Professional Ethics at Maldives
Professional ethics in the Maldives are shaped by the country’s unique socio-cultural, legal, and economic context. The Maldives, an island nation in the Indian Ocean, has a predominantly Muslim population, which influences its legal and ethical frameworks. As a developing country with a growing economy, the Maldives faces significant challenges in ensuring ethical conduct across various sectors, such as public service, business, healthcare, and media. The nation’s efforts to address corruption, governance issues, and professional accountability are crucial for its ongoing development and international relationships.
1. Legal and Institutional Framework
Constitutional Basis: The Constitution of the Maldives (adopted in 2008) provides a framework for human rights, the rule of law, and governance. The Constitution guarantees fundamental rights and freedoms, including the right to a fair trial and freedom of expression, which are essential for upholding professional ethics in various sectors.
Anti-Corruption Measures: The Maldives has made strides in creating anti-corruption frameworks, with the establishment of the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) and the Corruption Prevention Act. However, corruption remains a significant challenge, particularly in the public sector, and continues to impact ethical standards in governance and business.
Shariah Law Influence: As a predominantly Muslim country, the Maldives’ legal and ethical standards are influenced by Islamic law (Shariah), which affects personal behavior, business ethics, and public service. This cultural context plays a role in shaping professional ethics in areas such as banking, healthcare, and public administration.
International Influence: The Maldives is a member of the United Nations (UN) and the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), as well as a participant in the OECD and World Bank initiatives, which influence its ethical frameworks, particularly in terms of anti-corruption measures, human rights, and corporate governance.
2. Key Sectors and Professional Ethics
Public Sector
Code of Ethics: Public servants in the Maldives are required to adhere to a Code of Conduct, which outlines principles of integrity, impartiality, accountability, and transparency. These standards aim to ensure that government employees serve the public interest and act without bias.
Political Patronage: A major ethical issue in the public sector is political patronage. In a small, close-knit society, government appointments can sometimes be influenced by political loyalty rather than merit, undermining ethical standards and public trust.
Corruption and Governance: The Maldives has faced significant corruption issues, particularly in the allocation of government contracts, public funds, and land development projects. Despite legal reforms and anti-corruption measures, challenges remain in holding individuals accountable and enforcing ethical standards within the public sector.
Whistleblower Protection: While there are legal provisions for whistleblower protection, including the Whistleblower Protection Act, there are concerns about the effectiveness of these protections in practice, as individuals may fear retaliation for reporting unethical behavior, particularly within government circles.
Healthcare
Medical Ethics: Healthcare professionals in the Maldives, including doctors, nurses, and allied health professionals, are guided by the Medical Council’s Code of Ethics, which emphasizes patient care, confidentiality, informed consent, and professional integrity. The Maldives’ healthcare system, which is heavily dependent on foreign expertise and resources, faces ethical challenges related to limited access to services, especially in remote island communities.
Corruption and Resource Allocation: The healthcare sector faces ethical dilemmas related to the distribution of resources. As a result of limited infrastructure and personnel, there is often a need to make tough ethical decisions about prioritizing care. Corruption in procurement, bribery for medical services, and favoritism in treatment allocation have been reported.
Healthcare Access: The Maldives struggles with disparities in healthcare access between urban areas (primarily the capital, Malé) and the outer islands, raising ethical concerns about equity and the fair distribution of medical services.
Legal and Judicial Ethics
Judicial Independence: The Maldives’ legal system is based on both Islamic law (Shariah) and civil law traditions. Judicial ethics are governed by principles of impartiality, fairness, and the avoidance of conflicts of interest. However, concerns about political influence over the judiciary have been raised, especially in high-profile cases involving political leaders or business elites.
Legal Profession Ethics: Lawyers in the Maldives are expected to adhere to standards of honesty, fairness, and confidentiality, as outlined by the Maldives Bar Association. However, issues such as client conflict, corruption, and political influence can sometimes compromise ethical practices within the legal profession.
Rule of Law: The rule of law and judicial independence have been challenged in recent years due to political tensions and the perception of bias in the judiciary, especially in cases involving opposition politicians or government officials. Ensuring the impartiality of the legal system is an ongoing ethical challenge.
Business and Corporate Ethics
Corporate Governance: The Maldives has laws that govern corporate ethics, including the Companies Act and Capital Market Development Authority (CMDA) regulations, which are designed to ensure transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct in business practices. However, challenges remain in terms of enforcement, especially in the tourism and construction sectors, where issues such as bribery, kickbacks, and unfair business practices are not uncommon.
Tourism Industry: The Maldives’ economy is heavily dependent on tourism, and ethical challenges in this sector include labor rights, environmental sustainability, and community relations. There have been concerns about the exploitation of low-wage workers in the hospitality industry, as well as environmental degradation caused by large-scale hotel developments on the islands.
Environmental Ethics: The Maldives faces serious environmental challenges, particularly related to climate change, overfishing, and marine pollution. Ethical issues arise in balancing economic development with environmental sustainability, especially in the tourism and fishing industries. The country has made significant international commitments to environmental protection but struggles with enforcement at the local level.
Media and Journalism
Press Freedom: The Maldives has made progress in media freedom, but ethical challenges persist, particularly with respect to self-censorship and governmental influence over the press. Journalists in the Maldives must navigate a challenging environment where political sensitivities and threats of legal action may stifle investigative reporting.
Journalistic Ethics: Journalists are expected to report with accuracy, impartiality, and fairness. However, media outlets in the Maldives are often subject to government pressure, and ethical dilemmas arise when media companies are owned by political figures or business interests, which can affect editorial independence.
Defamation and Censorship: Journalists and media organizations in the Maldives must also navigate legal risks associated with defamation and censorship, especially when reporting on political issues or government corruption. The Defamation Act and other legal frameworks limit the freedom of the press, which creates ethical concerns around the public’s right to know and the press's ability to hold power to account.
Education
Academic Integrity: In the education sector, ethical issues primarily concern academic integrity, fairness in assessments, and equal access to educational opportunities. There are concerns about corruption in the allocation of scholarships, favoritism in university admissions, and plagiarism in academic work.
Access to Education: The Maldives has made significant strides in expanding access to education, but challenges remain in providing quality education to children in remote islands. Ethical concerns include the equitable distribution of educational resources and the inclusion of marginalized groups in the education system.
Religious and Political Influence: In a country where Islam plays a central role in public life, ethical concerns also arise regarding the role of religion in education, particularly in relation to curriculum content and the balance between secular and religious teachings.
3. Ethical Challenges in the Maldives
Corruption and Governance: Corruption remains one of the most pressing ethical challenges in the Maldives, particularly in government contracting, the judicial system, and business transactions. Efforts to strengthen anti-corruption institutions have been hampered by political instability and a lack of effective enforcement.
Political Influence: The Maldives has a history of political instability, and political patronage often influences appointments, promotions, and the distribution of resources in both the public and private sectors. This undermines ethical conduct and public trust in institutions.
Environmental Sustainability: Ethical dilemmas related to environmental degradation and climate change are critical in the Maldives, especially given its vulnerability to rising sea levels. Balancing economic growth through tourism and the protection of natural resources poses a significant ethical challenge for the government and businesses.
Freedom of Expression and Press Freedom: Journalists in the Maldives face legal and political risks when reporting on sensitive issues, particularly corruption and government practices. Ethical challenges arise when media outlets are pressured or censored by the government, limiting the role of the press in promoting accountability.
4. International Standards and Influence
United Nations and International Law: As a member of the United Nations (UN), the Maldives is bound by international agreements and conventions that shape its ethical standards, particularly in human rights, governance, and environmental protection. The country has ratified international agreements such as the Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) and the UN Declaration on Human Rights.
Sustainability Commitments: The Maldives has committed to environmental sustainability and climate change mitigation through international agreements such as the Paris Agreement. However, ethical concerns around environmental protection remain, particularly in industries such as tourism and fishing.
Conclusion
Professional ethics in the Maldives are influenced by a combination of legal frameworks, Islamic cultural values, and international standards. While the country has made progress in developing ethical guidelines across various sectors, challenges remain, particularly in terms of corruption, political influence, environmental sustainability, and press freedom. Strengthening enforcement mechanisms, promoting transparency, and fostering a culture of accountability will be key to addressing these challenges and ensuring ethical conduct in the Maldives' professional sectors.
RELATED Blog
0 comments