non-citizens without adequate justification.
- Contravention of Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty): The right to reproductive autonomy includes the right to seek surrogacy as a method of parenthood.
- International Human Rights Standards: The restrictions might conflict with international conventions like the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), which emphasizes the best interests of the child.
Implications for Surrogacy Practices
If the Supreme Court relaxes restrictions for NRIs and foreign nationals, this could have several ramifications:
- Legal Clarity on Surrogacy Agreements: The Court may provide guidelines on how to regulate surrogacy contracts involving foreign nationals to prevent exploitation.
- Citizenship and Parentage Legal Framework: Clearer laws might be needed to establish the nationality and parentage of children born through surrogacy to foreign parents.
- Regulatory Oversight: Strengthened oversight by the National Surrogacy Board to ensure ethical compliance and welfare of surrogate mothers.
Comparative International Perspectives
Many countries have varying laws on surrogacy:
- The United States permits commercial surrogacy, with regulations varying by state.
- The United Kingdom allows altruistic surrogacy but restricts commercial surrogacy.
- Countries like Thailand and Nepal have banned commercial surrogacy to prevent exploitation.
India’s evolving stance, especially under judicial scrutiny, might align more with global human rights principles and ethical norms.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s revisiting of surrogacy laws for NRIs and foreign nationals is a landmark step in balancing ethical concerns with individual reproductive rights. While the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, attempts to prevent exploitation and regulate surrogacy, the current exclusion of NRIs and foreigners raises important constitutional questions.
A nuanced and balanced legal framework that safeguards surrogate mothers, ensures the welfare of children, and respects the reproductive rights of all individuals, regardless of nationality, could emerge from the Court’s deliberations. Legal reforms in this area will continue to be closely watched by medical professionals, human rights advocates, and prospective parents worldwide.
RELATED Blog
0 comments