Supreme Court Eswatini
The Supreme Court of Eswatini (formerly known as Swaziland) is the highest court in the kingdom and serves as the final court of appeal in the country. The Supreme Court is responsible for interpreting and applying the law, ensuring that the Constitution is upheld, and providing final decisions on legal disputes.
Key Features of the Supreme Court of Eswatini:
Jurisdiction and Role:
- The Supreme Court has appellate jurisdiction, meaning it hears appeals from lower courts. These lower courts include the High Court and various specialized courts.
- It is the final court of appeal, meaning that its decisions cannot be appealed further, and its rulings are binding.
- The Court also has the authority to interpret the Constitution and ensure that laws and government actions comply with it.
Composition:
- The Supreme Court is composed of a Chief Justice and several other justices, known as judges of appeal.
- Judges are appointed by the King of Eswatini, who acts on the advice of the Prime Minister. The King has wide powers in the judicial appointment process, which has led to concerns about the independence of the judiciary.
- Judges of the Supreme Court are usually appointed from among senior judges of the High Court or legal professionals with significant experience.
Functions:
- Final Appellate Authority: The Supreme Court is the final authority on legal matters. Its decisions are binding on all other courts in Eswatini.
- Constitutional Interpretation: The Court plays an essential role in interpreting the Constitution of Eswatini and ensuring that all laws passed by Parliament are in compliance with the Constitution. It has the authority to invalidate laws that contradict the Constitution.
- Judicial Review: The Court can review government decisions, actions, and legislation to ensure they are lawful and constitutional. This includes ensuring that executive actions do not violate constitutional rights.
Judicial Independence:
- While the Supreme Court of Eswatini is supposed to be independent, concerns have been raised about the potential influence of the monarchy and the executive branch over judicial decisions. The King has the power to appoint and dismiss judges, which can impact the perceived impartiality of the judiciary.
- Reforms to improve judicial independence have been discussed, but the political context of Eswatini, with its absolute monarchy, presents challenges for a fully independent judiciary.
Court Structure:
- The Supreme Court is divided into several chambers, each responsible for different types of cases, such as civil, criminal, and constitutional cases. However, its primary function is to hear appeals from lower courts and settle disputes of national importance.
- The Court also includes a Constitutional Court, which deals specifically with issues related to the Constitution and the protection of individual rights.
Appointments and Terms:
- Judges of the Supreme Court are appointed by the King, often from a list provided by the Judicial Service Commission. These appointments are typically for fixed terms, but the King can reappoint judges.
- The Chief Justice is a highly influential position, and while there are term limits, reappointment can occur, which allows continuity in leadership within the judiciary.
Challenges and Criticism:
- Perceived Lack of Independence: The power of the King to appoint and remove judges has led to concerns about the independence of the judiciary, particularly in politically sensitive cases.
- Backlog of Cases: The Supreme Court, along with other courts in Eswatini, has faced challenges regarding case backlogs, leading to delays in the resolution of disputes.
- Human Rights Concerns: There have been concerns about the court's role in defending human rights, particularly in politically sensitive matters where the executive or monarchy may have interests.
Reforms:
- There have been discussions about reforming the judicial system to enhance independence and efficiency. This includes calls for changes to the judicial appointment process and measures to reduce delays in the handling of cases.
Conclusion:
The Supreme Court of Eswatini is an essential institution in the country’s legal system, serving as the final appellate body and playing a critical role in interpreting the Constitution. However, its independence has been questioned due to the extensive influence of the monarchy in judicial appointments. Efforts to reform the judicial system and enhance the independence of the judiciary continue to be a topic of discussion in Eswatini.
RELATED Blog
0 comments