Insolvency Law at Canada
Insolvency law in Canada is designed to provide a framework for dealing with individuals and businesses that are unable to meet their financial obligations. The main laws governing insolvency and bankruptcy in Canada are primarily found under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), as well as the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), and various provincial laws that can apply in specific cases.
Key Aspects of Insolvency Law in Canada:
Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA):
The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) is the primary piece of federal legislation governing the insolvency process for individuals, businesses, and corporations in Canada.
It applies to individuals and businesses that are unable to pay their debts and sets out the procedures for both voluntary and involuntary bankruptcy filings.
The BIA includes provisions for personal bankruptcy, corporate bankruptcy, and proposal processes (a type of debt restructuring process).
The BIA is administered by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB), a division of the federal government responsible for overseeing insolvency proceedings.
Personal Insolvency (Individual Bankruptcy):
For individuals, the BIA outlines a procedure for personal bankruptcy, which allows individuals to discharge certain debts after a set period (usually 9 months, though this can be extended depending on the individual's income and other factors).
A bankrupt individual will have their assets liquidated by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), and the proceeds will be used to repay creditors in a legally defined priority order.
An individual can also enter into a Consumer Proposal, which allows them to offer creditors a settlement (often a reduced amount) to avoid full bankruptcy.
There is a discharge process, which may take between 9 to 21 months depending on income levels and the number of filings an individual has had in the past.
Exemptions: Certain assets, like basic household goods, tools of the trade, and a primary residence (up to a limit), may be exempt from seizure during bankruptcy.
Corporate Insolvency:
For companies, the BIA offers a Division I Proposal option, which is similar to the U.S. Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection process. This allows businesses to restructure their debts and operations while continuing to operate. It offers a way for companies to avoid liquidation, provided they can reach an agreement with creditors.
If a company is unable to reach an agreement under a proposal or continues to fail to meet its financial obligations, it may proceed to liquidation under the BIA.
Winding up: The company’s assets are liquidated, and the proceeds are distributed to creditors in a specific order of priority.
Companies can also be liquidated under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) if the company has debts exceeding $5 million. The CCAA provides a more flexible approach to corporate restructuring, often involving negotiations with creditors and stakeholders.
Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA):
The CCAA is designed for larger corporations facing insolvency, and it allows companies to restructure their debts under the supervision of the court. This law provides a formal mechanism for companies to negotiate with creditors and attempt to return to profitability, without the need to go into liquidation.
It is typically used by businesses that have debts exceeding $5 million, as the BIA’s provisions for corporate insolvency apply only to smaller businesses.
Under the CCAA, companies may be given protection from creditors (a “stay of proceedings”) for a period, allowing time to propose a restructuring plan. The plan must be approved by the creditors and the court.
Role of the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT):
A Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) plays a central role in the bankruptcy process in Canada. These professionals are licensed by the federal government and are responsible for administering bankruptcies and proposals.
They act as intermediaries between the debtor and creditors, helping to ensure the proper legal procedures are followed. They are responsible for reviewing financial information, filing necessary documents with the court, and overseeing the liquidation of assets or implementation of a proposal.
For individuals, the LIT will handle the bankruptcy and consumer proposal processes, while for companies, the LIT may serve as the trustee overseeing the liquidation or restructuring.
Creditor’s Rights and Priority:
Under the BIA, there is a priority system for how debts are repaid during insolvency proceedings.
Secured creditors (those with collateral) are paid first.
Preferred creditors (including employees with unpaid wages and pension contributions) are paid next.
Unsecured creditors (such as credit card debt holders, suppliers, and vendors) are paid after secured and preferred creditors.
Shareholders are last in line and typically receive nothing if a company is liquidated.
Insolvency and Employment Law:
Insolvency law in Canada also intersects with employment law. Employees whose employer files for bankruptcy have specific rights under the BIA and are considered preferred creditors for unpaid wages, vacation pay, and pension contributions, up to certain limits.
In the case of bankruptcy, employees are given priority for compensation, though there may be limitations on the amount they can claim.
International Insolvency:
Canada is a signatory to various international conventions, such as the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency. This allows Canadian insolvency proceedings to be recognized and coordinated with those in other jurisdictions, helping businesses and individuals with international debts or assets navigate insolvency processes more smoothly.
Recent Developments and Reforms:
There have been ongoing discussions in Canada about reforming insolvency law, particularly around improving corporate restructuring mechanisms, increasing transparency in the bankruptcy process, and making it easier for individuals to navigate the consumer proposal process.
There have been reforms to encourage reorganization over liquidation, particularly for businesses that may have a viable path to recovery but need time to restructure debts.
Key Challenges and Criticisms:
Complexity: The insolvency process can be complex, particularly for corporations seeking to restructure under the CCAA or BIA. The legal and financial requirements can be burdensome.
Cost of Restructuring: For businesses, restructuring under the CCAA can be expensive and time-consuming, often involving a significant amount of legal and administrative fees.
Effect on Creditors: While the BIA and CCAA provide some protections for creditors, the process often leaves unsecured creditors with little to no recovery in liquidation scenarios.
Conclusion:
Insolvency law in Canada is structured to provide both individuals and businesses with avenues to address their financial difficulties, ranging from liquidation to restructuring. The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) offers a comprehensive legal framework for dealing with both personal and corporate insolvency. For individuals, personal bankruptcy or consumer proposals offer a path to debt relief, while companies facing significant debts can use the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) or proposals under the BIA to attempt to reorganize and avoid liquidation. The system provides various protections to creditors and ensures fair distribution of assets during insolvency proceedings. However, the process can be complex and costly, particularly for larger corporations.
RELATED Blog
0 comments