Law of Evidence at Tunisia
Tunisia's legal framework governing the law of evidence is primarily encapsulated in the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures. These codes outline the principles and rules concerning the admissibility, evaluation, and presentation of evidence in both criminal and civil proceedings. (Law No. 2010-36 of July 5, 2010, on Amendments to Certain Provisions of the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures, Tunisia, WIPO Lex)
🏛️ Constitutional and Legal Foundations
The Tunisian Constitution of 2022 enshrines the right to a fair trial, which implicitly includes the right to present and challenge evidence in court. This constitutional guarantee ensures that individuals have access to justice and due process . (Tunisian Constitution of 2022)
⚖️ Criminal Procedure: Code of Criminal Procedure
1. Presumption of Innocence and Burden of Proof
Tunisian law upholds the presumption of innocence, stipulating that the prosecution bears the burden of proof. This principle ensures that an accused person is not compelled to prove their innocence .
2. Admissibility of Evidence
Article 151 of the Code of Criminal Procedure mandates that judges base their decisions solely on evidence presented during the trial proceedings and discussed openly among the parties involved. This ensures transparency and fairness in the judicial process . (THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE IN TUNISIA:)
3. Confessions and Coerced Statements
Confessions obtained through torture or coercion are explicitly prohibited. Article 155, introduced by Decree No. 106/2011, renders any statement or confession made under such circumstances invalid and inadmissible in court .
4. Witness Testimony
Witnesses are required to take an oath before testifying. Their testimonies must be given in the presence of the accused, and they are subject to cross-examination to ensure the reliability and credibility of their statements . (Code of Criminal Procedure (approved by Law No. 68-23 of July 24, 1968), Tunisia, WIPO Lex)
📄 Civil Procedure: Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures
1. Types of Evidence
The Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures recognizes various forms of evidence, including documents, witness testimony, expert reports, and physical evidence. Parties are required to present their evidence in a timely manner to ensure its admissibility . (Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures (promulgated by Law No.130 of October 5, 1959, and amended up to Law No. 2010-36 of July 5, 2010), Tunisia, WIPO Lex)
2. Role of Experts
Experts play a crucial role in civil proceedings, providing specialized knowledge to assist the court. Article 113, amended by Law No. 2010-36, outlines the procedures for expert appointments, the determination of fees, and the submission of expert reports . (Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures (promulgated by Law No.130 of October 5, 1959, and amended up to Law No. 2010-36 of July 5, 2010), Tunisia, WIPO Lex)
3. Documentary Evidence
Documents are admissible as evidence if they are presented in their original form or as certified copies. The authenticity of documents must be established to ensure their reliability in court .
🧾 Additional Legal Considerations
1. Illegally Obtained Evidence
Evidence obtained through illegal means, such as unauthorized searches or seizures, is generally inadmissible in Tunisian courts. This principle upholds the integrity of the judicial process and protects individuals' rights .
2. Appeal Process
Decisions made by trial courts can be appealed to higher courts, such as the Court of Appeal or the Court of Cassation. These appellate courts review the application of law and the admissibility of evidence to ensure that justice is served .
Tunisia's legal system emphasizes the importance of lawful and fair procedures in the handling of evidence. The prohibition of coerced confessions, the requirement for transparency in trials, and the recognition of various forms of evidence collectively contribute to a judicial process that seeks to uphold justice and protect individual rights.
RELATED Blog
0 comments