De minimis – About minimal things.
Meaning:
De minimis is a Latin term which means “about minimal things” or “trifling matters.”
In legal context, it refers to matters that are too trivial or minor to merit consideration by the court.
In simpler words:
If something is so small or insignificant that it doesn’t affect the law or the rights of a person, it can be ignored as de minimis.
Key Points:
Insignificant matters: The law does not concern itself with very minor issues.
Threshold principle: Helps courts focus on substantial and meaningful disputes rather than trivial ones.
Widely used in: Civil law, criminal law, intellectual property, contract law, tax law, and regulatory matters.
Examples in Law:
Civil Law:
A very small trespass on land, like a branch of a tree slightly crossing a neighbor’s property line, might be considered de minimis. The court may refuse to intervene because it is trivial.
Criminal Law:
Taking an object of extremely low value, such as a pen from a store accidentally, may sometimes be considered de minimis and not pursued as a crime.
Tax Law:
Minor rounding errors or negligible amounts in tax filings may be ignored as de minimis.
Case Law Example (India):
1. State of Maharashtra v. Dr. Praful B. Desai (2003) 4 SCC 601
Facts: The court discussed matters which were minor or trivial in the context of professional negligence.
Held: Courts may ignore acts which are de minimis and focus on substantial breaches that cause material harm.
2. K.K. Verma v. Union of India (1963 AIR 1289)
Fact: Small procedural lapses in administrative work were argued as violations.
Held: The court held that minor lapses, which do not prejudice anyone materially, are de minimis and do not attract legal consequences.
Key Takeaways:
Principle: The law does not concern itself with trivialities (“De minimis non curat lex” – the law does not concern itself with trifles).
Ensures judicial efficiency by preventing courts from wasting time on insignificant matters.
Often acts as a shield for minor, inconsequential acts in law.
RELATED Blog
0 comments