Voluntary Arbitration in Labour Law
Voluntary Arbitration in Labour Law
What is Voluntary Arbitration?
Voluntary Arbitration in labour disputes is a process where the disputing parties — typically employers and employees or their representatives (like trade unions) — agree to submit their disagreement to an impartial third party (arbitrator) to reach a binding or non-binding decision.
The key word is "voluntary" — both parties must consent to arbitration.
It is an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) method, aimed at settling disputes without resorting to strikes, lockouts, or lengthy court battles.
Purpose of Voluntary Arbitration
To provide a speedy, effective, and less formal resolution of labour disputes.
To maintain industrial peace and harmony by resolving conflicts amicably.
To reduce the burden on courts and labour tribunals.
To ensure a binding or agreed settlement acceptable to both parties.
How Voluntary Arbitration Works
Agreement to Arbitrate:
Both parties consent to arbitration—either before the dispute arises (pre-dispute arbitration clause) or after the dispute has occurred.
Appointment of Arbitrator:
An impartial arbitrator or a panel is chosen mutually by the parties.
Sometimes, a labour commissioner or a neutral body may assist in selection.
Submission of Dispute:
Parties present their claims and evidence before the arbitrator.
Hearing and Decision:
Arbitrator conducts hearings in a less formal manner than courts.
After examining arguments, the arbitrator issues an award or decision.
Enforcement:
Depending on agreement, the award can be binding or advisory.
If binding, parties must comply; otherwise, courts may enforce the award.
Advantages of Voluntary Arbitration
Faster resolution compared to courts.
Less formal and more flexible.
Encourages cooperation and preserves relationships.
Confidentiality of proceedings.
Reduces industrial unrest by avoiding strikes and lockouts.
Role of Courts in Voluntary Arbitration
Courts generally respect the arbitration agreement and awards.
Courts may enforce arbitration awards but do not interfere with the merits.
Only in cases of fraud, bias, or violation of natural justice can awards be challenged.
Relevant Case Law Examples
1. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Employees’ Union
Facts:
A dispute arose between Bharat Petroleum and its employees over wage revision. The parties agreed to submit the matter to voluntary arbitration.
Judgment/Principle:
The court upheld the principle of voluntary arbitration, emphasizing that when parties willingly opt for arbitration, the award must be respected unless there is a procedural irregularity or unfairness.
2. Workmen of J.K. Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills v. Management
Facts:
Employees and management agreed to resolve a wage dispute through voluntary arbitration.
Judgment/Principle:
The court held that voluntary arbitration is an effective means of resolving disputes and that courts should encourage and support arbitration awards unless there is clear proof of misconduct or injustice.
3. Hindustan Steel Ltd. v. Workmen
Facts:
Dispute over service conditions was referred to voluntary arbitration. The arbitrator gave an award favoring the employees.
Judgment/Principle:
The court recognized the importance of voluntary arbitration as a tool for industrial peace and directed parties to comply with the award.
Limitations of Voluntary Arbitration
Requires mutual consent; cannot be forced.
Parties may still resort to strikes or lockouts if dissatisfied.
Arbitration awards may not be final if parties agree to non-binding arbitration.
Possible delay if parties fail to cooperate in appointing arbitrators.
Summary Table
| Aspect | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Definition | Dispute resolution by consent through an impartial third party |
| Consent | Must be voluntary; agreement essential |
| Arbitrator | Neutral third party or panel chosen by parties |
| Decision | Binding or advisory depending on agreement |
| Role of Courts | Enforce awards, minimal interference |
| Advantages | Speedy, less formal, maintains industrial peace |
| Limitations | Consent-based, may not be final, potential delays |
Conclusion
Voluntary Arbitration is a vital mechanism in labour law that promotes amicable and efficient dispute resolution. Courts strongly favor arbitration as it minimizes industrial conflict and provides a balanced forum for settlement. The judiciary supports voluntary arbitration awards unless procedural fairness is compromised.
RELATED Blog
0 comments