Human Rights Law at Hungary
Human rights law in Hungary is governed by national constitutional provisions, European Union law, and international treaties. However, in recent years, Hungary has faced significant criticism from international human rights bodies and the European Union (EU) for its perceived erosion of democratic norms and human rights protections.
Here’s an overview of the human rights law situation in Hungary:
1. Legal Framework
Constitution: The Fundamental Law of Hungary, which came into effect in 2012, guarantees various fundamental rights, including:
Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, religion, press, and association
Right to a fair trial, privacy, and freedom from discrimination
European Union Law: As an EU member state, Hungary is bound by EU human rights standards, including:
Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union: This document guarantees a wide range of civil, political, economic, and social rights.
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR): Hungary is a party to the ECHR, which provides additional protections for human rights, including freedom from torture, right to a fair trial, freedom of expression, and protection from discrimination.
International Treaties: Hungary is a signatory to numerous international human rights agreements, such as:
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)
Convention Against Torture (CAT)
These international instruments obligate Hungary to uphold the rights of individuals within its jurisdiction.
2. Civil and Political Rights
Freedom of Speech and Press: Hungary has a robust legal framework protecting freedom of expression. However, in recent years, there has been concern over media freedom, with many independent media outlets facing pressure or being shut down.
The government’s control over public media and its influence on private media are increasingly cited as violations of press freedom.
Journalists and media organizations that criticize the government have faced harassment, intimidation, and legal challenges.
Freedom of Assembly and Association: The Hungarian Constitution guarantees the right to peaceful assembly, but recent laws restricting demonstrations and tightening NGO regulations have raised concerns.
In 2018, Hungary introduced a controversial law on foreign-funded NGOs, which has been seen as a restriction on freedom of association and political expression.
The Stop Soros law (2018) targeted organizations helping migrants and refugees, restricting their activities and imposing criminal penalties for aiding illegal immigration.
Political Rights: Hungary's political system has been increasingly criticized for undermining democratic norms. Opposition parties and activists face significant challenges, and there are concerns about the freedom and fairness of elections.
Electoral laws have been criticized for being gerrymandered in favor of the ruling party, and there have been increasing concerns about limitations on political pluralism and the independence of the judiciary.
3. Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights
Labor Rights: Hungary has labor protections that guarantee rights to unionize, strike, and receive fair wages. However, in 2018, the government introduced a new labor law often called the "Slave Law", which allows employers to demand overtime work without proper compensation, causing significant public outcry.
This law has led to large-scale protests by workers and unions, highlighting issues with workers' rights and conditions.
Social Rights: Hungary faces challenges related to poverty, healthcare, and education:
Healthcare is a significant issue in Hungary, with reports of overcrowded hospitals, inadequate healthcare resources, and long waiting times.
Education is another area of concern, particularly due to the influence of the government on the curriculum and the growing trend of privatization of education.
LGBTQ+ Rights: The Hungarian government has been criticized for its stance on LGBTQ+ rights, particularly regarding the legal recognition of same-sex couples and adoption rights. In 2020, the government passed legislation that effectively bans same-sex couples from adopting children and restricted the legal recognition of gender changes.
4. Rule of Law and Judicial Independence
Judicial Independence: Hungary’s judiciary is officially independent, but there are widespread concerns about the government’s influence over the judicial system. Reforms have been implemented that critics argue reduce the independence of the judiciary and undermine the rule of law.
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and the EU have criticized Hungary for its interference with judicial independence, particularly in cases related to corruption, freedom of expression, and political rights.
Rule of Law: Hungary’s constitutional and legal framework provides protections for human rights, but recent constitutional amendments and laws have been seen as eroding these rights, particularly in the areas of democratic governance and individual freedoms. The EU has taken legal action against Hungary for its breaches of EU laws and its disregard for fundamental rights.
5. Rights of Minorities
Roma Rights: The Roma community in Hungary faces discrimination, segregation, and limited access to quality education and healthcare. While the government has introduced some policies aimed at improving their situation, progress has been slow, and incidents of hate crimes and discrimination remain prevalent.
Refugee and Migrant Rights: Hungary has been at the center of debates about migration and refugee policies in Europe. The government has taken a strong stance against migration and has implemented anti-refugee laws, such as the border fence to block migrants from entering the country. These policies have been criticized for their violation of refugee rights and their disregard for international obligations under the 1951 Refugee Convention.
6. European Union and International Criticism
European Union: Hungary’s human rights record has increasingly been scrutinized by the European Union. The EU has taken several legal actions against Hungary over its undermining of democratic norms and human rights protections. In 2018, the European Parliament triggered the Article 7 procedure (a mechanism to suspend a country’s voting rights in the EU) due to concerns about rule of law and fundamental rights.
United Nations and NGOs: Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and other NGOs have criticized Hungary for its human rights violations, particularly in the areas of press freedom, judicial independence, discrimination, and LGBTQ+ rights.
Conclusion
While Hungary guarantees fundamental rights in its Constitution and under international law, in recent years, government policies have increasingly been seen as undermining those rights. Issues such as press freedom, LGBTQ+ rights, judicial independence, and democratic participation are areas of significant concern, both domestically and internationally. Hungary's relationship with the European Union and its human rights obligations will continue to be a key focus moving forward.
RELATED Blog
0 comments