Indemnity Clause in Contract
Indemnity Clause in Contracts
1. Meaning of Indemnity Clause
An indemnity clause is a contractual provision where one party agrees to compensate or reimburse the other party for losses, damages, or liabilities incurred due to certain specified events.
It is a form of risk allocation, where one party agrees to bear certain risks to protect the other from financial harm.
The party who promises to compensate is called the indemnifier, and the party protected is called the indemnity-holder or indemnity-holder.
2. Legal Definition of Contract of Indemnity (Indian Context)
Under Section 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract of indemnity is defined as:
"A contract by which one party promises to save the other from loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself, or by the conduct of any other person."
Essentially, the indemnifier agrees to protect the indemnity-holder from any loss or damage arising from certain acts.
3. Purpose and Scope
The indemnity clause is included in contracts to:
Allocate potential risks between parties.
Provide a remedy for loss without proving fault or negligence.
Encourage business confidence by managing liabilities.
4. Essential Elements of an Indemnity Clause
Promise to indemnify: One party must promise to compensate the other.
Loss or damage: The promise covers losses caused by specific acts or omissions.
Cause of loss: Loss may arise from the conduct of the indemnifier or a third party.
No fault requirement: The indemnity-holder need not prove negligence; mere loss suffices.
5. Types of Indemnity
Express Indemnity: Specifically written and agreed in the contract.
Implied Indemnity: Arises by law or circumstances, even if not expressly stated.
6. Legal Effect and Enforcement
When an indemnity clause is valid and enforceable:
The indemnifier must compensate the indemnity-holder for all losses specified in the clause.
The indemnity-holder can recover damages or losses directly from the indemnifier.
The indemnifier's liability is typically limited to the terms set in the clause.
7. Leading Case Laws
A. Cairns v. Modi (1879) ILR 6 Cal 142
This case established the principle that the indemnifier’s liability arises only when the indemnity-holder has actually suffered loss.
Mere risk or possibility of loss does not create a claim.
B. National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Boghara Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. AIR 2009 SC 244
The Supreme Court of India emphasized that indemnity clauses are strictly construed.
The indemnifier is liable only within the scope of the indemnity clause.
The indemnity clause must be clear and unambiguous to be enforced.
C. M/s United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M/s Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. (2008)
Reiterated that the indemnity clause protects against loss or damage as specifically mentioned.
Liability depends on the exact wording and intent of the parties.
8. Important Considerations
Scope of indemnity: Must be clearly defined to avoid disputes.
Loss suffered: Indemnity arises only after loss occurs.
Causation: Loss must be caused by the act or default covered under the indemnity clause.
Limitation: Clauses may include caps on liability or exclusions.
9. Practical Example of Indemnity Clause
"The Seller shall indemnify and hold harmless the Buyer from and against any and all claims, damages, liabilities, costs, and expenses arising out of or resulting from any breach of this agreement or any negligence on the part of the Seller."
10. Summary Table
| Aspect | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Definition | Promise to compensate for loss or damage |
| Legal Basis | Section 124, Indian Contract Act |
| Essential Elements | Promise, loss, cause, no fault needed |
| Liability Arises | Only after actual loss |
| Case Law Examples | Cairns v. Modi; National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Boghara Polyfab |
| Construction | Strict and clear interpretation |
11. Conclusion
An indemnity clause is a critical contractual tool to manage risk by shifting potential losses from one party to another. It provides security by ensuring that losses caused by specified events are compensated. However, the enforceability depends on the clarity of the clause and actual occurrence of loss.
RELATED Blog
0 comments