Insolvency Law at Pakistan
Pakistan's insolvency framework is governed by a combination of colonial-era statutes, contemporary corporate law, and evolving reform initiatives. The legal landscape is fragmented, with separate regimes for individual and corporate insolvency, and a lack of a unified insolvency code.
🧾 Individual Insolvency: Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920
The Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920 applies to individuals and unincorporated entities. Key features include: (Liquidation and Bankruptcy in Pakistan: A Comprehensive Overview - 24 Justice PK)
Eligibility: Debtors must be unable to pay debts amounting to at least ₹500.
Petition Filing: Debtors or creditors can file a petition in the district court.
Trustee Appointment: The court appoints a receiver to manage the debtor's estate.
Asset Distribution: Assets are liquidated, and proceeds are distributed among creditors.
Discharge: Debtors may be discharged from remaining debts after fulfilling obligations. (Creditor Winding up of Limited Companies in Pakistan Courting The Law, Liquidation and Bankruptcy in Pakistan: A Comprehensive Overview - 24 Justice PK)
However, this Act is outdated and lacks provisions for modern financial instruments and corporate structures. It is also limited to individuals and unincorporated entities, leaving corporations under a different legal framework.
🏢 Corporate Insolvency: Companies Ordinance, 1984
For corporations, the Companies Ordinance, 1984 governs insolvency proceedings. Key aspects include:
Winding Up: Companies can be wound up by the court if they are unable to pay debts exceeding ₹50,000 or 1% of paid-up capital.
Petition Filing: Creditors must serve a formal notice requiring payment within 30 days before filing a petition.
Court's Role: The court assesses the company's inability to pay debts and may order winding up. (Creditor Winding up of Limited Companies in Pakistan Courting The Law)
This framework primarily focuses on liquidation and lacks provisions for corporate rehabilitation or restructuring.
⚠️ Challenges in the Current System
Fragmentation: Separate laws for individual and corporate insolvency lead to inconsistent procedures and outcomes.
Outdated Legislation: Existing laws do not address modern financial complexities, such as cross-border insolvencies or corporate restructuring.
Lack of Rehabilitation Mechanisms: There are limited provisions for rehabilitating distressed businesses, focusing primarily on liquidation.
Judicial Delays: Prolonged court proceedings can hinder timely resolution of insolvency cases.
🛠️ Reform Initiatives
Recognizing these challenges, there have been calls for comprehensive insolvency reform:
Corporate Rehabilitation Act: A draft bill aimed at introducing a modern insolvency framework, including provisions for corporate rehabilitation, has been under consideration since 2007 but has not been enacted. (Why Pakistan desperately needs bankruptcy reform - DAWN.COM)
Banking Law Review Commission: The Commission has proposed reforms to streamline insolvency procedures and promote business recovery.
Despite these efforts, progress has been slow, and a unified insolvency code remains absent. (Josh and Mak International)
📌 Practical Considerations
Legal Assistance: Given the complexity and fragmentation of insolvency laws, seeking legal counsel is advisable for navigating proceedings.
Creditors' Vigilance: Creditors should monitor debtors' financial health and initiate proceedings promptly to protect their interests.
Policy Advocacy: Engaging with policymakers can help accelerate the enactment of comprehensive insolvency reforms.
In summary, Pakistan's insolvency framework is characterized by outdated and fragmented laws, posing challenges for both debtors and creditors. While reform initiatives are underway, the absence of a unified insolvency code hampers effective resolution of insolvency cases. (Josh and Mak International)
RELATED Blog
0 comments